METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Study: Increasing competition among transportation modes could cut oil consumption

The report analyzed the specific effect on oil demand from telecommuting, bus rapid transit, transit competition, improved transportation technology, vouchers and other policies. The group also recommended implementation strategies to maximize oil savings.

December 14, 2010
Study: Increasing competition among transportation modes could cut oil consumption

A new report, released by newly formed coalition focusing on transportation reform, calls for an increased federal investment in transportation technology to save drivers time and money and increased transportation system efficiency and services. Photo courtesy Nashville Metropolitan Transit Authority.

3 min to read


[IMAGE]multimodal-Nashville-MTA-full-2.jpg[/IMAGE]By increasing competition among transportation modes, making transportation pricing transparent, and tying transportation spending to energy and economic performance, America could cut oil demand by as much as 779 million barrels a year by 2030, according to a study released by newly formed coalition focusing on transportation reform.

The analysis "Taking the Wheel: Achieving a Competitive Transportation Sector Through Mobility Choice," took the ideas put forth by the coalition's Mobility Choice Blueprint and ran them through a rigorous analysis to project their potential impact on oil demand. It details the benefits of 10 specific policy options that would level the playing field among transportation options.

Ad Loading...

The Mobility Choice Coalition, which includes the Institute for the Analysis of Global Security (IAGS), the Intelligent Transportation Society of America, the Natural Resources Defense Council and the American Bus Association (ABA), as well as 15 other organizations, came together around a fiscal conservative vision for transportation reform, which would reduce government waste and, by expanding competition among transportation modes, decrease the strategic importance of oil.

The report emphasizes having options means not only that people will have greater transportation choices, but also that the nation will have greater flexibility if confronted with oil price spikes or supply restrictions.

"Giving options allows the customer to weigh their decisions and make different choices, based on what meets his or her needs," said Peter J. Pantuso, president/CEO of the ABA. "It also, potentially, creates some competition in the market-place amongst the various modes of transportation."

The report's recommendations aim to reduce economic disruptions from oil spikes, cut wasteful government spending, and provide Americans with economical and convenient transportation options.

"The key takeaways from the report are that at a time of soaring deficits and crumbling infrastructure, it is critical to shift the way transportation infrastructure is funded in this country to a system grounded in basic economics," explained report co-author Anne Korin of the IAGS. "As long as users are not directly and fully paying for the infrastructure they use, be that highways, bridges, trains or buses, there will be a profound disconnect between what gets funded with taxpayer dollars as compared to what actually would meet demand."

Ad Loading...

The report analyzed the specific effect on oil demand from telecommuting, bus rapid transit, transit competition, improved transportation technology, vouchers and other policies. The group also recommended implementation strategies to maximize oil savings.

As an example, the report said government agencies can set a good example by encouraging telecommuting and a compressed workweek for its workforce. Barriers to telecommuting in state and local tax codes should be eliminated, and tax incentives can be provided for telecommuting infrastructure setup, Internet connectivity and maintenance costs similar to the tax-free benefits currently provided for other workplace transportation costs.

"It's also very important to consider load factor. Buses running empty or with very few passengers waste energy, not to mention hard earned taxpayer money, as compared to each of those passengers driving a car, so we should ensure that tax dollars are only going to lines that run mostly full," said Korin.

The report also calls for an increased federal investment in transportation technology to save drivers time and money and increased transportation system efficiency and services. The Coalition believes that with the new Congress about to take office, now is the right time to pay attention to "Taking the Wheel..."

"Transportation policy is a great place for policymakers to start a focused effort of government reform," Korin said. "Transparency, accurate pricing, more local rather than federal control of tax dollar allocation, spending tied to economic and energy metrics — all these are key to ensuring that when it comes for transportation infrastructure Americans get what they pay for and pay for what they get."

 

More Paratransit

MTA Advances Accessibility Improvements in Brooklyn
Paratransitby StaffJune 17, 2026

New York MTA Leverages Zoning Program to Advance Station Accessibility

Accessibility enhancements at Nevins St Station will be financed through a development agreement tied to the MTA's Zoning for Accessibility initiative.

Read More →
A maintenance person with a tablet.
ManagementJune 5, 2026

Reinventing Fleet Maintenance with Real-time Visibility and AI

Transit leaders need to know what needs fixing, where to look, who is responsible, when work is completed, and what it costs without having to chase information across disconnected systems.

Read More →
SamTrans planning for ballot measure
Managementby StaffJune 4, 2026

SamTrans Sets Priorities for Potential Connect Bay Area Revenue

The board-approved framework allocates future funding to maintaining service, rider improvements, equity initiatives, and infrastructure repairs.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Managementby StaffJune 1, 2026

Chicago's NITA Act Moves Into Next Phase as Service Improvements Begin

Rider-focused improvements will begin rolling out across the system immediately as CTA, Metra, and Pace increase service this summer in the six-county region.

Read More →
frontrunner bus image
SponsoredJune 1, 2026

Low-Floor vs. High-Floor Cutaway vs. Modified Van: How 3 Accessible Minibus Designs Compare

As transit demands evolve, so should your fleet. Download the whitepaper to see how the Low-Floor Frontrunner Minibus compares to traditional options.

Read More →
thumbnail for 2026 METRO Buyer’s Guide & Directory
SponsoredMay 27, 2026

2026 METRO Buyer’s Guide & Directory

Searching for the right vehicles, technology, equipment, or services for your public transit or motorcoach operation? This industry guide brings together manufacturers and suppliers from across the transportation market — all in one place. Download it to connect with the companies that help agencies and operators improve mobility, enhance operations, and move their organizations forward.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Emily DeVito and her children
Managementby Alex RomanMay 26, 2026

Rays the Mark Foundation to Honor CDTA’s Emily DeVito at October Fundraiser

Event at Chicago-area Ravisloe Country Club will support DeVito, a transit employee and mother of twins battling kidney failure and awaiting a transplant.

Read More →
A Heliox charger on KC Metro property

King County Test Heliox Chargers, Keolis Lands California Contract Top Biz Briefs

Stay informed with these quick takes on the projects and companies driving progress across the transportation landscape.

Read More →
Spare logo for Fixed Route Platform
Technologyby StaffMay 19, 2026

Spare Expands AI-Native Operations Platform With Fixed-Route Capabilities

The launch marks a major milestone in Spare’s vision for unified transit operations.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Trinity Metro On Demand Vehicle
Technologyby StaffMay 19, 2026

Via Announces Scheduling and Supply Studio

The Scheduling and Supply Studio provides the world’s first fully integrated platform for optimizing vehicle and driver availability to rider demand, said company officials.

Read More →