How Cities Are Embracing Streetcars Once Again

Posted on March 22, 2017 by Rhonda Bell - Also by this author

Kansas City Streetcar  - Robert Hodnett
Kansas City Streetcar  - Robert Hodnett
The streetcar might seem like a transit method of the past, but look at some of the major metropolitan areas in the U.S. — Portland, Seattle, Salt Lake City, Tucson, Atlanta, Dallas, Washington D.C. and Orange County, Calif. — and it’s clear that cities are starting to embrace the streetcar once again. While it’s one cog in the wheel of a comprehensive transit system, streetcar systems can act as a boon for economic development, and a powerful tool for revitalizing sagging corridors and attracting the much-sought after talent of a young, hip workforce who choose to reduce, delay or completely forego car ownership.

Reincarnation of the Streetcar
The reincarnation of the streetcar began in the U.S. with the 2001 opening of the Portland Streetcar. This "second generation" system emulates, in many ways, the operational model of the original streetcars — drawing power from an overhead wire, sharing space with vehicles, and stopping every block or two — but uses a sleek, modern train with ADA-accessible, low-floor boarding. Often credited with being the catalyst for the development of the well-known Pearl District, the Portland Streetcar made this "old" transit mode new again.

Seattle Streetcar – Phil Klinkon
Seattle Streetcar – Phil Klinkon

The Seattle Streetcar followed in 2007, and after a six-year gap, Salt Lake City’s S Line in 2014. Since then, Tucson and Atlanta (2014), Dallas (2015), Washington D.C., Kansas City and Cincinnati (2016) have all opened modern streetcar systems, with more systems in the planning and development phases (Orange County, Calif. in 2020).

While many of these systems are too new to truly assess the pro/con balance of the modern streetcar, there is no denying they are bridging the rich history of these areas to modern community needs. 

History of the Streetcar
Streetcars in the U.S. trace their roots to the horse-drawn, omni-buses of the early 19th century — simple wagon- or trolley-like vehicles pulled along the often-muddy streets of the country’s larger cities. The first step towards modernization came when operators laid rails to reduce rolling resistance and increase speed, still keeping "hay burners" as the primary source of power until the mid-1800s. At that time, companies began experimenting with other methods of locomotion, such as cable cars, before finally transitioning to electric streetcars in the late 1800s and early 1900s.

The availability of cheap, reliable public transit opened a new era of urbanization, and made it possible for large numbers of workers to move from the often-crowded and unhealthy innercity to more affordable homes along the tree-lined streetcar routes extending from the city center. These early development patterns are still evident today, with clusters of shops and businesses alternating with homes along these linear pathways.

Tucson Streetcar - Phil Klinkon
Tucson Streetcar - Phil Klinkon

Streetcar ridership generally peaked in the 1920s, with 11,000 to 17,000 miles of streetcar tracks in cities from coast to coast. Although beginning to decline by the 1930s in some cities, streetcars served an important function during WWII, when resources such as gas and rubber were rationed or directed to the war effort. As the cloud of conflict lifted, however, the nation was hungry for new beginnings and fascinated with modernism. Cars were futuristic and sophisticated, and streetcars were seen as antiquated. Large-scale production of buses offered more flexibility in routing with less infrastructure investment, and a more comfortable ride.  

The rise of automobile and bus use, however, may have only hastened a disappearance that began years earlier when streetcar companies, virtually all privately owned and consolidated over the years into large single providers, struck deals with local jurisdictions that guaranteed transportation exclusivity, but fixed fares with no provision for increase. This left the financial burden of maintaining the roadways on which they ran to the owners, to the streetcar’s ultimate detriment.
By the mid-1950s, with the exception of a handful of "heritage" lines, streetcars had disappeared from almost all of the nation’s largest cities.

Future of the Streetcar
Modern streetcars are just one part of a city’s larger transportation system — a system that may include light rail, commuter rail, buses, and bike-share and car-share programs — and the optimal mix of modes will be different in each city to meet specific transit needs.

The streetcar is not only about economic development of an area or providing a different form of transportation; it’s an investment in community revitalization — rebranding the entire city as a place that prioritizes experimentation, quality of life and sense of place. The resurgence of the streetcar signals that cities are taking a big-picture view, investing in themselves and in a complex layering of systems that together define quality of life: moving people and enhancing the experience of moving.

Over the next several months, we’ll dive further into how streetcars are meeting the needs of modern cities, how the streetcar has evolved technologically (including sustainability best practices), and what the future has in store for streetcars from an urban design and development perspective.  

This article is co-authored by Rhonda Bell an Urban Design and Landscape Architecture Senior Associate with RNL and Phil Klinkon, AIA, NCARB Pacific Region Transit Director at RNL (www.rnldesign.com).

View comments or post a comment on this story. (7 Comments)

More Transit Dispatches Blog Posts

August 8, 2017

Caught on Tape: Transit Employees' ‘Heroic Acts’

For transit employees working with the public on a daily basis, no two shifts might be the same and each day can bring an opportunity to make a difference in the lives of the customers we serve. Often, the acts go unnoticed, but for two SEPTA employees, their special acts — both coming within hours of each other — were caught on video.

August 2, 2017

Understanding Streetcar Costs, Funding, Operations and Partnerships

On a per-mile, capital cost basis, streetcar systems typically cost more than bus systems, but less than light rail (LRT). One of the biggest contributors to this difference is right-of-way: streetcars and buses typically run within an existing roadway and thus require minimal property acquisition...

July 19, 2017

Reimagining the Public Transportation Rider Experience for the Digital Age

Transit systems move millions of people each day, getting us to where we need to go, influencing our moods, and shaping our collective stories. But, faced with fluctuating ridership, uncertain budgets, and the sky-high expectations of a digital savvy customer — open app, get car — how can centuries-old transit systems keep up?

July 12, 2017

The Case for Outcome-Based Procurement in Transit

Would you buy cash-handling services and dictate to the security firm what type of armored truck and cash counters to use? By the same logic, why would you buy an innovative transit product or platform and mandate how the vendor designs the technology? You likely would not — and why would you?

June 14, 2017

Why Investing in 'Half Measures' When Hiring Frontline Employees Will Bring Public Transit to Its Knees

The public transit industry faces a severe human resources crisis... we began to focus on the science behind identifying and hiring more resilient human beings up front, in order to make it easier to build resilience and preparedness with employees once they are onboard.

See More

Post a Comment

Post Comment

Comments (7)

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher

Automotive Fleet

The Car and truck fleet and leasing management magazine

Business Fleet

managing 10-50 company vehicles

Fleet Financials

Executive vehicle management

Government Fleet

managing public sector vehicles & equipment

TruckingInfo.com

THE COMMERCIAL TRUCK INDUSTRY’S MOST IN-DEPTH INFORMATION SOURCE

Work Truck Magazine

The number 1 resource for vocational truck fleets

Schoolbus Fleet

Serving school transportation professionals in the U.S. and Canada

LCT Magazine

Global Resource For Limousine and Bus Transportation

Please sign in or register to .    Close