New research could potentially lead to turnstile-free mass transit
Ultra-wideband tech. could lead to better tracking of trains and buses, and potentially eliminate the need for turnstiles, tickets or cards.

Ultra-wideband tech. could lead to better tracking of trains and buses, and potentially eliminate the need for turnstiles, tickets or cards. Photo: University at Albany

Ultra-wideband tech. could lead to better tracking of trains and buses, and potentially eliminate the need for turnstiles, tickets or cards. Photo: University at Albany
Researchers with the University at Albany have taken the first steps toward possibly making turnstile-free subways a reality.
Led by Assistant Professor Hany Elgala, Ph.D., working with partners at the university's Parking and Mass Transit Services and Office of Facilities Management, the scientists studied the feasibility of applying ultra-wideband (UWB) technology to public transportation systems.
The group included those from: the Center for Technology in Government at the University at Albany (CTG at UAlbany) and the Signals & Networks Lab (SINE) within the College of Engineering and Applied Sciences.
Their methods and results are available in the recently published report, "Intelligent Transportation based UWB Positioning and Connectivity: A Proof of Concept for Improving Public Transportation."
"UWB is a wireless radio system that uses a small amount of energy for simultaneous ranging, location tracking, andtransmission of large amounts of data over a wide range of frequency bandwidths," explained G. Brian Burke, managing director of CTG at UAlbany in the report. "For public transportation, UWB could lead to better tracking of trains and buses, and potentially eliminate the need for turnstiles, tickets or cards to deposit money or swipe for payment."
"Based on the obtained results, more investigations are needed to study how the technology performs in more real-world scenario and associated conditions," Elgala said. "We believe that the UWB technology has much more to offer for metropolitan public transportation including train-to-wayside communication and obstacle detection in front of trains."
This technology, if successfully implemented, could be a boon for the millions of Americans who rely on buses, trains, and subways. In 2017 alone, the American Public Transportation Association reported 10.1 billion trips were taken on public transportation.
According to the report, the team wanted to see if UWB could hit specific levels of accuracy, consistency, and resiliency required by public transportation authorities to ensure service quality, effectiveness, and safety. Specifically, they wanted to test determining the location of a train or bus ("ranging") and to see if they could find a sensor within a "crowd" ("localization") which would be used to pay for rides without traditional turnstiles.
Working with their on-campus partners, and with commercially available ultra-wideband devices, the researchers ran tests in UAlbany's tunnels and on outdoor campus roadways to evaluate environmental and other effects on the systems. Their experiments measured reliability and precision.
For ranging, the scientists tracked a bus, between two UWB nodes about a tenth of a mile apart and in line-of-sight of each other. In that scenario, researchers could track a bus within about four inches of the vehicle's actual location. For non-line-of-sight situations, with two UWB nodes about 28 yards apart, the precision was within 20 inches.
Inside the tunnel, with six UWB nodes, scientists could locate a sensor within two inches of its actual location during localization testing.
"The best way to think of it," Burke said of the report, "is as if you had a payment card in your pocket, but just walked right onto a bus and were charged automatically, instead of stopping to swipe the payment card."
"These are just the early steps toward a turnstile-less world," said Burke. "There are levels of consistency and precision that need to be met, not to mention the policies needed to manage this kind of technology — but the impact could be felt by millions of Americans who rely on public transportation."
To learn more about UWB technology as it pertains to public transportation, visit https://www.ctg.albany.edu/projects/ultrawideband.
More Technology

STraffic Expands North American Presence with Fare Collection Technology
John Moon, Associate Director, Product Strategy at STraffic, discusses the company's growth in North America, its efforts to reduce fare evasion, and more.
Read More →
Laketran Cuts Fuel Costs, Boosts Efficiency with Propane-Powered Fleet
The Ohio transit agency is using propane-powered vehicles and on-site fueling infrastructure to cut fuel and maintenance costs while meeting growing demand for paratransit services.
Read More →
Right-Sizing Rural Transit: Lessons from North Grenville’s On-Demand Model
A small municipality shows how flexible service, rider needs, and public accountability can expand mobility with limited resources.
Read More →
Transit Expands Agency Partnerships, Reaching 200 Official App Partners
COO Jake Sion discusses Transit’s growth, the success of its Transit Royale program, and how technology is helping agencies improve the rider experience.
Read More →
Biz Briefs: Ballard, Solaris Partner, New Flyer Receives Florida Order, and More
In METRO's latest installment, we also take a look at recent news from New Flyer, STV, Spare, and more partnerships making headlines across the transportation sector.
Read More →
Hampton Jitney Microgrid Offers a Roadmap for Fleet Electrification
Sprocket Power’s on-site energy system is designed to manage charging costs, reduce pressure on the electric grid, and prepare the Long Island transportation provider for expanded electric fleet operations.
Read More →
ETA CEO John Maglio on Transit Technology, Innovation, and Building Agency Trust
ETA founder and CEO John Maglio explores the evolution of transit technology, the importance of reliable systems, and how stronger partnerships can help agencies improve operations and the passenger experience.
Read More →
Lextran, Via Team for On Demand, HDR to Work on Twin Cities BRT, and More
In METRO's latest installment, we also take a look at recent news from Keolis, Complete Coach Works, Anchor Transportation, and more partnerships making headlines across the transportation sector.
Read More →
Caltrain’s Electrification Drives a New Era of Ridership Growth
The railroad’s shift to electric service has brought more frequent trains, stronger customer satisfaction, and increased ridership, earning it APTA’s Outstanding Public Transportation System award.
Read More →
Video Surveillance in Public Transit: What Riders Really Think
As video surveillance gains public acceptance, new research from Axis Communications reveals what transit riders expect from agencies when it comes to safety, privacy, and AI.
Read More →