METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Buy America gets challenged again

Countries all over the world recognize the need for government investment to jump-start their economies, build their heavy industry, and keep or add more higher-wage jobs.

by Frank Di Giacomo, Publisher
April 2, 2009
3 min to read


Although not the major objection, a loud outcry to the stimulus legislation just signed into law was raised over Buy America provisions in the bill. The kind of misinformation being raised about the issue could be a signal of things to come, and the public transportation industry must be prepared to deal with it.

Buy America attacks create misinformation

Ad Loading...

As the bill was being debated shortly after President Obama was inaugurated, a chorus of conservatives began throwing a series of charges at the proposals. They contended that the bill was too big, spent too much on things that “were not stimulative” (never mind that any spending generates economic activity as the money is spent into the economy) or that there was not enough infrastructure spending. Others said there was too much infrastructure spending, calling it “pork.” At the other end of the political spectrum, some liberal economists worried that the bill was not big enough to stimulate the economy as much as is needed.

Then, as the bill was headed for passage, another objection was raised: protectionism. Opponents charged that the bill contained “Buy America” provisions that could “trigger a trade war” of the kind that helped worsen the Great Depression or was propping up obsolete companies. While these provisions remain intact in the final legislation, we in the industry should take this minor squabble as a warning that a big debate about this issue could be coming within the federal surface transportation authorization debate scheduled to take place later this year.

First, though, we must dispel the myth that the Buy America provisions of federal transportation policy, which have been with us since the 1970s, are protectionist or anti-trade. Rather, they are incentives for transit agencies to use U.S. tax dollars (or, more lately, money borrowed from Asian sovereign wealth funds) to procure hardware made in America to create or preserve American jobs. By the way, European and Asian nations dealing with their own economic crises have enacted massive infrastructure investments with their own incentives to ensure that the money gets spent in their own economies. As President Obama said of the U.S. strategy, “spending is the whole point.”

Let us remain united

The other major point about Buy America is this: it is existing, settled U.S. law — and it has worked. Sure, the regulations implementing the law are complicated and arcane, but because of this policy many companies headquartered in other countries have invested in the U.S. marketplace, spending millions if not billions of dollars to build factories and hire American workers. Would they have done so without the law? Possibly, but certainly not to the levels they have were there no minimum requirements. More than that, because the law has existed for so long and has worked, it would be grossly unfair to the companies who have made those investments to allow competition from those who have not.

Ad Loading...

Countries all over the world recognize the need for government investment to jump-start their economies, build their heavy industry, and keep or add more higher-wage jobs, especially in industries that grow a greener economy. The last thing the U.S. needs is to pursue some purists’ notions of what international trade should be — even though it never has been what they think.

Topics:RailBus
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Bus

Endera electric buses for California’s Mendocino Transit Authority
Technologyby StaffJune 25, 2026

Biz Briefs: Endera Delivers to California, Safety Vision Teams with San Antonio's VIA, and More

From manufacturers and suppliers to transit agencies and motorcoach operators, these updates offer a snapshot of the projects, partnerships and business moves driving the industry forward.

Read More →
A VIA Metropolitan PRIMO bus
Busby StaffJune 23, 2026

VIA's Silver Line Clears Environmental Review, Advances Toward Construction

The VIA Rapid Green Line is currently under construction, with service expected to begin in April 2028.

Read More →
New MobilityJune 19, 2026

Modernizing Mobility with CharterUP CEO Armir Harris

From digital transformation to evolving customer demands, CharterUP's Armir Harris offers his perspective on the transportation industry's next chapter.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
CTTC Bolsters Statewide Workforce Development
Managementby StaffJune 19, 2026

CTTC Enhances Transit Workforce Pipeline Through New Partnerships and Leadership

The group's latest initiatives focus on developing talent, expanding training opportunities and addressing workforce needs across the transit sector.

Read More →
A Nova LFSe+ electric bus for STM
Technologyby Staff and News ReportsJune 18, 2026

Biz Briefs: Montréal Debuts Nova Electric Buses and More

In this edition of Biz Briefs, we spotlight the latest developments shaping the future of mobility.

Read More →
Zero-emissions bus with FLEETWATCH technology
ManagementJune 17, 2026

The Hidden Cost of Fuel Data Inaccuracy in Public Transit Fleets

In today's transit environment, accurate fuel and mileage data are critical to reducing costs, minimizing downtime, and improving fleet performance.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Six-Year Plan Boosts Virginia Transit, Rail Investments
Managementby StaffJune 17, 2026

Virginia's $28.5B Transportation Plan Targets Transit and Rail

Approved by the Commonwealth Transportation Board, the program supports ongoing infrastructure projects while providing new investments in transit, state of good repair and transportation alternatives.

Read More →
Group announcing BUSES Act
Motorcoachby StaffJune 16, 2026

Bipartisan BUSES Act Seeks Changes to New York City's Bus Idling Enforcement Program

Backed by motorcoach operators, the legislation seeks to balance emissions goals with passenger safety by allowing limited idling for inspections, accessibility needs and extreme weather conditions.

Read More →
An LA Metro D Line train in Union Station
Managementby StaffJune 16, 2026

D Line Expansion Fuels Growth Across LA Metro's Rail System

Weekend rail ridership was especially strong, soaring 18% as riders embraced expanded access to jobs, entertainment, dining, and cultural destinations, said the agency. Total system ridership for May, including bus and rail, was 26,966,657.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
An ENC bus being manufactured in its facility.
Busby StaffJune 10, 2026

ENC to Deliver Three Clean Diesel Buses to Canada's York Region Transit

Since 2005, City View and ENC have supplied nearly 90 E-Z Rider II buses to YRT.

Read More →