Rail

Student studies pros, cons of Denver's P3 commuter rail partnership

Posted on January 9, 2017

RTD commuter rail line. Photo: University of Denver
RTD commuter rail line. Photo: University of Denver
When commuters first stepped aboard Denver Regional Transportation District's new commuter rail line between Denver International Airport and downtown’s Union Station last April, they probably weren’t aware of the groundbreaking nature of those 23 miles of track.

Not only did the project break ground literally, but the new line is part of the nation’s very first public-private partnership (P3) for commuter rail. Known as the Eagle P3, the project also includes the new B Line to Westminster and the G Line to Arvada scheduled to begin service in 2017.

For Sylvia Brady, a doctoral student in University of Denver’s Department of Geography and the Environment, the Eagle P3 serves as a case study for her dissertation. With Professor Andrew Goetz as her advisor, she’s assessing the project’s unique public-private aspect from both a financial and social perspective.

“One of my questions is whether the Eagle P3 could serve as a model for transit agencies in other locations,” Brady says. “What are the benefits and shortcomings of Denver’s approach?”

With population and traffic congestion growing in urban areas throughout the U.S., the demand for transportation infrastructure is increasing. Funding to expand and repair infrastructure has fallen, however, due to local revenue shortfalls, lack of federal funds and the economic crisis associated with the Great Recession. As a result, state and local agencies increasingly are turning to the private sector to fill funding gaps.

“Most of the research out there on P3s in the U.S. has focused on roads, bridges and tunnels,” Brady says. “We need more research on the emerging trend of using P3s for transit infrastructure.”

The Eagle P3 is a component of the Denver Regional Transportation District’s multibillion-dollar FasTracks program, the nation’s largest voter-approved mass transit expansion. Under the partnership, a private consortium called Denver Transit Partners holds a 34-year agreement with RTD that includes five years to design and build the three new lines followed by 29 years to operate and maintain them.

The main benefit of the partnership is that the private sector assumes some of the risks associated with the new lines, which reduces overall costs and expedites the project. According to Brady, the estimated cost of designing and constructing the lines was $300 million lower than if RTD had undertaken the project itself.

“With these savings, RTD has been able to open additional rail lines and build more infrastructure faster and cheaper,” she says.

She points out that while design and construction costs were less with the P3, the project’s long-term operational costs could ultimately end up costing more than if RTD had built the lines itself. The P3 does, however, offer cost certainty to RTD.

One disadvantage of the P3 approach is the complication that arises from formulating and navigating a public-private contract, which can increase exploratory and legal expenses. “In addition, the public sector cedes some control of the project to the private sector,” Brady explains. “Some people don't think that public assets should be privately managed.”

Brady’s work in public transportation grows out of her interest in sustainability. “My real passion for this comes from how more people can benefit from public transportation, and how it can help reduce pollution and increase sustainability,” she says. “Denver, in particular, is in a position where the city needs to balance growth with policies to help reduce negative impacts of that growth.”

When she finishes her dissertation, Brady plans to share her results with RTD. Her research methods have involved numerous interviews with project stakeholders.

“I've gotten a good look at the inner workings of public transport through this research and have been pleasantly surprised with how transparent everyone has been,” she says. “The project leaders have been excellent at sharing information with me.”

View comments or post a comment on this story. (0 Comments)

More News

Dallas' D2 subway reaches preliminary design milestone

The next phase is preparing a supplemental draft environment impact statement to access potential impacts and benefits of the project.

Bombardier temporarily ceases work at its Canadian facilities

The suspension includes Bombardier’s aircraft and rail production activities in the provinces of Quebec and Ontario.

Sound Transit completes downtown light rail service

The return follows the conclusion of Connect 2020, an 11-week period of major service impacts while construction crews connected the existing system in downtown Seattle to East Link.

FRA seeks to gauge performance, service of intercity passenger rail

The rule would define Amtrak on-time performance and would set forth a minimum on-time performance standard of 80%.

Calif.'s Metrolink lands $10.7M CRISI grant

The grant will partially fund the Burbank Corridor Speed and Safety Improvements Project, which will enhance service on Metrolink’s Ventura County and Antelope Valley lines.

See More News

Post a Comment

Post Comment

Comments (0)

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher

Automotive Fleet

The Car and truck fleet and leasing management magazine

Business Fleet

managing 10-50 company vehicles

Fleet Financials

Executive vehicle management

Government Fleet

managing public sector vehicles & equipment

TruckingInfo.com

THE COMMERCIAL TRUCK INDUSTRY’S MOST IN-DEPTH INFORMATION SOURCE

Work Truck Magazine

The number 1 resource for vocational truck fleets

Schoolbus Fleet

Serving school transportation professionals in the U.S. and Canada

LCT Magazine

Global Resource For Limousine and Bus Transportation