Electric rail systems generate significant air pollution, particularly where these systems are powered by electricity generated by fossil fuel power plants, according to a new study. The study, conducted by the Breakthrough Technologies Institute, reveals that bus rapid transit (BRT) produces significantly less pollution than electric rail, while costing a fraction of the cost to build and operate. "Using coal to power transit simply moves the tailpipe to the smokestack -- the overall environment benefit is questionable," said Bill Vincent, author of the study. Three forms of transit were looked at throughout the study: electric heavy rail, electric light rail and BRT. It found that electric rail transit systems create significant power plant emissions, including carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, mercury and particulate matter, that contribute to smog, lung disease and global climate change. The study also found that BRT systems can produce significantly less pollution than electric rail when powered by advanced engines and fuels. The report makes a number of recommendations to maximize the environmental value of transit investments, including requiring transit agencies to purchase renewable power wherever that option is available. The report, titled "The Electric Rail Dilemma: Clean Transportation From Dirty Electricity?", is available for free download at www.gobrt.org.
BRT cleaner than electric rail transit, study says
Electric rail systems generate significant air pollution, particularly where these systems are powered by electricity generated by fossil fuel power plants.
More Bus

Measuring the True Cost of Paratransit Fleets
What truly drives the cost of a paratransit fleet? Beyond the purchase price, seven operational factors quietly determine maintenance frequency, downtime, and long-term service reliability. This whitepaper explores how these factors shape lifecycle cost and what agencies should evaluate when selecting paratransit vehicles.
Read More →Inside The Bus Coalition’s Push for Stronger Federal Transit Investment
In this conversation, TBC’s Executive Director Ed Redfern, President Corey Aldridge, and Washington Representative Joel Rubin outline the coalition’s key policy priorities, the challenges facing transit agencies, and how industry stakeholders can work together to strengthen the voice of bus transit at the federal level.
Read More →
Biz Briefs: Tolar Manufacturing Supports PSTA Spark Service and More
Stay informed with these quick takes on the projects and companies driving progress across the transportation landscape.
Read More →
Pittsburgh Unveils 'Bus Line Refresh' Plan
Originally introduced in 2023 as the Bus Line Redesign, the effort has evolved into a more targeted update that maintains familiar routes while improving reliability, frequency, evening and weekend service, and connections across Allegheny County.
Read More →
Seattle's Sound Transit Breaks Ground on S3 Bus Line
S3 will connect communities along SR 522 with fast, reliable, battery-electric bus service from Shoreline South Station to Bothell via Kenmore and Lake Forest Park.
Read More →
Pittsburgh Regional Transit Announces All-Door Boarding on the University Line
All-door boarding will allow passengers to pay while entering the front, middle, or rear doors of the University Line’s 60-foot articulated buses.
Read More →
Complete Coach Works Names Patrick Scully President
He succeeds the company founder, Dale Carson, who remains chairman of the board.
Read More →
Atlanta's MARTA Sets Date for 'A-Line' BRT Launch
The five-mile Rapid A-Line connects Downtown Atlanta to Capitol Gateway, Summerhill, Peoplestown, and the Beltline’s Southside Trail.
Read More →
Ster Seating, Maryland Transit Launch First Parent/Child Transit Seat in North America
The configuration uses Ster Seating's Gemini seat platform to create a family-friendly floor layout specifically engineered to accommodate parents traveling with young children.
Read More →
Seattle’s Sound Transit Breaks Ground on New Transit Center
The Renton Transit Center project will relocate and rebuild the Renton Transit Center to better serve the regional Stride S1 line, local King County Metro services, and the future RapidRide I Line.
Read More →
