Transit watchdog group criticizes N.Y. MTA
Report alleges poor emergency planning in the area of communications, but praises efforts of Long Island Rail Road.
A committee of transportation advocates in New York said this week that the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) and its transit divisions must improve their emergency communications plans to inform passengers and employees and keep them safe during a terrorist attack or emergency.
In its report, "Ladies and Gentlemen: This Is Not A Drill," the Permanent Citizens Advisory Committee to the MTA criticizes New York City Transit (NYCT) and Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) for inadequate emergency plans, while praising the Metro-North Railroad for its communications and employee training.
According to the New York Times, the report also claims that NYCT and LIRR have not clearly outlined employee responsibilities in the event of a crisis and have not set up emergency task forces to develop strategies and review and update existing plans.
In a written statement, MTA Executive Director Katherine Lapp disputed some of the report’s claims, but conceded that the agency will perform “a thorough review of our emergency operating procedures in our communications with the public to ensure uniformity in our established protocols.”
The advisory committee is a state-sponsored body, comprising three commuter councils that represent riders of the MTA’s two commuter railroads and the city's subways and buses.
More Management

NITA Proposes $5B Operating Budget, $9.7B Capital Program for 2027
The proposed budget includes funding for expanded transit service, safety initiatives, fleet upgrades, and infrastructure improvements across CTA, Metra, and Pace.
Read More →
Financing, Fleet Replacement Requires a More Strategic Approach
Executives from ABC Companies and MCI discuss how rising costs, changing market conditions, and post-pandemic challenges are prompting motorcoach operators to rethink financing strategies, fleet replacement cycles, and long-term planning.
Read More →
Bringing Austin’s First Light Rail System to Life
Austin Transit Partnership CEO Greg Canally discusses the city's nearly 10-mile light rail project, its collaborative approach to project delivery, the importance of community engagement, and the milestones ahead as construction approaches in 2027.
Read More →
ETA CEO John Maglio on Transit Technology, Innovation, and Building Agency Trust
ETA founder and CEO John Maglio explores the evolution of transit technology, the importance of reliable systems, and how stronger partnerships can help agencies improve operations and the passenger experience.
Read More →
Metra Draft Plan Outlines Costs, Service Improvements for Regional Rail
The Systemwide Network Plan identifies infrastructure needs and potential investments to expand all-day, bidirectional rail service across the Chicago region.
Read More →
New Orleans RTA Names Augustine III as New CEO
In this edition, we also spotlight recent personnel moves at HDR, PATH, STV, and more, highlighting the people taking on new roles across the transportation industry.
Read More →
How Transit Agencies Are Using Free Rides to Improve Voting Access
Transit agencies are using fare-free service, trip-planning tools, and targeted rides to improve voting access. See what other agencies can learn from these efforts.
Read More →
Caltrain’s Electrification Drives a New Era of Ridership Growth
The railroad’s shift to electric service has brought more frequent trains, stronger customer satisfaction, and increased ridership, earning it APTA’s Outstanding Public Transportation System award.
Read More →
Chicago, Charlotte Transit Agencies Expand Rider Support Programs
CTA launched crisis intervention teams as CATS prepares to deploy fare ambassadors, expanding customer assistance and security efforts across both systems.
Read More →
New York MTA Launches Historic $1.9B Signal, Track Modernization Project
Funded in part by congestion pricing revenue, the project will replace nearly century-old signals along the A and C lines in Brooklyn and Queens.
Read More →