Management & Operations

Insurance Crisis: How Much Longer?

Posted on January 1, 2004 by Jack Burkert

Bus operators, more acutely than most business enterprises, have felt the cold reality of the insurance industry’s business cycle. Today’s insurance buyer knows the woes of renewing a policy or replacing coverage with upward spiraling prices and a severe shortage of insurance providers. This combination, known as a hard market, means for bus operators fast-rising costs, and for insurers, a brief moment in time when pricing climbs high enough to erase the mistakes and losses incurred in policies past. We know the reality of today’s higher premium costs. Increases of 200% or more are not unusual, and the number of bus liability insurers has dwindled to a handful. How we got here While Sept. 11, 2001, is the date that resonates in the insurance world, this particular hard market started well before that traumatic day. Bus liability coverage premiums had fallen to levels not seen since 1984, the eve of the last insurance crisis. Inflation kept driving claims costs higher, but premiums ignored the numbers and kept heading south. At some point, one of the insurers seems to have blinked and said “No more.” That started the rush to the bus insurance exit door. Without question, the events of Sept. 11 crystallized the hard market tendency already at work in the insurance arena. Insurers, and their re-insurance partners, watched much of their net worth virtually evaporate in New York, Pennsylvania and Washington, D.C. In the face of such a financial blow, there was an immediate need to begin restoring that capital to insurance company bottom lines. Another less-understood problem was the creation of a shortage of companies offering coverage. When the financial strength of an insurer declines, premiums must be reduced to maintain a fiscally sound “risk-to-capital” ratio. Companies began dropping business lines, like bus liability, to reduce premiums, and thus maintain proper financial ratios. Overall, the effect was making coverage harder to find. What’s the future hold? Where does this leave us? We are well into the second year of this particular hard market, meaning that we should now be seeing two things: profitability returning to the insurance companies and signs of price stabilization. That is exactly where we seem to be. According to the trade publication Risk and Insurance Management, today’s insurance company profits are largely being used to pay for yesterdays “sins,” primarily under-pricing and poor risk selection. Correcting these errors is the primary force behind today’s hard market. The insurance industry saw improved results throughout 2003, with vastly improved profitability. According to various sources, price stabilization seems to have taken hold, and increases this year, where proposed, are predicted to remain in single-digit percentages. This plateau of pricing is the necessary next step in the insurance cycle. Prepare for a ‘soft’ market Crystal ball gazing is a tough vocation, but most prognosticators foretell of a return to the ‘soft’ market, with lower premiums and easier standards by 2005. For the individual insurance consumer, what are the next steps? Making your company more attractive to an underwriter begins with cutting your loss rate and increasing your compliance rate. Underwriters will look at your DOT violation history and your loss runs before quoting. They want details of your safety program efforts. Use a quality agent and prepare your application early. Communicate to the underwriter the quality your company and its drivers represents. And when necessary, confront loss history problems with details of the corrective actions you have taken. Jack Burkert is a bus industry consultant and former Lancer Insurance executive. He can be reached at [email protected].

View comments or post a comment on this story. (0 Comments)

More News

NorthEast Charter joins IMG network

The company joins IMG’s Cyr Bus Lines in serving the state of Maine and surrounding areas.

TriMet's GM McFarlane to retire

He led the expansion of TriMet’s light rail system, which has become a national model for integrating land use and transportation planning, policy and development.

Nashville mayor unveils $5.2 billion transportation plan

It includes 26 miles of Nashville’s first-ever light rail system, four rapid bus routes, a dramatic increase in the service and frequency of the bus system, and a strategy of service and infrastructure improvements.

RATP Dev North America adopts one brand

Rebranding of McDonald Transit and RDMT simplifies client interactions by immediately connecting clients to the parent company in North America.

MV Transportation names IT exec to CEO post

Kevin Jones joins MV from DXC Technology, a publicly traded IT services company, where he served as sr. VP and GM of the Americas region.

See More News

Post a Comment

Post Comment

Comments (0)

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher

Automotive Fleet

The Car and truck fleet and leasing management magazine

Business Fleet

managing 10-50 company vehicles

Fleet Financials

Executive vehicle management

Government Fleet

managing public sector vehicles & equipment


Work Truck Magazine

The number 1 resource for vocational truck fleets

Schoolbus Fleet

Serving school transportation professionals in the U.S. and Canada

LCT Magazine

Global Resource For Limousine and Bus Transportation

Please sign in or register to .    Close