Brief stay granted after action denied for Charter Service Rule
Appellate court granted an administrative stay Tuesday evening until July 8, 2010, which allows legal counsel adequate time to prepare arguments.
The United Motorcoach Association (UMA) issued an update on the legislative provision authored by Senator Patty Murray, which was ruled unconstitutional. The legislation blocked the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) from enforcing the Charter Service Rule concerning Seattle's King County Metro Transit. The FTA was directed to administer the Charter Service Rule immediately.
After internal deliberations, the Department of Justice on behalf of the FTA filed a request for a stay while the case was appealed. Oral arguments were made on behalf of UMA members by legal counsel Dan Mastromarco. The stay was denied.
Within hours, the Department of Justice filed an appeal with the appellate court challenging the lower court's decision denying the stay.
It is important to note that King County Metro stated publicly their charter service contract with the Seattle Mariners would cease by June 30, 2010 if no stay was entered. The government argued that the Court enter an immediate administrative stay of the district court's order, pending the Court's resolution of this motion.
The appellate court granted an administrative stay Tuesday evening until July 8, 2010; which allows legal counsel adequate time to prepare arguments.
"Certainly we are disappointed in the Court's decision for a brief administrative stay," stated Vic Parra, president/CEO of UMA. "However, we are confident our arguments are sound and the lower court's decision will prevail."
Meanwhile, in a statement released in response to the lower court's ruling, Murray vowed to continue to fight for a change in the rule that "forces local fans and event goers to use overpriced and inefficient private charter buses." She said her amendment to the appropriations act was drafted in response to fans' complaints about private charter operators.
"It's clear the government is overreaching here," comments Ken Presley, vice president of industry relations. "It is imperative that our members know the position of their Congressional and Senate Representatives, make their wishes known, and vote accordingly. Senator Murray did not pass this legislation alone."
More Motorcoach

Reinventing Fleet Maintenance with Real-time Visibility and AI
Transit leaders need to know what needs fixing, where to look, who is responsible, when work is completed, and what it costs without having to chase information across disconnected systems.
Read More →
ABA's Ferguson Testifies in Support of BUS Act, National Standards for Bus Operators
The BUSES Act would create a nationwide framework preventing state and local governments from enforcing bus idling restrictions of less than 15 minutes, a threshold consistent with existing Environmental Protection Agency guidance.
Read More →A True Low-Floor Minibus Design Delivers Better Accessibility and Efficiency for Everyone
As transit demands evolve, so should your fleet. Download the whitepaper to see how the Low-Floor Frontrunner Minibus compares to traditional options.
Read More →2026 METRO Buyer’s Guide & Directory
Searching for the right vehicles, technology, equipment, or services for your public transit or motorcoach operation? This industry guide brings together manufacturers and suppliers from across the transportation market — all in one place. Download it to connect with the companies that help agencies and operators improve mobility, enhance operations, and move their organizations forward.
Read More →
ABA Foundation’s 2025 Motorcoach Census Highlights Industry Growth, 77K Jobs
Conducted annually by Tourism Economics, the study found that 1,769 companies operating 49,543 motorcoaches are based in the US, while 122 companies operating 1,425 motorcoaches are located in Canada.
Read More →
ENC Lands Additional 10-Bus Order From Academy Bus
The latest purchase brings Academy Bus’ AXESS fleet orders to 35 vehicles as ENC continues expanding its heavy-duty transit lineup.
Read More →
American Bus Association Files Lawsuit Against NYC Over Bus Idling Rules
The lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, challenges the City’s use of its Citizens Air Complaint program.
Read More →
Avoiding Mid-Season Breakdowns: A Fleet Readiness Q&A
John Hatman, COO of Master’s Transportation, breaks down the priorities, warning signs and common mistakes fleet managers should address now to stay ahead of summer demand.
Read More →
ABA Report: Motorcoach Sales Tick Up in Q1 2026 as Market Stabilizes
The Foundation produces the report each quarter, using data collected from surveys of major motorcoach manufacturers that sell vehicles in the US and Canada.
Read More →
How the Motorcoach Industry Supports Disaster Response and National Preparedness
Fred Ferguson, president and CEO of the American Bus Association (ABA), discussed how the industry prepares for emergencies, the growing recognition of motorcoaches as critical infrastructure, and steps operators can take to strengthen disaster readiness.
Read More →