Rail

Proposed Buy America changes miss the real solution

Posted on September 9, 2010 by Frank Di Giacomo, Publisher

A new law recently introduced by California Congressman John Garamendi (D-Sacramento) would toughen existing Buy America rules governing public transportation procurements. While on the face of it the proposal sounds like a great idea, the changes miss the real solution to building the U.S. transit supply side and could worsen American companies' ability to compete overseas.

Waiver elimination

 "Buses, Rail Cars, Ferryboats: Make it in America Act of 2010 (H.R. 5791)" is one of three bills that Garamendi introduced on the same day this past July. This bill would eliminate all but one of the waivers to the Buy America requirement for rolling stock. Current law allows agencies and manufacturers to request a waiver for non-availability of the components or systems in the U.S., use of microprocessors and other reasons that the FTA deems in the public interest.

Under Garamendi's bill, if passed, transit agencies would be allowed a waiver for one remaining reason: if procurement from a domestic supplier increases costs by 25 percent or more. His other bills would encourage purchases of domestically produced alternative energy technologies and close loopholes that he and others say encourage the shifting of jobs overseas.

"Middle class wages in America have stagnated for three decades, and our country's future success depends on bringing back good manufacturing jobs," Garamendi says.

Tougher rules

All this is well intentioned, and there is certainly some merit in wanting to see the rules for waivers tightened. However, the FTA has not exactly been overwhelmed with waiver requests in the past two years, with almost half of them being denied anyway.

Any overtly tougher Buy America rules would probably cause some retaliation by other countries. Many were already complaining when some wanted tougher requirements in the 2009 stimulus bill, and threatened to do the same for their industries in their own stimulus packages.

The real solution to growing the supply side is to pass the main recommendations of the Apollo Alliance's reports issued on the bus and rail industries. In addition to some research and technical assistance, the Alliance strongly urges Congress and the president to pass a full authorization bill with the funding guarantees as in the past. I strongly agree. The real threat to our domestic industries and the jobs they create is the lack of orders.

 

View comments or post a comment on this story. (0 Comments)

More News

Hyperloop to build full-scale track next year

The Quay Valley, Calif. Hyperloop track will be built using HTT’s tube, capsule and station models. It will be instrumental in optimizing passenger system needs — such as loading, departure and safety considerations — to ensure Hyperloop is ready for larger-scale operation.

Keolis/MBTA make strides with commuter rail snowstorm recovery

Milestones include the completion of snow and ice removal from all platforms and critical rail switches system-wide, as well as the addition of supplemental trains, doubledecker and standard passenger cars to increase capacity and combat overcrowding.

Alstom to deliver to Sydney Citadis X05

Company is responsible for the integrated tramway system, which includes the design, delivery and commissioning of 30 coupled Citadis X05 trams; power supply equipment, including APS -ground power supply; signaling systems, the energy recovery system HESOP, depot equipment and maintenance.

Ann Arbor transit official urged MDOT not to lease railcars

In 2009, more than a year before MDOT signed a contract to lease and refurbish the double-decker railcars, which since have cost the state about $12 million, an Ann Arbor transit official told MDOT the cars were not suitable for proposed commuter rail services because they didn't meet federal requirements.

Hitachi purchases manufacturer of Honolulu's rail system

Finmeccanica owns all of AnsaldoBreda, which is unprofitable, and 40% of Ansaldo STS, which is profitable, according to the report. The two Ansaldo companies formed a joint venture, Ansaldo Honolulu JV, to design and build the 20-mile, 21-station elevated train system for Oahu under a $1.4 billion contract.

See More News

Post a Comment

Post Comment

Comments (0)

Please sign in or register to .    Close