METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Report: Traffic problems rising as economy rebounds

Key findings include a continued rise in congestion and commuter costs, and that public transportation saved travelers 785 million hours of delay, 640 million more gallons of fuel and $19 billion in congestion costs. APTA and T4 America leaders respond.

January 20, 2011
Report: Traffic problems rising as economy rebounds

Photo by danorth1 via flickr.

5 min to read


[IMAGE]Traffic-danorth1-4434409336-7500ccf12f-z-2.jpg[/IMAGE]After two years of slight declines in overall traffic congestion — attributable to the economic downturn and high fuel prices — leading indicators suggest that as the economy rebounds, traffic problems are doing the same, according to a new report from the Texas Transportation Institute (TTI).

While 2008 was the best year for commuters in at least a decade, the problem again began to grow in 2009.

Ad Loading...

The 2010 Urban Mobility Report, published by TTI at Texas A&M University, provides a snapshot of traffic congestion in the 439 U.S. urban areas. The current report offers a greatly enhanced picture of congestion on a city-by-city basis, using the wealth of speed data provided by INRIX, a private-sector provider of travel time information.

Highlights from the research illustrate the effects of the nation's traffic problems:

  •     Congestion costs continue to rise: measured in constant 2009 dollars, the cost of congestion has risen from $24 billion in 1982 to $115 billion in 2009.

  •     The total amount of wasted fuel in 2009 topped 3.9 billion gallons – equal to 130 days of flow in the Alaska Pipeline.

  •     Cost to the average commuter: $808 in 2009, compared to an inflation-adjusted $351 in 1982.

  •     Yearly peak delay for the average commuter was 34 hours in 2009, up from 14 hours in 1982.

Ad Loading...

The methodology used to calculate congestion has been improved more than a dozen times since the Urban Mobility Report was first published in 1984, but the changes made possible by access to hour-by-hour speed data are the most significant improvement yet, researchers say.

As a result of the new data, a revised congestion trend has been constructed for each urban region from 1982 to 2009. Eleven new urban regions have been added, including San Juan, Puerto Rico. Finally, three new measures of congestion are calculated for the 2010 report: delay per auto commuter, delay per non-peak traveler, and a Commuter Stress Index (CSI), which is calculated for the worst direction in each peak period to show the time penalty to those who travel in the peak direction.

The congestion reduction benefits of two significant solutions are discussed — public transportation and roadway operations. Without public transportation services, travelers would have suffered an additional 785 million hours of delay and consumed 640 million more gallons of fuel — a savings of $19 billion in congestion costs. Roadway operational treatments save travelers 320 million hours of delay and 265 million gallons of fuel for a congestion cost savings of $8 billion.

Researchers recommend a balanced and diversified approach to reducing traffic congestion – one that focuses on more of everything. Their strategies include:

  •     Get as much use as possible out of the transportation system we have.

  •     Add roadway and public transportation capacity in the places where it is needed most.

  •     Change our patterns, employing ideas like ridesharing and flexible work times to avoid traditional "rush hours."

  •     Provide more choices, such as alternate routes, telecommuting and toll lanes for faster and more reliable trips.

Ad Loading...
  •     Diversify land development patterns, to make walking, biking and mass transit more practical.

  •     Adopt realistic expectations, recognizing for instance that large urban areas are going to be congested, but they don't have to stay that way all day long.


American Public Transportation Association (APTA) President William Millar responded to the report: “There is no doubt that expanding public transportation use is key to reducing traffic congestion,” he said. “Clearly, even if you don’t ride public transportation, it is still in your best interest to support investment in public transit.  Better public transportation in your community means less congestion on the roads.”

Pointing out that the surface transportation authorization legislation has not yet been enacted by Congress, Millar added, “This report offers compelling evidence of the importance of investing in public transportation…Now is the time for Congress to pass a long-term authorization bill that will help reduce the problem of urban road congestion through a greater investment in public transportation…Each passing day means a delay in addressing congestion problems which impact individuals and undermine business productivity.”

Meanwhile, Transportation 4 America’s Director, James Corless, issued the following statement:

“The Urban Mobility Report is an important reminder that too many Americans are stuck without good options for efficient, safe and affordable travel in our cities and towns. It is especially timely as Congress prepares to reset priorities for investing our transportation trust fund. However, we must note that flaws in the UMR's analysis could lead to faulty conclusions about what the report indicates.

It assumes, for example, that everyone should be able to speed as rapidly down the highway during rush hour as they could in the middle of the night. American taxpayers will never stand for being asked to turn over their wallets and their neighborhoods in order to build that kind of highway capacity.

They would much rather see Congress make more efficient use of their money by fixing crumbling roads and bridges; investing in technology to manage existing freeway traffic better; providing rail and rapid bus service in congested corridors; and linking transportation funding to smarter planning and development.

The economist Joe Cortright showed in a study for CEOs for Cities that the UMR obscures the fact that people who live in cities with transportation options and less urban sprawl generally have shorter commutes. That means a lower proportion of the population is subjected to highway congestion than is true in places where long automobile commutes are the predominant option.

In the upcoming transportation authorization, Congress can fix the system that has left too many with no alternative but to sit in traffic, by giving communities the tools they need to provide more and better choices in living locations and travel options.”

More Paratransit

BusJanuary 22, 2026

Biz Briefs: BART, Uber Launch Partnership and More

Stay informed with these quick takes on the projects and companies driving progress across the transportation landscape.

Read More →
SponsoredJanuary 19, 2026

3 New Ways Fleet Software Pays: ROI opportunities for modern fleet managers

Transit agencies depend on safe, reliable vehicles to deliver consistent service. This eBook examines how next-generation fleet software helps agencies move from reactive processes to proactive operations through automated maintenance, real-time safety insights, and integrated data. Learn how fleets are improving uptime, safety outcomes, and operational efficiency.

Read More →
RailJanuary 15, 2026

Biz Briefs: Alstom Supplying TTC Subways, SilverRide Lands California Contracts, and More

Stay informed with these quick takes on the projects and companies driving progress across the transportation landscape.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
New Mobilityby Alex RomanJanuary 5, 2026

Forest River Working to Redefine Reliability, Responsibility in the Bus Industry

As the transportation landscape continues to evolve in the wake of the pandemic, few manufacturers have faced, or embraced, change as decisively as Forest River Bus.

Read More →
Managementby StaffJanuary 5, 2026

New York MTA Marks Record Year for Ridership, Performance in 2025

The subway, Long Island Rail Road, and Metro-North Railroad all recorded record-highs for on-time performance in 2025.

Read More →
A white and blue graphic with text reading "Milwaukee County Transit Plus Riders Join WisGo in 2026."
Paratransitby StaffJanuary 5, 2026

Milwaukee County Transit Plus Riders Join WisGo in 2026

Transit Plus riders gain access to WisGo cards and mobile fare payment through the Umo app in 2026.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Technologyby StaffJanuary 5, 2026

Vancouver's TransLink Taps Spare to Improve Paratransit Service

Starting next week, HandyDART will also extend its hours to 2 a.m., improving service availability for customers and aligning more closely with SkyTrain operating hours.

Read More →
New Mobilityby Staff and News ReportsDecember 19, 2025

Biz Briefs: Spare, Nova Bus, and More!

Biz Briefs covers the latest supplier news in the motorcoach and public transit industries.

Read More →
New Mobilityby StaffDecember 15, 2025

Florida's JTA Greenlights Major Fare Cuts for Bus, Paratransit Services

The JTA board also approved making Neighborhood Autonomous Vehicle Innovation service complimentary, effective December 15.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
New Mobilityby Staff and News ReportsDecember 12, 2025

Biz Briefs: Fare Collection, Motorcoach Orders, and More

Biz Briefs covers the latest supplier news in the motorcoach and public transit industries.

Read More →