METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

NTSB puzzled by SUV involved in Metro-North crash

The force of the crash was so severe that the electrified third rail broke off and pierced the vehicle's chassis and gas tank before penetrating the first train car and igniting a "fierce fire," investigators said Wednesday.

February 5, 2015
NTSB puzzled by SUV involved in Metro-North crash

NTSB Member Sumwalt and investigative team discuss details of the Metro North crash. NTSB

1 min to read


NTSB Member Sumwalt and investigative team discuss details of the Metro North crash. NTSB

VALHALLAH, N.Y. — The force of the fatal crash between a Metro-North commuter train going nearly 60 mph and a stopped SUV was so severe that the electrified third rail broke off and pierced the vehicle's chassis and gas tank before penetrating the first train car and igniting a "fierce fire," investigators said Wednesday, Newsday reported.

Six people died in the crash Tuesday night along the Harlem Line in the Westchester community of Valhalla. The train thrust into the vehicle's side and pushed it along the tracks for up to 1,000 feet, said National Transportation Safety Board officials Wednesday, the report said.

What is most puzzling to investigators at the scene is why the SUV was on the grade crossing as the warning gate lowered and slammed it on the rear — seconds before impact, according to the report.

"For reasons that are not precisely known at this time, for whatever reason, the Mercedes SUV was stopped on the tracks," Sumwalt said at a news conference.

NTSB recorder specialist George Haralampopoulos search for event recorder in the Metro North train.NTSB


In coming days, the NTSB team will interview the conductor and engineer, and analyze the crash from every possible angle, Sumwalt said.

Ad Loading...

Train involved in Valhalla, N Y, Metro-North accident at maintenance facility to be further examined. NTSB

For the full s

Board Member Robert Sumwalt views damaged rail car involved in Metro North train accident. NTSB

tory, c  lick here.

More Security and Safety

LADOT Launches Bus-Mounted Camera Enforcement
Security and Safety•by Alex Roman•October 29, 2026

LADOT to Launch Bus-Mounted Camera Enforcement on DASH Buses

The program will begin with a 60-day warning period before citations are issued in January 2027, joining similar efforts across Southern California to improve bus reliability, safety, and accessibility.

Read More →
An A line MTA subway car near the soon to be replaced signaling system.
Rail•by Staff and News Reports•October 23, 2026

New York MTA Launches Historic $1.9B Signal, Track Modernization Project

Funded in part by congestion pricing revenue, the project will replace nearly century-old signals along the A and C lines in Brooklyn and Queens.

Read More →
New Standard Helps Transit Agencies Address Climate Risks
Security and Safety•by Alex Roman•October 19, 2026

CSA Group Releases Climate Resilience Standard for Transit, Passenger Rail

Developed with support from the Standards Council of Canada, CSA D700 guides assessing climate-related risks and planning adaptation measures for transit and passenger rail systems.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A San Diego MTS Copper Line vehicle
Security and Safety•by Alex Roman•October 16, 2026

San Diego MTS Approves New Fare Evasion Penalty Program

The new administrative process will move eligible violations out of the criminal court system, cap penalties at $125, and provide flexible payment options for riders.

Read More →

RTC of Southern Nevada Reports 29% Drop in Transit Operator Assaults

The agency credits expanded security measures, employee training, and technology investments for improvements in transit safety, while security officers have responded to 19 suspected overdoses since July.

Read More →
Help Shape the 2027 Public Transit Conference
Management•by Alex Roman•September 29, 2026

Public Transit Conference Returning to GFX in 2027, Call for Papers Now Open

The Call for Papers is now open, allowing transit agency professionals and industry experts to help shape the PTC educational program by submitting session ideas for consideration.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic showing the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C., with the headline “Safe Transit Act Proposes New Security Rules for Funding” and the METRO Magazine logo.
Security and Safety•by Elora Haynes•September 28, 2026

Safe Transit Act Proposes New Security Requirements for Federal Transit Funding

Proposed legislation would link federal transit dollars to safety measures while requiring security investments, onboard cameras, and new fare collection standards.

Read More →
Two MBTA railcars in station.

FTA Ends Direct Oversight of MBTA Safety Actions

The federal agency closed its remaining special directive to the Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities following a safety review that began in 2022.

Read More →
Transit Leaders Gather for National Safety Summit
Security and Safety•by Alex Roman•September 16, 2026

Transit Agencies Highlight Safety Gains at National Summit

Leaders from 15 major transit systems shared crime-reduction results and safety initiatives while discussing the role of continued federal support.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
DART's light rail station at 8th and Corinth
Security and Safety•by Alex Roman•September 10, 2026

DART Launches Major Security, Fare Enforcement Initiative

The 90-day demonstration will deploy coordinated security teams at five light rail stations while testing controlled access and gathering data to guide future investments.

Read More →