METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

A desire named streetcar

FTA Small Starts program favors quick-to-implement projects like streetcar service.

by Cliff Henke
March 1, 2006
3 min to read


The explosion in bus rapid transit (BRT) interest has somewhat obscured another, quieter renaissance. More than 100 cities in the U.S. are interested in streetcar projects, according to estimates by Jeff Boothe, founder of the Streetcar Coalition, a group that seeks funding for these projects. As much as or perhaps even more than BRT, streetcar interest is what drove Congress to create the Small Starts program in SAFETEA-LU. That bill authorized $800 million over the life of the program — $200 million for the next four years. (The Bush Administration, however, cut the amount for the first of those years in half in its recent FY 2007 budget proposal to Congress.) Crowded fiscal picture
Whether this program existed or not, smaller projects will likely be the norm in the coming years, simply because the demand for better public transit is outstripping the supply of funding at all levels of government. BRT and streetcars could become the modes of choice in this climate. Recently appointed Deputy FTA Administrator Sandra Bushue put it this way in her March testimony on Capitol Hill: “The [administration’s proposed] budget requests almost $1.5 billion for the New Starts program…The $1.5 billion fully funds the federal commitment included in 16 existing full funding grant agreements (FFGAs) with transit agencies. Funding also supports two FFGAs that we expect to sign before the end of FY 2006, one in Pittsburgh and one in New York City.” The FTA also announced in its recent annual report on the subject that five new projects have completed final design —“the New Starts finish line,” as Bushue called it — and are thus ready to receive grant agreements. FFGAs are the FTA’s commitment that a project will receive a specified amount of money — though not necessarily in the amounts and years that a project specifies. The Small Starts program was created to give smaller projects and systems a fighting chance in the very crowded game. A few years ago, former FTA Administrator Jenna Dorn pointed out that there was a $16 billion gap between what was being sought in the New Starts program and what she could afford — even at the record levels of funding authorized last summer. The fact of the matter is that transit has become a victim of its own success; its popularity throughout the country outweighs what the public sector can afford. Enter the Small Starts idea, which provides up to $75 million in federal funding for projects under $250 million in total cost. Although Bushue said that her agency wanted it “because it levels the playing field for medium and small communities,” it already stipulates that the federal share will be far less than even the current average of 50% in the larger New Starts program. The FTA explains that it only requested $100 million for next fiscal year because the regulations governing this new program will not be finalized until June 2007 at the earliest. Thus, smaller projects seeking less federal funding will favor lower-cost and faster-to-implement technologies — like streetcars and BRT. Why streetcars?
So why reintroduce an idea that is at least a century old again now? It is all about shaping development and urban form, say Boothe and others. Whether operated by volunteers using restored equipment as in Dallas or using more modern, off-the-shelf versions as in Portland, streetcars are quick to implement, cost less than light rail to operate, help create ambiance and thereby shape urban form and, most importantly, attract development. Because of the slowdown in the federal pipeline, look for communities to fund these with a package of nontraditional sources of investment — private and local government — rather than take a number and wait in line.

Topics:Management
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

A red, white, and blue graphic with the APTA logo and text reading "APTA Nominates 2026-2027 Chair & Vice Chair."
Managementby Staff and News ReportsSeptember 10, 2026

APTA 2026 Nominating Committee Selects Leadership Slate, Names Chair and Vice Chair Nominees

Leadership changes will help shape the association’s priorities and its representation of the transportation industry during the 2026–2027 term.

Read More →
DART's light rail station at 8th and Corinth
Security and Safetyby Alex RomanSeptember 10, 2026

DART Launches Major Security, Fare Enforcement Initiative

The 90-day demonstration will deploy coordinated security teams at five light rail stations while testing controlled access and gathering data to guide future investments.

Read More →
STraffic White Paper Cover Learn about delivering 1300 gates at 91 stations while managing fare evasion. Explore the large scale deployment, solution customization and real-world results that affect the region. Prepare for deployment in your region now.
SponsoredSeptember 9, 2026

Advancing Fare Collection Through Technology and Innovation

Learn about delivering 1300 gates at 91 stations while managing fare evasion. Explore the large scale deployment, solution customization and real-world results that affect the region. Prepare for deployment in your region now.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A TransLink train goes by a large FIFA World Cup soccer ball structure.
Managementby Elora HaynesSeptember 8, 2026

Game Day in Motion: Moving Millions During the 2026 World Cup

Between packed transit stations and team motorcoaches, see how agencies and operators across North America tackled the transportation demands of the 2026 FIFA World Cup.

Read More →
A blue and white graphic with text reading "Surface Transportation Averts Shutdown, Leaves Transit Funding Gap."
Managementby Elora HaynesSeptember 4, 2026

Surface Transportation Extension Averts Shutdown, Leaves Transit Funding Gap

The stopgap keeps federal transportation programs moving, but missing advance funding could complicate the transit and rail projects agencies are planning next.

Read More →
Bus Tech Talk: Transit Tech Training...What's Changed?
Busby Alex RomanSeptember 4, 2026

Bus Tech Talk: Keeping Transit Technicians Ahead of the Technology Curve

LA Metro’s Obed Mejia discusses technician training, evolving maintenance technology, fleet replacement, and strategies for getting the most out of today’s transit fleets.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Designing Stations Around the Passenger
RailSeptember 2, 2026

Why Simulating Pedestrian Movement Has Become Essential for Modern Rail Stations

Pedestrian microsimulation is helping rail planners identify bottlenecks, test station designs, and prepare complex transit hubs for growing passenger volumes.

Read More →
Holly Arnold
Managementby Alex RomanSeptember 2, 2026

People Movement: Holly Arnold Joins Transdev and More

In this edition, we also cover recent appointments and announcements at Pace, CamTran, MCI, and more, showcasing the individuals helping to shape the future of transportation.

Read More →
A Chicago rail and rail car in the city.
Managementby Staff and News ReportsSeptember 1, 2026

NITA Launches New Era of Regional Transit in Chicago

The new authority replaces the RTA and brings CTA, Metra, and Pace under a strengthened regional framework for funding, planning, fares, safety, and service coordination.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Canada-Qatar match fans underneath a TransLink SkyTrain overpass.
Managementby Elora HaynesSeptember 1, 2026

How World Cup Mobility Put Transit and Motorcoaches to the Test

Behind the seamless trips were months of planning, multimodal partnerships, and lessons agencies and operators can carry into the next mega-event.

Read More →