METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

FTA rules against Westchester DOT

FTA orders WCDOT to cease and desist providing impermissible charter services.

by Staff
February 15, 2007
2 min to read


Charter operators scored another big victory over public transit agencies trying to infringe on their business when the FTA ordered the Westchester County Department of Transportation (WCDOT) to stop providing impermissible charter services.

The decision stems from a complaint filed in June 2006 by Service Tours Inc. of Yonkers, N.Y., accusing the WCDOT of violating conditions placed on recipients of federal transit assistance by providing shuttle service to the Buick Classic golf tournament in Harrison, N.Y.

Ad Loading...

In its claim, Service Tours alleged that the contract it had in place with tournament organizers to provide services during the tournament was canceled when the WCDOT agreed to provide services with its federally funded buses, which Service Tours said was a direct violation of the FTA’s charter regulations. It also alleged that the agency did not determine if there were any willing and able charter operators available to perform the service.

In its final decision, the FTA ruled WCDOT was in violation of the law because it did not demonstrate a broad outreach and attempt to make the service known to the general public; the tournament’s organizers, and not the WCDOT, were in control of the financial agreement reached; the tournament bus stop was not part of its regular services; and the demand-responsive service it provided was not designed to benefit the public at large.

“I’m pleased that the FTA saw that they clearly competed with private enterprise,” said Sal DiPaolo, president of Service Tours.

As of press time, the WCDOT, which had 10 days to do so, did not file an appeal.

Topics:Management
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

A New Flyer 60-foot articulated bus
Busby StaffMay 29, 2026

WMATA Debuts 'Fares Pay for Service' Awareness Campaign

The campaign was highlighted during a media event at the Paul S. Sarbanes Transit Center in Silver Spring, where WMATA’s GM/CEO Randy Clarke joined Metro Transit Police officers, WMATA management team, board members, and staff to expand fare enforcement and customer education efforts on Metro Bus routes throughout the region.

Read More →
ManagementMay 29, 2026

Managing Complexity: HDR’s Brian Buchanan on Delivering Major Transit Programs

HDR’s transit program management lead discusses the challenges of overseeing large capital projects, adapting to cost and supply chain pressures, and the capabilities agencies need to build for the future.

Read More →
Managementby StaffMay 29, 2026

Seattle’s Sound Transit Adopts Updated ST3 System Plan

The updated system plan incorporates cost savings across the agency, including new revenue sources and financial policies, to set the agency on a sustainable path for the future.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Managementby StaffMay 29, 2026

Audit Finds Regional Coordination Across California's East Bay Transit Agencies

The State Auditor further concluded that while collaboration among transit agencies is functioning, the Bay Area’s public transportation systems face mounting structural fiscal pressures that threaten future service levels if sustainable funding solutions are not secured.

Read More →
Biz Briefs for May 29, 2026

Biz Briefs: Foothill Gold Line Award, Matawan Contract, and More

From strategic partnerships to acquisitions and service expansions, the industry continues to evolve at a rapid pace. Find out all the latest here.

Read More →
An EMBARK bus going down the street.
Managementby Alex RomanMay 28, 2026

Inside Look: EMBARK Expands Fare-Free Transit Program Through New Public-Private Partnership

The OKC transit agency says sponsorship helps subsidize the Third Friday Free initiative while reducing barriers for first-time riders and boosting ridership across buses, streetcars, and river cruises.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A green TriMet FX bus at a bus stop.

Oregon's TriMet Adopts Major Budget Cuts to Address Financial Shortfall

The board adopted the agency’s fiscal year 2027 budget, approving approximately $64.5 million in spending reductions, including about $53 million in administrative cuts and roughly $11 million in service reductions.

Read More →
A blue OCTA transit bus at a bus stop.
Technologyby StaffMay 28, 2026

OCTA Sees Growing Adoption of Wave Fare Payment System

Since launching in October 2025, the Wave system has steadily replaced previous fare media with faster, more flexible payment options designed to streamline boarding, improve reliability, and help riders more easily access fare discounts and cost-saving benefits, said OCTA

Read More →
Managementby StaffMay 27, 2026

North Carolina's Metropolitan Transit Commission Concludes Decades of Leadership

To commemorate the occasion, current members of the MTC were presented with a custom painting of the Charlotte Transportation Center in Uptown.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
CTAA award presented to Mountain Line
Managementby StaffMay 27, 2026

Montana's Mountain Line Named Nation’s Best Transit System by CTAA

The award was presented to Mountain Line representatives at the CTAA Expo in mid-May, with bus operator Bryan Ursery, who has worked at Mountain Line for more than two decades, accepting the award on the agency's behalf.

Read More →