METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Beaten by a nose

San Francisco MTA pulls plug on ill-conceived advertising campaign.

by Steve Hirano, Editor/Associate Publisher
January 12, 2007
3 min to read


Those of you who are offended by perfume strips inserted into magazines will be happy to know that adhesive strips infused with the aroma of chocolate chip cookies have been removed from five bus shelters in San Francisco.

The cookie-scented strips were pasted on the bus shelters as part of the California Milk Processor Board’s “Got Milk?” campaign. The board was trying to break new ground with the nation’s first outdoor scent-based marketing campaign. The goal, of course, was to fill bus riders with a yearning for milk.

Ad Loading...

The cookie aroma lasted one day, Dec. 4, before the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (MTA) pulled the plug. MTA officials informed CBS Outdoor, which coordinates the agency’s bus shelter advertising, that it needed to remove the scent-infused adhesives immediately.

Aroused by the aroma
What happened? As you might have guessed, environmental activists peppered the MTA with complaints about possible illnesses and allergic reactions that could be triggered by the chemicals in the scent-infused adhesive strips.

Concerns were also voiced about the possibility that homeless people without the means to purchase cookies (or milk, I gather) would be unnecessarily tantalized by the aroma. I assume other people complained that they simply didn’t like the smell of chocolate chip cookies, whether they’re sitting in a bus shelter or in their mother’s kitchen.

MTA Executive Director Nathaniel Ford told the San Francisco Chronicle that his agency did not look closely at the proposal before allowing the shelters to be part of the unusual marketing campaign. He said the MTA’s decision to remove the advertising was not prejudiced by the involved foods. “We’re not against chocolate chip cookies, and we’re not against milk,” he told the newspaper.

CBS Outdoor said it would comply with the MTA’s request, but argued that the health concerns were exaggerated. The company would seem to have a point, seeing that the typical urban bus shelter is normally bombarded with exhaust fumes from cars, trucks and, yes, buses. Could the smell of chocolate chip cookies be any worse for your health?

Ad Loading...

But that’s not the point here. The question is whether or not it’s fair to inject another sensory stimulus into an environment already overloaded with unwanted sights, sounds and smells. (Remember how much nicer public places were when you didn’t have to listen to other people’s phone conversations?)

Take a deep breath
The MTA made the proper decision. It would be different if the advertising campaign was only visually annoying. Bus riders would at least have the option to look in another direction. But you have no choice about the air that you’re forced to breathe. Whether or not you like the smell of chocolate chip cookies, and I do, you should not be forced to inhale its aroma just to satisfy a marketer’s desire to sell more milk.

Before the bus shelter campaign was launched, Steve James, chairman of the California Milk Processor Board, predicted that it would “help us build buzz by creating a sensory trigger for milk in an unusual way and place.” It built buzz, no doubt. Future attempts to use scent marketing in outdoor venues will be hobbled by the buzz that was built in San Francisco, probably not the best place to launch an advertising campaign that could incite health or environmental concerns.

Maybe a better idea would have been to paint a milk mustache on the front of a MUNI bus. OK, maybe not.


Topics:Management
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

Angela Castro, CEO of the RTC of Southern Nevada
Management•by Alex Roman•November 13, 2026

Castro to Lead RTC of Southern Nevada and More in People Movement

In this edition, we also cover recent appointments and announcements at the STV, MCI, and more, showcasing the individuals helping to shape the future of transportation.

Read More →
STraffic's John Moon
Technology•by Alex Roman•November 12, 2026

STraffic Expands North American Presence with Fare Collection Technology

John Moon, Associate Director, Product Strategy at STraffic, discusses the company's growth in North America, its efforts to reduce fare evasion, and more.

Read More →
An aerial shot of the Denver region
Management•by Alex Roman•November 12, 2026

Study: Denver RTD Generates $2.1 Billion in Annual Economic Activity

An economic impact study finds the agency supports approximately 17,500 jobs, delivers $1.6 billion in annual community and mobility benefits, and generates $2.42 in economic value for every dollar invested.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
METRO Magazine leadership update graphic featuring a portrait of Mark Aesch, identified as administrator of the Federal Transit Administration (FTA), alongside the U.S. Department of Transportation and FTA logos on a blue gradient background.
Management•by Alex Roman•November 12, 2026

Mark Aesch Nominated to Lead Federal Transit Administration

The former Rochester transit chief and TransPro founder, who has also contributed to METRO Magazine, brings decades of industry experience and a focus on performance, accountability, and financial sustainability to the nomination.

Read More →
Two pedestrians wait at a crosswalk on a wet city street as a public transit bus approaches an intersection, with cars and other pedestrians in the background.
Management•by Elora Haynes•November 12, 2026

Best and Worst U.S. Cities for Public Transportation in 2026

A new analysis of 50 major U.S. urban areas ranks public transit systems based on accessibility, affordability, usefulness, and safety, highlighting where transit performs best and where challenges remain.

Read More →
A Laketran vehicle at a propane fueling station
Paratransit•November 11, 2026

Laketran Cuts Fuel Costs, Boosts Efficiency with Propane-Powered Fleet

The Ohio transit agency is using propane-powered vehicles and on-site fueling infrastructure to cut fuel and maintenance costs while meeting growing demand for paratransit services.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Rail maintenance workers wearing orange high-visibility coveralls and hard hats work on railroad tracks at night, using tools and equipment under bright work lights, with a yellow maintenance vehicle in the background.
Management•by Staff and News Reports•November 11, 2026

Canada’s Public Transit Supports $65.6 Billion in Annual GDP

New research from the Canadian Chamber of Commerce examines transit's economic contributions, including job creation and the financial implications of transportation investment.

Read More →
Pierce Transit Prepares for Major Fleet, Service Expansion
Bus•by Alex Roman•November 10, 2026

Pierce Transit Moves to Expand Fleet Following Proposition 1 Approval

The agency authorized the purchase or refurbishment of up to 60 buses to support a 47% service expansion, as voters nationwide approved billions in new transit funding.

Read More →
An NGtransit vehicle operating in the snow
New Mobility•November 9, 2026

Right-Sizing Rural Transit: Lessons from North Grenville’s On-Demand Model

A small municipality shows how flexible service, rider needs, and public accountability can expand mobility with limited resources.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Several King County Metro buses, including electric trolleybuses, line a downtown Seattle street beneath overhead power lines, with city buildings and traffic in the background.
Management•by Elora Haynes•November 9, 2026

Transit Ballot Victories Signal Strong Voter Support: What Comes Next?

Voters approved billions in public transportation investments in 2026, giving agencies opportunities to preserve service, expand operations, and strengthen regional connections amid a changing political landscape.

Read More →