METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Economic, political climate spell chance for more public-private collaboration

The combination of what appears to be a strong outlook for public transit and the need for motorcoach operators to diversify should spell a unique opportunity for both segments of the public transport industry to work together.

by Frank Di Giacomo, Publisher
March 1, 2001
3 min to read


The combination of what appears to be a strong outlook for public transit and the need for motorcoach operators to diversify should spell a unique opportunity for both segments of the public transport industry to work together. Yet, if the two fail to work together as some modest experiments have shown that they can, they might turn into bitter rivals, which will help neither side. Two very important documents contributing to that situation were issued within weeks of each other last winter. The first was a gloomy report sponsored by the United Motorcoach Association, one of two primary industry groups for that segment. It concluded that the recent downturn in traditional motorcoach travel markets would continue for the foreseeable future. Importantly, it suggested that operators diversify by trying to serve the growing commuter market. The second document was released shortly thereafter. It is the Bush Administration’s Fiscal Year 2002 budget proposal which, if adopted (and it looks very likely), will spell very good news for the public transit segment. It suggests that spending will rise in the year beginning Oct. 1, 2001, by nearly half a billion dollars, to $6.7 billion. That’s 7% above the current fiscal year’s already record levels. When you consider the fact that federal spending only accounts for about half of all such expenditures, that means public transit could be buying nearly $13 billion in capital goods and services next year. One of the challenges that the transit segment is facing is showing those record investments quickly “get on the street” in the form of upgraded service. Make no mistake: The public is demanding such service, in part because they are voting for politicians and referenda at all levels of government to achieve these spending levels. It’s also due to the fact that congestion, air quality and other lifestyle issues are appearing higher on voters’ radar screens than ever before. This is where both traditional transit and motorcoach companies can help each other. Motorcoach operators know a thing or two about high-quality, cost-effective service. They emphasize great customer service, safety and sound maintenance, or they don’t stay in business too long, because they are competing not only with many other coach operators but airlines, Amtrak and the private auto as well as their traditional markets. Transit, by the same token, needs to show quality service quickly and it can use motorcoach operators as weapons in its growing arsenal. That can come in the form of service contracts on express runs, just as many transit agencies currently outsource those routes. Or it could come in the form of granting franchises to operate along certain routes or in and out of certain transfer facilities. Although a tried-and-true method of privatization in other nations, it’s not used as much in the U.S., and some institutional and legal obstacles might have to be hurdled in order to take advantage of that strategy in America. Then there are other arrangements, such as brokering tour and charter services (often booking agencies will call transit systems even though it is not a traditional market) and joint marketing for airport-to-downtown service. The point is that there are enormous opportunities for the two communities to work together. This magazine has long argued for better working relationships between transit and the motorcoach segment. I deliberately use “segment” rather than “industry” to describe the two because they both should be considered part of the same industry—public transportation. This philosophy actually underpinned federal policy since the enactment of the Urban Mass Transportation Act nearly four decades ago. Lawmakers chose the term “mass transportation” in that bill to include private operators. It also underpinned another landmark piece of legislation—the one passed in 1991 that has the word “intermodal” in it. It’s time to make that word mean something.

Topics:Management
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

Nadine S. Lee
Managementby StaffMarch 26, 2026

DART's President/CEO Announces Departure from Agency

Nadine S. Lee, who has served as president/CEO since July 2021, said the decision comes after careful reflection on the agency’s progress and its path forward.

Read More →
An NJ TRANSIT railcar at a station
Managementby StaffMarch 26, 2026

New Executive Order Targets Better Rider Experience on NJ TRANSIT

The Executive Order has two parts. Within 45 days from signing, the Commissioner of Transportation, in her capacity as Chair of the NJ TRANSIT board, will develop and send to the Governor a comprehensive plan to improve riders’ experiences. 

Read More →
A KCATA bus
Managementby StaffMarch 26, 2026

KCATA Taps KL2 Connects to Lead President/CEO Search

The KCATA board will remain actively engaged throughout the search process to ensure the selection of a highly qualified leader who will advance the agency’s commitment to serving the Kansas City region, the agency said.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Cover photo for Guiding Star mentorship program
Managementby StaffMarch 24, 2026

STAR Transit, ITLC Team Up on Workforce Mentorship Initiative

The Guiding Star Mentor Program connects experienced operators with new employees to support onboarding, retention, and long-term career growth.

Read More →
A TTC subway station.
Managementby News/Media ReleaseMarch 24, 2026

TTC Launches Five Research Projects to Drive Transit Innovation

In collaboration with Toronto Metropolitan University, five new projects aim to improve TTC operations, infrastructure, and rider experience.

Read More →
Denver RTD non-English speaking pins.
Managementby StaffMarch 23, 2026

RTD Launches Multilingual 'I Speak' Buttons, QR Decals to Expand Rider Language Access

RTD is distributing 1,500 buttons in Spanish, Amharic, French, Arabic, Oromo, Swahili, Italian, Nepali, German, Hindi, Farsi, and American Sign Language. Employees can volunteer to wear them on their shirts, hats, lanyards, or other visible items, in accordance with uniform standards. 

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Managementby StaffMarch 19, 2026

People Movement: The Latest from TARTA, STV, and More

METRO’s People Movement highlights the latest leadership changes, promotions, and personnel news across the public transit, motorcoach, and people mobility sectors.

Read More →
A BART railcar
Managementby StaffMarch 19, 2026

BART Monetizes Empty Parking With New Online Leasing Tool

BART began offering select parking lots to non-BART riders to generate new revenue to help address its FY27 $376M operating budget deficit brought on by remote work.

Read More →
MTA Chair & CEO Janno Lieber sits with a customer service employee and takes calls.
Managementby Elora HaynesMarch 19, 2026

Transit Agencies Nationwide Celebrate 2026 National Transit Employee Appreciation Day

Agencies across the U.S. honored transit workers on March 18, recognizing the essential roles they play in keeping communities moving daily.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Cover for METROspectives with Inez Evans Benson
ManagementMarch 18, 2026

Inez Evans-Benson on Leadership and the Future of Transportation

Drawing on decades of industry experience, Evans-Benson offered insights into the differences between the two, along with tips for better customer engagement and more.

Read More →