METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Why libertarians are wrong about federal transportation investment

The responsibility of government to enforce public rights of way and ensure a well functioning marketplace was not questioned in America's founding. One of President George Washington's first acts was to plan and design the National Road.

by Cliff Henke, Contributing Editor
February 9, 2011
3 min to read


Newly installed House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman John Mica (R-Fla.) wants to report a new surface transportation authorization bill out of his committee this coming spring. The question is whether it will be a two-year law or a full six-year authorization, because neither the administration nor enough members of Congress have the stomach to propose a tax increase to fully fund a bill. So, any gap in a six-year measure would have to be funded by general revenues, which, in turn, likely means deficit spending or finding cuts elsewhere. Yet, there may be a more fundamental, troubling reason: Mica's own leadership may not believe that the federal government should play much of a role in transportation infrastructure other than maintaining existing highways.

The ideological opposition to federal transit spending, even when the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the recent bipartisan commission on the deficit support gas tax increases to fund additional infrastructure investment, is deepening. It is often driven by those who fail to acknowledge the history of such spending. They deny even the nation's founders' beliefs about federal responsibility on this issue.

Ad Loading...

Assumptions ignore history

Many say, for example, that transit spending specifically — a few others even argue most forms of transportation investment — never was intended to be responsibilities of the federal government. They are wrong on a number of levels. Even from the time of Magna Carta, the national government, in those days, the crown, had an assumed right - some  even assert a responsibility — to enforce public rights of way, either through forcing adjacent land owners to maintain them themselves or by projects funded from the treasury. This traditional responsibility was later expanded as the British parliament assumed responsibilities for such infrastructure investments. Adam Smith, in his seminal work, The Wealth of Nations, published in 1776, viewed infrastructure as a responsibility of government to ensure a well functioning marketplace.

This tradition was not even questioned in America's founding. Possibly because of his own background as a land surveyor, one of President George Washington's first acts in his first term was planning and designing the National Road, linking coastal ports with the expanding interior along the Ohio River valley.

President Abraham Lincoln, through federal land grants, helped to fund development of the transcontinental railroads. In the 20th Century, two major federal highway programs helped to create the extensive network of U.S. roads that are the envy of the world. President Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal funded many public transportation investments. Indeed, many Republicans said they opposed the 2009 stimulus package, in part, because there was too little infrastructure spending in the bill.

Where are the grown-ups?

Ad Loading...

Where are those leaders now? Our infrastructure needs are no less acute. Virtually every other government in the world, including conservative ones, preserved infrastructure investment, despite austerity programs undertaken by many. The new British government is a noteworthy example.

There is plenty of room for disagreement over how this responsibility should be undertaken. To suggest, however, government, particularly the federal government, is not responsible for addressing challenges that have national, interstate and, now, even international importance, is either ignorant or disingenuous.

Cliff Henke, a contributing editor to METRO, is senior analyst at PB. His views herein are solely his own.

 

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Bus

Busby Alex RomanSeptember 11, 2026

New York MTA Plans Largest Bus Fleet Upgrade in More Than a Decade

The agency is seeking manufacturers for 650 new CNG buses to replace aging vehicles, improve reliability, and advance its broader fleet modernization strategy.

Read More →
How BAE Systems Electrifies Transit Fleets
Zero Emissionsby Alex RomanSeptember 10, 2026

Building a Flexible Path to Transit Electrification

John Hroncich discusses BAE Systems’ modular and scalable approach, lessons learned from decades of real-world operations, and how agencies can identify electrification strategies that fit their fleets.

Read More →
Bus Tech Talk: Transit Tech Training...What's Changed?
Busby Alex RomanSeptember 4, 2026

Bus Tech Talk: Keeping Transit Technicians Ahead of the Technology Curve

LA Metro’s Obed Mejia discusses technician training, evolving maintenance technology, fleet replacement, and strategies for getting the most out of today’s transit fleets.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
RIPTA, APTA, and federal officials at the launch of the agency's new Frontrunner vehicles
Technologyby Alex RomanSeptember 4, 2026

Biz Briefs: RIPTA Unveils New Frontrunners, Clevland RTA Adds New Siemens, and More

In METRO's latest installment, we take a look at recent news from Siemens, Prevost, Dodge, and more partnerships making headlines across the transportation sector.

Read More →
Holly Arnold
Managementby Alex RomanSeptember 2, 2026

People Movement: Holly Arnold Joins Transdev and More

In this edition, we also cover recent appointments and announcements at Pace, CamTran, MCI, and more, showcasing the individuals helping to shape the future of transportation.

Read More →
A man in a blue suit stands at a clear podium.
Busby Elora HaynesAugust 26, 2026

The High Cost of Transit Buses: Industry Leaders Look to Procurement Reform

Transit leaders and policymakers examine how standardized bus designs, streamlined procurement, and predictable funding could help agencies stretch budgets and deliver better service.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Ray Melleady and industry leaders on Capitol Hill
Managementby Alex RomanAugust 24, 2026

The Business Voice Behind Public Transportation

As chair of APTA’s Business Members Board of Governors, Ray Melleady explains how more than 850 business members are partnering with transit agencies to advance funding, innovation, and industry-wide collaboration.

Read More →
METROspectives: The Overlooked Issues Holding Bus Operators Back
Managementby Alex RomanAugust 21, 2026

From Surviving to Thriving: Building Stronger Transportation Organizations

Bus Business Consultants founder Brian Dickson shares lessons on leadership, organizational health, and creating options for long-term success in a changing transportation industry.

Read More →
Finding the Right Balance: Optimizing Transit Maintenance
ManagementAugust 14, 2026

Finding the ‘Happy Medium’: Optimizing Maintenance Without Sacrificing Reliability

The key to maintenance optimization isn’t doing less work—it’s doing the right work at the right time on the right assets.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
AI Powers Bus Lane Enforcement
Technologyby Alex RomanAugust 12, 2026

LA Metro, City of West Hollywood, and Partners Advance Smarter Bus Lane Enforcement

The award-winning partnership combines AI-powered detection with human oversight to improve bus reliability, accessibility, and enforcement efficiency.

Read More →