January 13, 2012

Shakeup in Calif. bad news for high-speed rail?

ARTICLE TOOLS


By  Alex Roman

In surprising news yesterday, California High-Speed Rail Authority CEO Roelof van Ark announced his departure, effective in February. The authority's chairman of the board, Thomas J. Umberg announced that he would also vacate his position and recommend that Dan Richard, who was recently appointed to the board by Gov. Jerry Brown, assume his leadership role.

The departure of van Ark and Umberg comes a week after an independent review panel issued a critique of the project and refused to recommend that the state issue billions in bonds to help fund the first leg of the 520-mile project in the Central Valley. Simultaneously, federal support of high-speed rail remains to also catch fire, which it has since President Obama and his Administration said that it would look at the technology as a way to both create jobs and prepare the nation for the future growth in population.

The shake-up coincided with Gov. Jerry Brown's plan to move the rail authority into a newly created transportation agency that includes the state's Department of Transportation, according to KNBC. Gov. Brown's decision to do so is said to be a signal to Feds that he still believes that project is viable. Likewise, the appointment of Dan Richard, a long-time Gov. Brown associate, is said to be a signal that the governor remains in full support of the project, according to the San Jose Mercury News.

Even with all that said, to say California's high-speed rail project is on tenuous ground would be an understatement. Do you think the so-called "California Bullet Train" will ever become a reality?

In case you missed it...

Read our METRO blog, "Perfomance management and the role of the simulator instructor," here.


Write a letter to the editor
deli.cio.us digg it stumble upon newsvine


  • Bill Hough[ January 13th, 2012 @ 11:53am ]

    It’s time to cancel the California high speed rail project and disband CHSRA. This is due to the ballooning project costs and continuing dishonesty on the part of the California High Speed Rail Authority. The latest revelation is that claims that high speed rail would create a million jobs have been proven false. The San Jose Mercury explains “The 1-million figure came from the project's technical studies. It actually was the number of "job years," a statistical term that counts years of work rather than actual jobs. One person working for five years adds up to five job years in this parlance.” The high speed rail project now being pushed by the Governor and the High Speed Rail Authority is not the same project that the voters approved in 2008. The Authority is guilty of pulling a “bait and switch” on taxpayers, who live in a state in deep denial of its financial problems.

  • Jan van Eck[ January 13th, 2012 @ 11:57am ]

    These are projects that only work if the bonds can be issued with an effective zero-interest coupon, and even then, the project has running-cost issues. With a $50 billion budget deficit, I just do not see how the math works out.

  • Frank[ January 13th, 2012 @ 1:30pm ]

    I am a Rail-fan, trust me. however, we are not in Europe, Japan, China, or even on the NE Coast. this Article is talking about CA. I am not totally sure that we can get people out of their cars, or even off airplanes for that manner. in fact. one wastes just as much time screwing around with Post 911 Airport Security (which must be done)., vs being on the Plane its self. and I fine that is the point. i.e. that the Eur-star Works from London to Paris. even with Edited Security. and so on. its still Downtown London to Downtown Paris. And to finish, the High-Speed would had been build over 3 earthquakes faults. What would it cost? would it be run by Amtrak?

  • Robert Schrecengost[ January 15th, 2012 @ 7:30am ]

    It's sad that as a society we don't place more value on HSR. We surely need to find alternatives to the auto only approach. To see the system really work you need to approach transportation as a total system, not just High Speed Rail as a stand alone. It really doesn't do any good to board a train in LA and arrive at San Diego an hour later if it is going to take another hour to find a bus/trolley, or whatever to reach your final destination. The systems that truly work in other countries are integrated systems that combine trains, buses, light rail, steamship lines, and air transportation using end to end schedules that are reasonable in price and easy to achieve the individuals total transportation needs. Lets do the research before we spend billions on HSR running through the least populated portion of the State going where?

E-NEWSLETTER

Receive the latest Metro E-Newsletters in your inbox!

Join the Metro E-Newsletters and receive the latest news in your e-mail inbox once a week. SIGN UP NOW!

View the latest eNews
Express Tuesday | Express Thursday | University Transit

Author Bio

Janna Starcic

Executive Editor

Janna is the Executive Editor of METRO Magazine.


Alex Roman

Managing Editor

Alex Roman is Managing Editor of Metro Magazine.


Nicole Schlosser

Senior Editor

Nicole Schlosser is Senior Editor for METRO Magazine.


Will Kempton

CEO, Orange County Transportation Authority

Will Kempton is the CEO of the Orange County Transportation Authority in California.


Louie Maiello

Louie Maiello, former director of training, New York City Transit Bus & Safety Division and 2003 NTI Fellow, is the current Transit SME at FAAC Inc.


Dan Reichard

Dan Reichard, a long-time member of the transit industry, was installed into APTA's Hall of Fame in 2006 and is an honorary member of APTA's Business Member Board of Governors.


Heather Redfern

Press Relations Officer, SEPTA

Heather Redfern is the press relations officer for the Philadelphia-based Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority.


Alan Wulkan

A long-time industry veteran, Wulkan is managing partner at InfraConsult LLC, which has four offices in Scottsdale, Ariz.; Honolulu; San Diego and Los Angeles.


White Papers

Hazard Analysis: The Practice of Using Cell Phones While Operating a Transit Vehicle Examining system safety principles, available information in the public domain, recent transit incidents and policies.

More white papers


STORE
METRO Magazine - June 2011

METRO Magazine
Here are the Highlight:
  • Top Rail Projects Top $83 Billion
  • Chicago Railcar Testing Reaches Home Stretch
  • Simulators for Driver Training
    And much more…
  •  
    DIGITAL EDITION

    The full contents of Metro Magazine on your computer! The digital edition is an exact replica of the print magazine with enhanced search, multimedia and hyperlink features. View the current issue