Fighting the odds
High-tech equipment isn't everything in transit security.
The odds of a terrorist attack on a passenger rail system in the U.S. are small . . . really, really small. That’s the good news. The bad news is that bus and rail operators must continuously bolster their defenses in preparation for an attack. They have to assume that the odds are much greater than they are.
To that end, some large transit systems are spending millions of dollars on high-technology security equipment such as chemical and biological weapons sensors. These types of investments are, of course, the exception.
In addition, spending millions of dollars on high-technology security equipment doesn’t ensure that terrorists will not be able to penetrate your system. What it does is reduce your vulnerability, probably by a small percentage. That means you’re going from a 0.0001% chance of an attack to a 0.00001% chance. Or something like that. Is that tiny additional cushion of security worth the investment?
The cost of deterrence
Some people don’t think so. At a recent conference on rail security, Tim O’Toole, the managing director of the London Underground subway system told attendees that it’s not wise to invest in “supercomplicated” — and superexpensive — technology.
With the open system that’s required in public transit to move people in a timely fashion, it’s almost impossible to significantly reduce the system’s exposure by adding high-tech hardware. Sensors to detect chemical and biological weapons sound like a good idea, but terrorists likely have already figured out a way to circumvent them.
How do transit systems reduce the chances of a terrorist attack on their buses or trains? It’s been mentioned countless times, but I’ll repeat it here anyway — by training their people. O’Toole put it this way: “Invest in people and count on them.” Training your employees to recognize suspicious behavior or packages is a critical part of any strategy to reduce the risk of a successful attack.
The other human element that will play a key role in a possible terrorist attack will be emergency response. Because it’s so difficult to prevent an attack, transit properties need to prepare an effective response. Amid all the chaos of a bombed bus or rail system, transit personnel need to provide a calm and coordinated response.
But we shouldn’t dismiss the role that hardware and software will play in the prevention of terrorist attacks. Here’s how O’Toole framed it: “Invest in technology and don’t count on it.” Technology, as it goes, isn’t a panacea but nor is it impotent. Eventually, it will be sophisticated enough to make an important contribution to the deterrence of terrorist attacks. And we’re getting closer all the time.
For example, sophisticated surveillance systems being installed in some rail stations can not only provide footage in the aftermath of an attack, but can also detect intrusions of prohibited areas, possibly helping to deter an attack. Content-analysis capabilities will continue to evolve in ways that cannot yet be predicted. Eventually, this type of equipment will play a significant role in transit security.
The human advantage
High-tech equipment, however, will never replace a highly trained and capable transit police force. It cannot duplicate the intuition and savvy of a transit police officer. Nor can it replace the eyes and ears of front-line transit operators and customers, who are in the best position to thwart an attack.
We need to prepare for the worst. Attacks in London and Madrid illustrate this. We need to maximize our security investment, coupling interests in humans and machines to most effectively thwart the desires of terrorists who most certainly are devising strategies to disrupt our transportation systems and demoralize our citizens.
More Management

Right-Sizing Rural Transit: Lessons from North Grenville’s On-Demand Model
A small municipality shows how flexible service, rider needs, and public accountability can expand mobility with limited resources.
Read More →
Transit Ballot Victories Signal Strong Voter Support: What Comes Next?
Voters approved billions in public transportation investments in 2026, giving agencies opportunities to preserve service, expand operations, and strengthen regional connections amid a changing political landscape.
Read More →
Transit Expands Agency Partnerships, Reaching 200 Official App Partners
COO Jake Sion discusses Transit’s growth, the success of its Transit Royale program, and how technology is helping agencies improve the rider experience.
Read More →
Everett Transit, Community Transit Approve Consolidation of Services
The agreement will bring Everett Transit into Community Transit’s network in April 2027, with plans to increase bus service by 50% by 2031 and expand regional connections.
Read More →
NITA Proposes $5B Operating Budget, $9.7B Capital Program for 2027
The proposed budget includes funding for expanded transit service, safety initiatives, fleet upgrades, and infrastructure improvements across CTA, Metra, and Pace.
Read More →
Financing, Fleet Replacement Requires a More Strategic Approach
Executives from ABC Companies and MCI discuss how rising costs, changing market conditions, and post-pandemic challenges are prompting motorcoach operators to rethink financing strategies, fleet replacement cycles, and long-term planning.
Read More →
Bringing Austin’s First Light Rail System to Life
Austin Transit Partnership CEO Greg Canally discusses the city's nearly 10-mile light rail project, its collaborative approach to project delivery, the importance of community engagement, and the milestones ahead as construction approaches in 2027.
Read More →
ETA CEO John Maglio on Transit Technology, Innovation, and Building Agency Trust
ETA founder and CEO John Maglio explores the evolution of transit technology, the importance of reliable systems, and how stronger partnerships can help agencies improve operations and the passenger experience.
Read More →
Metra Draft Plan Outlines Costs, Service Improvements for Regional Rail
The Systemwide Network Plan identifies infrastructure needs and potential investments to expand all-day, bidirectional rail service across the Chicago region.
Read More →
New Orleans RTA Names Augustine III as New CEO
In this edition, we also spotlight recent personnel moves at HDR, PATH, STV, and more, highlighting the people taking on new roles across the transportation industry.
Read More →