Bus

Could a Voice From the Hill Change the Charter Rule?

Posted on February 9, 2010 by Nicole Schlosser, Associate Editor - Also by this author

Page 1 of 2

[IMAGE]Charter.jpg[/IMAGE]Recent upset to the Charter Rule occurring in Washington State has left motorcoach industry experts wondering what the future holds for the law. On Dec. 16, Congress approved and the Obama Administration signed the Omnibus Appropriations Bill, which included a provision from Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.) to exempt King County Metro Transit from the Charter Rule, allowing the agency to take precedence over private transportation companies to provide shuttle service for the Seattle Seahawks, Seattle Mariners and University of Washington Huskies sporting events.

While the provision is strictly meant to apply to charter service for these sports teams, it could be extended to other area events, meaning that potentially the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) would be unable to enforce the Charter Rule against King County Metro on any charter work, taking business away from an increasing number of private operators.

While the bill is not a permanent provision of the law, and so far is only in effect for the current fiscal year, chances are that if the bill is renewed, the provision will stay put.

Clarifying communication

In 2008, clarifications were made to the Charter Rule, to enhance communication between public and private transportation and to make clearer which entity could take certain jobs. The Rule was also revised to add clarification on the appeal process, who to report to and penalties. The cornerstone of the original Charter Rule was a "willing and able" provision, meaning that if there was a private, willing operator who could provide the requested service and was able because they had the necessary equipment and met the requirements of the customer, then that operator had precedence over the public entity. It ensured that if there wasn't a private operator able or available, that the service would be done by a public agency, so the customer got service.

That intent did not change in the negotiated rulemaking. The revisions further clarified the "willing and able" provision and specified that the public entity could seize opportunities to showcase itself. "As a transit agency, if the mayor said '[there are] dignitaries coming to town, we want to be able to showcase our own service that we're paying for,' you weren't obligated to follow the willing and able rule and hire a private company when you had the service in your own backyard," explains Peter Pantuso, president, American Bus Association (ABA).

"[The clarifications] made the rule easier for everybody to understand: clearer definitions, clearer lines of who was responsible for what. Now those clear lines have been blurred, because you have a successful sports franchise that doesn't want to pay for service, and people buying tickets to go to a Seattle Seahawks football game, who are spending $100 or more a ticket, don't want to pay an extra couple of dollars for transportation," he adds.

Fostering teamwork

While they worked on the clarifications, the Rule brought the public and the private sectors of the transportation industry together to put a meaningful rule in place that clarified how to share information. Pantuso says that the provision could have a ripple effect on the industry. "It would be very easy for other senators and members of Congress to all of a sudden follow the same model [as Washington State] for an agency that they represent. It could very quickly end up turning the Charter Rule around to the point where it was worse than when the negotiated agreement took place," he adds.

Pantuso points to examples of public and private operators working together more effectively over the last year, likely as a result of the clarifications. "The private sector stepped up to the plate, and provided excellent service for golf tournaments, the Kentucky Derby and the Hollywood Bowl Concert Series - all of those were done in an environment where they wouldn't been done before by the private sector." Many operators worked to develop relationships with the local transit agency. "It's been more of a partnership in the last year-and-a-half than it ever had been in the past, and it's unfortunate to see it moving in a different direction now," Pantuso says.

Victor Parra, president, United Motorcoach Association (UMA), says that the exemption undermines the entire Charter Rule, creating a potentially dangerous precedent. "The whole Rule was [intended] to keep publicly funded transit out of work that has been the purview of the private sector. Given that the transits are subsidized by taxpayer dollars, there's no way we can compete. They offer the same service at a lesser price." He notes that while Sen. Murray said that she doesn't want any other jurisdictions or states to jump on board, that potentially could happen down the road.

Parra says that the Rule is valuable because it has promoted the need for the public and the private sector to work together at a time when deficits are climbing. He sees this teamwork as a way of reducing taxpayer expenditures and utilizing private sector resources to support the transportation needs of the community. "Government dollars, state and federal, are being squeezed," he adds. "This is a smart time to utilize private sector resources. Hopefully we'll see a lot more of that going forward. Instead of continuing to put out more money for publicly funded equipment, let's use private sector assets. They're there, they're paid for."

View comments or post a comment on this story. (0 Comments)

More News

Grande West receives orders for 9 Vicinity buses

Current total firm orders for 2017 and the first half of 2018 Vicinity deliveries are for 276 buses valued at over $74 million.

Gillig moves into upgraded HQ in Livermore, Calif.

The 127-year-old business, which operated out of Hayward for more than 80 years, will celebrate its grand opening on June 1.

Alexander Dennis begins Switzerland double-decker bus deliveries

The vehicles ordered for Eastern Switzerland are based on the company's Enviro500 standard model, but the company has adapted them to PostBus’s needs and Swiss regulations.

MCI delivers Commuter Coaches, J4500s to Texas, Canada

The first five Woodlands Township MCI Commuter Coaches were delivered in December of 2015, followed by 10 more coaches in March 2016, while Banff's Brewster Travel Canada has added 20 J4500s in 2016 and 2017.

ARBOC produces Spirit of Liberty buses for Fla. agency

Martin County intends to use these buses on their Commuter Service to Palm Beach County.

See More News

Post a Comment

Post Comment

Comments (0)

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher

Automotive Fleet

The Car and truck fleet and leasing management magazine

Business Fleet

managing 10-50 company vehicles

Fleet Financials

Executive vehicle management

Government Fleet

managing public sector vehicles & equipment

TruckingInfo.com

THE COMMERCIAL TRUCK INDUSTRY’S MOST IN-DEPTH INFORMATION SOURCE

Work Truck Magazine

The number 1 resource for vocational truck fleets

Schoolbus Fleet

Serving school transportation professionals in the U.S. and Canada

LCT Magazine

Global Resource For Limousine and Bus Transportation

Please sign in or register to .    Close