METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Public transit sees increase in liability claim severity, study says

Study participants rank third-party liability as top risk facing the transit industry.

December 11, 2018
Public transit sees increase in liability claim severity, study says

Compared to other industries, the public transit sector faces some of the greatest exposure to the general public. Photo: SORTA

2 min to read


Compared to other industries, the public transit sector faces some of the greatest exposure to the general public. Photo: SORTA

Nationwide, public transit systems are seeing an increase in liability claim severity according to a new report. This inaugural Aon Public Transit Liability Benchmark Analysis, which examines ridership and operation claims for rail and bus transit agencies, was conducted in conjunction with the American Public Transportation Association.

“Compared to other industries, the public transit sector faces some of the greatest exposure to the general public. These concerns are boosting safety to the top of the priority list for many transit organizations.”

While public transit liability claim severity is up 4% annually, claim frequency showed an increase of only .5% annually. The report breaks down the data, finding that the frequency of bus claims is higher than that of rail claims, while the severity of rail claims is higher than that of bus claims. This is due in part to the fact that buses interact with pedestrians and other road traffic, leaving greater potential for incidents leading to liability claims. The study also found that vehicle-on-pedestrian claims account for 3% of claims, but nearly 40% of incurred loss dollars.

Ad Loading...

“Compared to other industries, the public transit sector faces some of the greatest exposure to the general public. These concerns are boosting safety to the top of the priority list for many transit organizations,” said Otis Tolbert, rail and transit practice leader for Aon Risk Solutions.

Other statistics from the analysis include:

  •     The forecasted 2016 accident year frequency for bus and rail operations combined is .34% per 1,000 riders, or one occurrence per 295,879 riders.

  •     The forecasted 2016 accident year loss rate for bus and rail operations combined is $39.17 per 1,000 riders, or 3.9 cents per rider.

  •     Approximately 72% of the claims arose from automobile accidents, with 91% of those claims stemming from vehicle on vehicle accidents. Of the claims that did not arise from automobile accidents, approximately 32% arose from passengers falling.


More Management

A Community Transit Swift Articulated Bus
Busby StaffApril 23, 2026

City of Everett, Community Transit Advance Transit Consolidation Effort

In the coming months, the parties will develop an interlocal agreement for the city’s annexation into Community Transit’s district. The proposal will be considered by the Everett City Council and the Community Transit board this fall, said officials.

Read More →
A Chicago Transit Authority 7000-series railcar at a snowy station.
Managementby StaffApril 23, 2026

CTA To Upgrade 28 Stations, 14 Bus Turnarounds Under Expanded Improvement Program

A $6.5 million investment will bring station improvements, rider-friendly features, and workforce opportunities as CTA prioritizes safer, more welcoming transit spaces.

Read More →
Diane Cowin, AECOM’s transit market leader for the Americas.
Managementby Alex RomanApril 22, 2026

From Collaboration to Innovation: Diane Cowin on What’s Next for Transit

In this Consultant Roundtable, AECOM’s transit market leader for the Americas discusses how agencies can align teams, manage complexity, and prepare for the next generation of transit infrastructure and service delivery.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A blue and white graphic with text reading "New Bill to Strengthen America's Transit Workforce."
Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 22, 2026

New Bill Aims to Strengthen America’s Transit Workforce

Legislation would expand funding for training, apprenticeships, and workforce development as agencies face staffing shortages and evolving technology demands.

Read More →
Nashville SC mascot poses in front of a purple WeGo Transit bus.
Managementby Elora HaynesApril 22, 2026

Transit Takes Sports Fans Where They Want To Go

In this photo gallery, see how transit agencies and sports teams collaborate to move fans efficiently and enhance the game day experience.

Read More →
An Amtrak Acela train at New York Penn Station
Managementby StaffApril 21, 2026

USDOT Announces $6.7B for Northeast Corridor, Nationwide Rail Upgrades

Under Secretary Duffy, the grant program’s revamped criteria will prioritize safety; the American family; and workforce development, job quality, and wealth creation, according to a press release.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A group of people pose for a picture outside.
Managementby Staff and News ReportsApril 20, 2026

WeGo Journey Pass Enrollment Reached 10,000 in April

Nashville’s fare-free, income-based transit pilot hits a major milestone, expanding access and reshaping daily mobility for thousands of riders.

Read More →
A photo of a San Antonio VIA Metropolitan Transit zero-emission bus.
Busby Staff and News ReportsApril 20, 2026

Recovery and Risk Define the Transit Bus Market in 2025

A 5% rise in deliveries and a surge in zero-emission buses signaled progress in 2025, but high costs, long lead times, and shifting funding priorities continue to cloud the outlook.

Read More →
People Movement for April, 17, 2026
Managementby StaffApril 17, 2026

People Movement: New NTSB Vice Chair, HDR, and More

METRO’s People Movement highlights the latest leadership changes, promotions, and personnel news across the public transit, motorcoach, and people mobility sectors.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A picture of a San Diego MTS railcar and bus at a transit station.
Managementby StaffApril 17, 2026

San Diego Transit Agencies Propose Fare Hike to Close Budget Gaps

The agencies, San Diego MTS and NCTD - San Diego Railroad, which share a fare system (PRONTO), proposed the changes to help address their respective financial sustainability strategies.

Read More →