METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Public transportation's reckoning is coming soon

Cliff Henke, a contributing editor to METRO, is senior analyst at PB. His views herein are solely his own.

by Cliff Henke
May 18, 2011
3 min to read


As I have recently written in this space, the wave of changes in Congress, state legislatures and governors to a much more conservative content has already had a significant impact on federal and state public transportation policy, particularly in rail investments. Already in 2011, we have seen the Congress and President Obama agree to significant cuts to General Fund discretionary (i.e., non-Highway Trust Fund) transportation programs for the rest of the current fiscal year, and for transit, even the "guaranteed" money from the Mass Transit Account was frozen at last fiscal year's levels.

Most ominously, this bill provided no funding for high-speed rail in FY 2011 and cuts the Capital Investment Grant (New Starts) program by $400 million, with $280 million rescinded from the FY 2010 appropriation bill for New Starts. The president agreed to some of these cuts because of the projects that governors in Wisconsin, Florida and New Jersey recently killed. Yet another, in Ohio, will end state funding for Cincinnati's streetcar, which happens to be the highest-rated project in Gov. John Kasich's state, according to Ohio's bipartisan transportation commission.

Ad Loading...

They have only begun

These more conservative officials have only begun, however, and the next few months will likely be the most significant for the future of rail investments, perhaps in the next decade or even generation. How three interrelated issues are decided in the short term, all of them even possibly by the time you read this, will largely determine this outcome.

The first of these decision points is over raising the debt ceiling. While the chances of this happening are slim, the idea of flirting with default could make interest rates spike, not only for federal Treasury bills and bonds but also for other public and private sector debt tied to the benchmark federal rates. This could include local and state bond issues for any transit projects. If that happens, the budget will also have to be cut even further to make room for higher interest federal debt payments, putting even further pressure on lawmakers to cut discretionary spending, and, so far, public transportation has taken bigger hits than most other programs.

The second decision is how the president and congressional leaders will agree to cut the federal deficit. Although the recently enacted House budget — which would severely cut not only some of the most politically sacrosanct programs like Medicare and Social Security, but also transportation programs by as much as 30 percent over the next decade — is likely dead on arrival in the Senate, both that body and the White House must agree with the House leadership on something. What that "something" will be will shape federal transportation policy for a decade or more.

Deficit drives decisions

Ad Loading...

These negotiations will drive the final decision point — authorization. House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman John Mica will likely draft something that will be vastly smaller than President Obama's $550 billion proposal. The Senate will likely be somewhere in between — but any amount over Mica's would require more taxes. This is why everyone is watching what the "Gang of Six" Senators will do on the long-term deficit. They are starting with recommendations from the president's deficit commission, which included a gas tax increase for the deficit and infrastructure.

This is how the reckoning on the future of federal investment in public transportation will play out. It is unclear how this will go, but all who care need to weigh in, forcefully.

 

 

 

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Bus

Frontrunner's new facility in Billerica, Massachusetts.
Busby StaffJune 8, 2026

Frontrunner Bus Group Expands with New Massachusetts Headquarters

The significantly larger facility will provide the infrastructure needed to support the company’s growing workforce, advanced technologies, and expanding product line.

Read More →
New MobilityJune 5, 2026

Joshua Schank on Transportation Innovation, Risk, and the Future of Mobility

In this edition of METROspectives, Joshua Schank discusses lessons from launching LA Metro’s Office of Extraordinary Innovation, the challenges of advancing new mobility technologies, and much more.

Read More →
A maintenance person with a tablet.
ManagementJune 5, 2026

Reinventing Fleet Maintenance with Real-time Visibility and AI

Transit leaders need to know what needs fixing, where to look, who is responsible, when work is completed, and what it costs without having to chase information across disconnected systems.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
SamTrans planning for ballot measure
Managementby StaffJune 4, 2026

SamTrans Sets Priorities for Potential Connect Bay Area Revenue

The board-approved framework allocates future funding to maintaining service, rider improvements, equity initiatives, and infrastructure repairs.

Read More →
World Cup Crowds Will Test Transit Systems
ManagementJune 3, 2026

When Routine Fails: How Public Transit Must Adapt for the World Cup

The 2026 FIFA World Cup will test transit agencies’ ability to manage unpredictable travel patterns, making real-time data and operational flexibility critical to moving millions of visitors efficiently.

Read More →
Bus Roadeo at APTA Mobility 2026
Busby Staff and News ReportsJune 1, 2026

Photo Highlights from APTA's 2026 Mobility Conference

The photo gallery captures scenes from the conference, including the International Bus Roadeo, exhibit hall activities, the Bus Showcase, and much more.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Managementby StaffJune 1, 2026

Chicago's NITA Act Moves Into Next Phase as Service Improvements Begin

Rider-focused improvements will begin rolling out across the system immediately as CTA, Metra, and Pace increase service this summer in the six-county region.

Read More →
A SEPTA bus going down the road
Managementby StaffJune 1, 2026

Philadelphia's SEPTA Approves Annual Transit Service Plan

Between 2021 and 2024, SEPTA held more than 200 public meetings — including 144 in-person sessions — throughout the SEPTA service region.

Read More →
frontrunner bus image
SponsoredJune 1, 2026

A True Low-Floor Minibus Design Delivers Better Accessibility and Efficiency for Everyone

As transit demands evolve, so should your fleet. Download the whitepaper to see how the Low-Floor Frontrunner Minibus compares to traditional options.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A New Flyer 60-foot articulated bus
Busby StaffMay 29, 2026

WMATA Debuts 'Fares Pay for Service' Awareness Campaign

The campaign was highlighted during a media event at the Paul S. Sarbanes Transit Center in Silver Spring, where WMATA’s GM/CEO Randy Clarke joined Metro Transit Police officers, WMATA management team, board members, and staff to expand fare enforcement and customer education efforts on Metro Bus routes throughout the region.

Read More →