Management & Operations

The Madrid syndrome

Posted on May 1, 2004 by Steve Hirano Editor/Associate Publisher

The March 11 train bombings in Madrid that caused the deaths of nearly 200 people dominated world headlines for several days and created widespread concern about renewed terror attacks. But the impact of the bombings on transit ridership in the United States will likely be negligible. In fact, 75% of respondents to our Web poll (at believe that the Madrid bombings will not have any effect on U.S. ridership. Although it’s too soon to tell, the actual ridership numbers will probably back this majority opinion. The question arises, however: Why aren’t people frightened off buses and trains after terrorist attacks? It’s not for a lack of attacks. Suicide bombers often target crowded buses in Israel. And those bombings aren’t ignored by the media. People all over the world understand that Israelis invoke a small, but very real risk every time they step on a bus. Why wheels keep rolling
Yet the buses keep running and people keep riding them. In fact, Israel is in the midst of significant expansion of its public transportation system, including extensive rail systems. The country understands that the importance of bus and rail to its long-term mobility overrides the short-term dilemma created by terrorists. But that still doesn’t explain why people in the U.S. do not avoid public transportation in the wake of terrorist attacks. There are two key reasons why this is so. First, the vast majority of people believe that horrible things only happen to other people. And 99.9999% of the time, they’re right. The odds, for example, that you’ll be struck by lightning are incredibly small, but an average of 90 people are killed by lightning in the U.S. each year. Do we live in fear of lightning? No. Do we live in fear of earthquakes? No, at least not outside California. Do we live in fear of terrorist attacks on buses and trains? No. The second reason is that most people have little choice about whether they’ll use public transportation. That is, they must risk the chance of a terrorist attack if they want to get to work or to their doctor’s appointment or to the social services agency. Terrorist threats aren’t even a consideration in their everyday lives. They have other, more pressing concerns. Imagine, however, that a fully loaded transit bus in New York City is struck by a suicide bomber with dozens of people killed. How would that affect bus and rail ridership in the United States? The consequences would be immediate and dramatic. Just as air travel declined sharply after the Sept. 11 attacks, bus and rail ridership would see a drop-off for several weeks or months. But people would come back. Public transportation is an essential part of everyday life in most communities. It does more than get people from Point A to Point B; it alleviates traffic congestion, reduces pollution and provides more than 400,000 jobs across the country. Taking the proper safeguards
What the public needs to know is government officials are doing their level best to thwart the efforts of terrorists, domestic or international. Programs such as the Federal Transit Administration’s Transit Watch, which is modeled after Neighborhood Watch, will help to soothe frayed nerves and upgrade security programs. For more information about Transit Watch, visit Transit systems also need further investment by the Transportation Security Administration, whether it’s for employee training, equipment upgrades or emergency response preparation. The lesson that we’ve learned from the Madrid bombings is that terrorists are not going to confine their attacks on buses or trains to the Middle East or other regions of unrest. The next attack could be in our own backyard. Are we doing everything we can to prevent it?

View comments or post a comment on this story. (0 Comments)

More News

Yoder appointed treasurer of Mid-Size Bus Manufacturers Assoc.

Kim Yoder is the national sales manager for ARBOC Specialty Vehicles LLC.

Denver RTD commuter rail campaign wins APTA AdWheel Grand Award

This campaign resulted in over 255 million multimedia impressions over a three-month period, drew 100,000 people to opening events and introduced the phrase "Train to the Plane" into the public lexicon.

Uber, Lyft reduces transit usage, increases vehicle miles, report finds

The author of the report, Regina Clewlow, said in a statement that although ridehailing is complementary to transit and helps reduce vehicle ownership, ridehailing services are facilitating a shift away from more sustainable modes of transportation.

Palm Tran Helps Transport Pets after Hurricane Irma

Palm Tran utilized four buses, included a 60-foot articulated bus, for transporting the pets. The effort involved multiple trips and took two days.

APTA GM Question of the Day: What are you doing to attract the next generation of talent to your agency?

METRO asked some of the top execs in the industry what they are doing to recruit the next generation of transportation leaders.

See More News

Post a Comment

Post Comment

Comments (0)

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher

Automotive Fleet

The Car and truck fleet and leasing management magazine

Business Fleet

managing 10-50 company vehicles

Fleet Financials

Executive vehicle management

Government Fleet

managing public sector vehicles & equipment


Work Truck Magazine

The number 1 resource for vocational truck fleets

Schoolbus Fleet

Serving school transportation professionals in the U.S. and Canada

LCT Magazine

Global Resource For Limousine and Bus Transportation

Please sign in or register to .    Close