Bus

Publisher's Perspective: Managing the LRT vs. BRT discussion

Posted on April 13, 2017 by James Blue - Also by this author

James Blue, General Manager
James Blue, General Manager
james.blue@bobit.com
The list of bus rapid transit (BRT) projects in North America continues to grow. The most commonly cited reasons for growth, include cost-effectiveness, implementation speed, and a wide flexibility of applications. One that I hear less and less, though, is this one: “We really wanted light rail [LRT], but we can’t afford it, so we settled for BRT.” That’s because our editorial team is discovering that there are much better answers to the “BRT or LRT” question.

More than a corridor solution

Put simply, BRT is growing in popularity because it is well suited to the variety of public transportation needs that cities face. Need a solution that supports both economic growth and better quality bus services? That’s what BRT projects in Fresno, Calif.; Pittsburgh; and Providence, R.I. hope to accomplish. Need good feeder service to your rail network, or service that helps to fill it in? That’s what many of Salt Lake City’s and Phoenix’s BRT projects aim to do. Need a fast, frequent commuter service that is retrofit into highway corridors? That’s what L.A.’s Silver Line and Denver’s Flatiron Flyer do.

It would also be nice if BRT could adopt a much more flexible, network-based approach that cities outside the U.S. typically take, such as in Brisbane, Australia or in cities in Colombia, where multiple routes and operators share some BRT infrastructure, but serve many more points in a sprawling metropolitan region. Unfortunately, our federal funding process bases decisions more on corridors being served, rather than on a network as a whole. Perhaps Hartford’s new CT FasTrak might open the feds’ minds a little.

“What we don’t want to do is re-litigate a phony BRT vs. LRT fight with which anti-transit critics want to divide our community.”

Moreover, some BRT projects are built to accommodate light rail as demand grows. This is the case in Waterloo and York, Ontario in Canada. It will soon be the case with L.A.’s Orange Line, which has been so successful that Angelinos this past fall voted to fund the building of more capacity that is needed in the corridor it serves by converting it to LRT.

Avoiding the BRT/LRT trap

What we don’t want to do is re-litigate a phony BRT vs. LRT fight with which anti-transit critics want to divide our community. There is plenty of room for both solutions, where each is appropriate for the specific circumstances. And these critics are showing their true colors anyway when they oppose good BRT projects like in Nashville. It showed us that, they don’t like any transit, not just service that runs on rails.

These are important points to keep in mind as arch-conservative anti-government types will use BRT to bash rail in the federal budget fights that just began as I write this. Do not play their false-choice games.

View comments or post a comment on this story. (0 Comments)

More News

ABC completes bus overhaul contract for OmniRide

The scope of work to be completed encompassed a full overhaul of 23 MCI D4500, model year 2008/2009 buses.

L.A. Metro retrofits CNG buses with new Cummins engines

The new ISLG and L9N Near Zero Emission Natural Gas Fueled Heavy Duty Engines will reduce emissions of NOx by 90% and greenhouse gases by 9%.

VIA's 'VIVA' routes hit 1 million passenger trips

More than 37 million visitors arrive in the Alamo City each year, many with destinations in the historic downtown area and the region’s cultural corridors.

Grande West introduces medium-duty version of its Vicinity bus

The company will begin marketing the Vicinity LT immediately for delivery in January 2020.

NJ TRANSIT graduates 500th bus operator as part of growth initiative

In 2018, NJ TRANSIT launched a major recruitment effort to fill the rosters of bus operators and locomotive engineers.

See More News

Post a Comment

Post Comment

Comments (0)

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher

Automotive Fleet

The Car and truck fleet and leasing management magazine

Business Fleet

managing 10-50 company vehicles

Fleet Financials

Executive vehicle management

Government Fleet

managing public sector vehicles & equipment

TruckingInfo.com

THE COMMERCIAL TRUCK INDUSTRY’S MOST IN-DEPTH INFORMATION SOURCE

Work Truck Magazine

The number 1 resource for vocational truck fleets

Schoolbus Fleet

Serving school transportation professionals in the U.S. and Canada

LCT Magazine

Global Resource For Limousine and Bus Transportation