Will driverless buses be accepted sooner than driverless cars?

Posted on May 6, 2015 by Jim Holm - Also by this author

Driverless cars have been in the news for quite some time. Last September, I speculated in PC 360, an insurance trade magazine, that insurance premiums for autos could decrease by as much as 40% over the next five years as autonomous cars made travel much safer. I increased my estimate to a 75% decrease in insurance premiums by extending the timeline to 15 years. When I wrote those two articles, I remember thinking how much of a personal paradigm shift was needed to accept a driverless car as safe. Now, it appears that driverless buses are in the near future as well.

In the mid-1980s, I created a self-insurance pool for political subdivisions, including school districts. Our criteria for accepting drivers included periodic physicals and clean driving records. The loss control company I owned held driver clinics teaching proper techniques and stressing safety habits. Of course, the drivers had to carry the appropriate licenses. There is immense fiduciary responsibility placed on a bus driver.

I can still remember how personally violated I felt when one of our insured school bus drivers had an accident that resulted in a rollover. The driver tested having a blood alcohol content in excess of the then-legal limit of .15. Thankfully, no one was hurt too severely. The first person on the scene smelled alcohol on the driver’s breath and restrained him until the authorities arrived.

RELATED: 'Connected' Vehicle Testing Aims to Bolster Bus Safety

Given the option to replace that particular driver with a computer, I would have unequivocally opted for the driverless bus.

My example isn’t remotely fair, in that you’re six times less likely to become a fatality in a motorcoach accident than you are in a private passenger auto accident. Even so, we’re moving quickly, in some people’s opinions, to jeopardize this safety by placing buses in the hands of computers.

Just a few weeks ago, there was an article released entitled “Don't Expect to Ride in Driverless Buses Anytime Soon.” It offered as proof for its assertion that bus manufacturers in the United States aren’t investing money into developing autonomous vehicles.

That is an erroneous conclusion.

I live in the Minneapolis/St. Paul area, where we already have moved toward driverless buses. That same article points to the 10 buses, with lane assist systems, operating on our southeast metro area highways. This technology, also used in snowplows, will make steering corrections to help the driver keep the bus within narrow lanes. It also provides visual and sensory signals to the driver. This is a sign that driverless busses are within our grasp.

All we have to do to see the future is look to Europe. They’ve been running tests on actual streets with driverless buses. Their first realization was that integrating driverless buses with actual traffic was far less problematic than with driverless cars. Buses have fixed routes. They also found that driverless vehicles could operate in much denser traffic than vehicles driven by humans.

The Transport Minister of the United Kingdom recently claimed that 2015 could be the year for driverless buses stating they could provide “better and more frequent service.”

Testing of driverless shuttle buses began in the Greenwich borough of London in February of 2015. These shuttles carry a maximum of 10 people and attain speeds of only 13 mph. The shuttles are designed to travel pre-determined routes, but can also respond to pick-up requests from smart phones apps, like Uber.

Personally, I believe that driverless buses will be accepted sooner by the masses than driverless cars. People have become accustomed to unmanned mass transit at airports, making it a short leap to autonomous buses. In contrast, people have too much fun behind the wheel to willingly give up driving their personal vehicles.

The Phileas Project in the Netherlands has invested over one billion euros into a “guided bus.” Although there is an attendant driver, the buses can drive automatically. Phileas high-speed trams are in operation in the Netherlands, Turkey, South Korea, Israel and France.

Driverless buses are already in use within contained environments. Toyota is fast developing the driverless bus and has them in operation at a theme park on Awaji Island.

In addition to the actual road tests, driverless bus manufacturers are putting virtual buses through massive virtual tests using computer models.

There is no statistical proof of autonomous bus shortcomings, but I have a bias.

I grew up on a farm. Machines are brutally unforgiving. Many farmers have been harmed by accidents with supposedly safe farm machinery.

I hope the technology people care more about safety than profits. I hope they care enough to make sure these driverless buses are as safe as the drivers of today have made motorcoach travel. Moreover, I hope that the economic savings projected by the proponents of these vehicles isn’t false economy in that one horrific loss attributable to mechanical failure would wipe out the “expense” of a competent driver.

Jim Holm, president of The InterAgency/Insurance Partners, has been in the insurance industry for five decades.

 

View comments or post a comment on this story. (7 Comments)

More Transit Dispatches Blog Posts

November 7, 2017

‘Precarious’ Transit Workforce Needs Data, Research to Help Fill the Void

As experienced workers retire, the pool of people to hire away has dried up. In recent years, it has become clear that talent needs to be developed rather than poached.

October 31, 2017

Autonomous shuttles could end commuting woes

Public transit options haven't provided commuters with enough first-mile/last-mile solutions, but a driverless shuttle could be what wins drivers over.

October 31, 2017

7 Tips for Making, Saving Money for Your Transit Agency

If there’s one thing I’ve learned in thirty years about getting increased funding from your board, it’s that winners get investment. People want to invest in winners because they have already shown a propensity to get results with what they have.  

October 25, 2017

Practice is Key for Incident Response on Rail Systems

Working in subway tunnels is difficult under any circumstances and when you have to maneuver around an electrified third rail in an environment with less lighting, the task is even more daunting. Now imagine what it is like during an emergency...

September 20, 2017

The Transit Industry's Workforce Challenge is Still Real

Where are we today with the great anticipated retirement wave? It looks like it may finally be starting, if not fully underway. It seems at least a couple times each month we here of a transit CEO who is retiring, technical staff who are leaving, and the difficulty in filling maintenance and operations positions with skilled workers for those who have retired.

See More

Post a Comment

Post Comment

Comments (7)

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher

Automotive Fleet

The Car and truck fleet and leasing management magazine

Business Fleet

managing 10-50 company vehicles

Fleet Financials

Executive vehicle management

Government Fleet

managing public sector vehicles & equipment

TruckingInfo.com

THE COMMERCIAL TRUCK INDUSTRY’S MOST IN-DEPTH INFORMATION SOURCE

Work Truck Magazine

The number 1 resource for vocational truck fleets

Schoolbus Fleet

Serving school transportation professionals in the U.S. and Canada

LCT Magazine

Global Resource For Limousine and Bus Transportation

Please sign in or register to .    Close