Transit watchdog group criticizes N.Y. MTA
Report alleges poor emergency planning in the area of communications, but praises efforts of Long Island Rail Road.
A committee of transportation advocates in New York said this week that the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) and its transit divisions must improve their emergency communications plans to inform passengers and employees and keep them safe during a terrorist attack or emergency.
In its report, "Ladies and Gentlemen: This Is Not A Drill," the Permanent Citizens Advisory Committee to the MTA criticizes New York City Transit (NYCT) and Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) for inadequate emergency plans, while praising the Metro-North Railroad for its communications and employee training.
According to the New York Times, the report also claims that NYCT and LIRR have not clearly outlined employee responsibilities in the event of a crisis and have not set up emergency task forces to develop strategies and review and update existing plans.
In a written statement, MTA Executive Director Katherine Lapp disputed some of the report’s claims, but conceded that the agency will perform “a thorough review of our emergency operating procedures in our communications with the public to ensure uniformity in our established protocols.”
The advisory committee is a state-sponsored body, comprising three commuter councils that represent riders of the MTA’s two commuter railroads and the city's subways and buses.
More Management

Jacksonville’s NAVI Project Charts a New Course for Autonomous Public Transportation
Through its NAVI program, JTA is showing how autonomous vehicles, intelligent infrastructure, and coordinated operations can work together to deliver everyday public transportation.
Read More →
FRA Announces $5.3B in Rail Investments, Including $2B for Amtrak
Funding will support grade-crossing improvements, infrastructure upgrades, and new Amtrak equipment in 23 states.
Read More →
Finding the ‘Happy Medium’: Optimizing Maintenance Without Sacrificing Reliability
The key to maintenance optimization isn’t doing less work—it’s doing the right work at the right time on the right assets.
Read More →
People Movement: MARTA Drops Interim Tag on GM/CEO Hunt and More
In this edition, METRO covers recent appointments and announcements at the FMCSA, HDR, SilverRide, and more, showcasing the individuals helping to shape the future of transportation.
Read More →
VIA Metropolitan Transit Reports 2 Million More Passenger Trips as Better Bus Plan Gains Momentum
San Antonio's transit agency said accelerated service improvements are driving ridership growth, offering another example of how increased frequency and workforce investments can translate into stronger transit performance.
Read More →
ABAF Study Reveals Growing Insurance Crisis for Motorcoach Operators
Preliminary findings show 98% of operators faced premium increases over the past five years, while shrinking insurer participation is putting added pressure on businesses and customers.
Read More →
PSTA Modernizes Workforce Management with Digital Bidding System
The award-winning Workforce Transit Modernization project replaced paper bidding with a transparent digital platform, cutting administrative effort while improving access for operators.
Read More →
Chicago to Host Public Transportation's Biggest Gathering at APTA TRANSform & EXPO 2026
North America’s largest public transportation gathering returns to Chicago, connecting transit decision-makers with the technologies, ideas, and partnerships driving the industry forward.
Read More →
New Tricks for Old Bureaucracies: Joshua Schank on Making Transit Innovation Stick
Former LA Metro Chief Innovation Officer Joshua Schank discusses why good ideas aren't enough, how transit agencies can overcome resistance to change, and why today's challenges demand more innovation.
Read More →
Washington's Community Transit Sets Six-Year Roadmap for Growth, Expansion
Approved TDP targets more bus service, new mobility options, Swift BRT expansion, and a potential Everett Transit annexation.
Read More →