METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Manage Risk...or Risk Big Losses

Plaintiff attorneys understand the benefits to be reaped from injury claims against motorcoach and bus operators. It's up to motorcoach operators to implement and maintain policies that help eliminate unnecessary risk.

by By Albert Neal, Assistant Editor
August 1, 2003
6 min to read


Some motorcoach operators do all they can to manage their risks, and yet things still fall apart. Others take it for granted, and losses never occur. Perhaps it’s all about luck. Perhaps not. The bottom line is that every motorcoach operator must make managing risk a big priority. Casualties and accidents, whether large or small, can mean a windfall for attorneys and their clients. Like vampires, attorneys seek the jugular vein and comb a company’s operational records for proof of negligence, be it hiring practices or overall operations methods. It’s up to motorcoach operators to protect themselves. Cases in point Careful hiring practices, meaning thorough screening and background checks to ensure a crop of well-trained and qualified drivers, are a given. But many operators stumble in this area. Inevitably, this oversight, poor judgment of character or simple failure to follow up returns to bite operators on the backside. In 2000, a California judge ruled in favor of plaintiffs in a case in which an unqualified and untrained driver panicked when his minibus caught fire due to faulty wiring. The driver couldn’t engage the emergency brake and, instead of conducting an emergency evacuation, allowed passengers to leap from the front exit, side windows and emergency exits. Approximately 20 plaintiffs suffered moderate to serious injuries. Upon investigation, it was discovered that the driver also was in violation of hours-of-service regulations, an easily avoidable risk that cost the driver’s company millions of dollars. Currently, drivers must adhere to a 10-hour driving limit. Driver fatigue is common but mostly inexcusable. “Fatigue contributes to the poor decision-making experienced in crashes,” says Robert Crescenzo, vice president for Lancer Insurance. “Our most expensive, horrific crashes are often related to fatigue. That’s a risk that can be managed through scheduling and good use of a driver’s time and vehicle.” Tailgating, which can lead to rear-end crashes, is another risk that can be managed. “Rear-end collisions are the No. 1 problem in bus, truck and almost every other kind of transportation,” says Jack Burkert, a safety consultant for the bus industry. “Following too closely means you don’t have the time and space to react properly.” Rear-end collisions are usually preventable and are almost always at-fault accidents. “You always want a minimum of four, but up to six, seconds of space between your coach and the vehicle ahead of you,” says Crescenzo. “That has to be put into context with traffic, weather and road conditions.” Moreover, drivers need to create and adjust space while on the road. They should also expect other commuters to jump into that created space. Responsible passenger care It’s also crucial that drivers give utmost consideration to loading and unloading areas. Several lawsuits have been filed and won by plaintiffs alleging gross negligence with stop placement, or what some term as passive unloading. In a 1999 California case, judges ruled in favor of the plaintiff when a bus driver discharged her several feet from the curb. The passenger sustained injuries after tripping and falling when she couldn’t step onto the curb. “The passenger should not have to step into the street before alighting on the curb,” says Crescenzo. Drivers must make sure that the vehicle is level with the ground and that it is stopped with the emergency brake applied before allowing passengers to disembark. More risky business Not only must there be concern for where and how passengers are dropped off, but also for what is happening on the bus. Passenger management is yet another issue that can cost motorcoach operators millions in judgments or settlements. “The driver is in a very difficult spot,” says Burkert. “First of all, he is supposed to drive the bus. He can’t manage the passengers and handle certain kinds of things while driving. He needs to make sure that he sorts these things out so that he doesn’t take lightly his responsibilities for safe driving.” In a New Jersey case, a driver operated his bus without a working two-way radio. Aboard the bus, an argument over a passenger’s radio with the volume turned too loud ensued and escalated into a fistfight, which ended in gunfire. One person died from gunshot wounds, and five others were wounded. The driver watched the entire incident unfold and failed to summon help. Jurors, of course, decided in favor of the plaintiffs. Had the driver’s radio been working, he could have contacted dispatch for back up and prevented the passenger’s death as well as any harm to the other passengers. Had he intervened, there is the possibility that the driver himself could have become a casualty. It’s a tough call. “Drivers need to be trained in good communication skills and how to interact with all types of passengers with all types of needs,” says Crescenzo. “However, they have to be authorized to stop the vehicle, call the police and get the assistance they need if a passenger is that unruly.” Dealing with a crisis In any volatile situation, the driver’s response is critical. “Unruly passengers are a very difficult issue for drivers because passengers are customers and you want to be sure in your approach to things,” says Burkert. “At some level it becomes a matter for the police, not the driver, to attend to. There’s a line that gets crossed when the safety of the individual or others is jeopardized; the problem is no longer passenger management, but criminal activity.” Drug and alcohol abuse, although not as common or frequent as other driver violations, still surfaces as the cause of many bus accidents. In a 1996 Pennsylvania case, a paratransit contractor unknowingly hired a driver with a criminal record for driving under the influence of alcohol. The plaintiff was severely injured when the driver struck another vehicle traveling in the same direction, jumped the median and crashed into several other cars traveling in the opposite direction. A post-accident toxicology scan found excessive levels of alcohol, cocaine and marijuana in the driver’s urine. Cases such as this occasionally pop up in newspapers but coach operators tend to have some control with this particular risk factor. Still, coach operators remain vigilant over their drivers and must maintain testing procedures, screenings and background checks for new hires. The bottom line The entire aspect of risk management should be integrated into every aspect of the business, says Crescenzo. “As long as the company has a risk evaluation component and reviews all of [its] policies and procedures, then [it] greatly reduce the amount of risk for [its] company and drivers.” Most operators do a reasonably good job of managing risk, says Burkert. They recognize the necessity of having control systems in place. “There are operators that are better at it than others and there are those that are more sophisticated than others,” Burkert says. “But even the smallest of companies has a recognition of the requirement to operate safely or they will not have a business in the future.”

Topics:Management
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

TTC Line 5
Management•by Alex Roman•November 18, 2026

How Gen Z's Changing Mobility Habits Are Reshaping Public Transit

As younger generations embrace multimodal mobility over private vehicles, transit agencies can rethink station design, the passenger experience, and public transportation's role in building connected communities.

Read More →
A rendering of Amtrak's Airo trainset
Rail•by Alex Roman•November 18, 2026

Amtrak Expands Airo Fleet with Eight Higher-Capacity Trainsets

The new 10-car trains, expected to enter service in 2031, will provide about 34% more seating capacity to meet growing demand on the Northeast Corridor.

Read More →
APTA Warns Proposed FTA Guidance Could Delay Major Transit Projects
Management•by Alex Roman•November 18, 2026

APTA Urges FTA to Withdraw Proposed Capital Investment Grants Guidance

The association warns that proposed changes could delay transit projects, reduce federal funding, and create new hurdles for 47 projects currently in the CIG pipeline.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
New Portal North Bridge Marks Major Milestone for Northeast Corridor Rail Service
Rail•by Alex Roman•November 17, 2026

Amtrak, NJ TRANSIT Launch Full Service on New Portal North Bridge

The completion of the two-track bridge over the Hackensack River eliminates a longstanding source of delays for NJ TRANSIT and Amtrak customers. It marks a major milestone for the Gateway Program.

Read More →
A Metrolink station with two trains.
Rail•by Alex Roman•November 16, 2026

Southern California’s Metrolink Approves $508.8M Budget, Avoids Service Cuts

A $20 million state allocation allows the regional rail agency to maintain existing weekday and weekend service through fiscal year 2028, although longer-term funding challenges remain.

Read More →
A Denver RTD paratransit vehicle on the road.
Paratransit•by Alex Roman•November 16, 2026

Denver RTD Committee to Review Paratransit Services, Improve Accessibility

The committee will oversee an independent study of paratransit operations, gather customer feedback, and recommend improvements to service reliability, accessibility, and accountability.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Angela Castro, CEO of the RTC of Southern Nevada
Management•by Alex Roman•November 13, 2026

Castro to Lead RTC of Southern Nevada and More in People Movement

In this edition, we also cover recent appointments and announcements at the STV, MCI, and more, showcasing the individuals helping to shape the future of transportation.

Read More →
STraffic's John Moon
Technology•by Alex Roman•November 12, 2026

STraffic Expands North American Presence with Fare Collection Technology

John Moon, Associate Director, Product Strategy at STraffic, discusses the company's growth in North America, its efforts to reduce fare evasion, and more.

Read More →
An aerial shot of the Denver region
Management•by Alex Roman•November 12, 2026

Study: Denver RTD Generates $2.1 Billion in Annual Economic Activity

An economic impact study finds the agency supports approximately 17,500 jobs, delivers $1.6 billion in annual community and mobility benefits, and generates $2.42 in economic value for every dollar invested.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
METRO Magazine leadership update graphic featuring a portrait of Mark Aesch, identified as administrator of the Federal Transit Administration (FTA), alongside the U.S. Department of Transportation and FTA logos on a blue gradient background.
Management•by Alex Roman•November 12, 2026

Mark Aesch Nominated to Lead Federal Transit Administration

The former Rochester transit chief and TransPro founder, who has also contributed to METRO Magazine, brings decades of industry experience and a focus on performance, accountability, and financial sustainability to the nomination.

Read More →