METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

TNCs divert riders from public transit, cost MBTA $20 million: Study

Analysis shows ride-hailing companies add traffic, reduce MBTA ridership, and increase greenhouse gas emissions across region.

July 23, 2019
TNCs divert riders from public transit, cost MBTA $20 million: Study

Boston's Logan Airport signage directs passengers to various transportation modes, including TNCs.

METRO Magazine/Janna Starcic

3 min to read


Boston's Logan Airport signage directs passengers to various transportation modes, including TNCs. METRO Magazine/Janna Starcic

Ride-hailing companies such as Uber and Lyft are increasing not just traffic but greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs) in Greater Boston, new data shows. The first-ever analysis of the climate impacts of transportation network companies, or TNCs was conducted by the Boston area's Metropolitan Area Planning Council (MAPC).

Using recently-released data from the state’s Department of Public Utilities (DPU), which tracks TNC trip data in Massachusetts, MAPC researchers calculated the effect of ride-hailing services on vehicles miles traveled (VMT) and greenhouse gas emissions across Greater Boston. DPU data for the state as a whole, the City of Boston, and individual municipalities in the region are available online at https://tnc.sites.digital.mass.gov.

MAPC found TNCs released an estimated total of 163,300 metric tons of CO2e, which is the equivalent of over 18 million gallons of gasoline consumed. Additionally, the MAPC analysis found that TNCs divert riders from public transit, costing the MBTA an estimated $20 million each year.

“We already know that TNC services are siphoning riders and dollars from public transit, but now we can see clearly that they leave an impact on our congestion as well as our air quality,” said Rebecca Davis, Deputy Director of MAPC, the regional planning agency serving Greater Boston. “Clearly we need to do more to promote shared trips when users choose these services, while advocating for better walking and biking infrastructure and safe, reliable public transit.”

Ad Loading...

“We already know that TNC services are siphoning riders and dollars from public transit, but now we can see clearly that they leave an impact on our congestion as well as our air quality.”

Between 2017 and 2018, the number of ride-hailing trips grew from 64.8 million to 81.3 million, a 25% increase across Massachusetts. MAPC calculated the GHGs by using the number of TNC trips by municipality, and the average miles per trip reported by DPU, applied against earlier research by MAPC that showed almost 60% of ride-hailing trips would have used a non-polluting mode of travel if Uber and Lyft were not an option.

According to MAPC, the negative effects of TNC emissions may be decreased by policies and programs that promote shared trips/ride pooling; providing incentives for drivers to use electric or zero-emission vehicles; and maximize the efficiency of pick-up and drop-off locations.

The study also calls for the state to collect more data on TNCs to better evaluate their impact, giving local planners more effective tools to measure and understand rider behavior.

An analysis by the Boston-based Metropolitan Area Planning Council found that TNCs divert riders from public transit, costing the MBTA an estimated $20 million each year. METRO Magazine/Janna Starcic

Lawmakers will host hearings related to TNC regulations this week. Fees on ride-  hailing will be the subject of testimony at a Joint Committee on Financial Services hearing where almost two dozen bills are on the agenda, including several that would increase the 20-cent per ride flat fee now imposed on Uber and Lyft trips.

Another bill by Rep. Adrian Madaro of East Boston would charge companies for congestion-causing “deadhead” rides – those with no passenger – at Logan Airport. Legislation filed last week by Gov. Charlie Baker would impose new safety restrictions and data-collection requirements on ride-hailing companies but is not yet set for a hearing, and has been referred to the Joint Committee on Transportation.


More New Mobility

Officials and community leaders cut a ribbon in front of a Pace On Demand shuttle bus outside Rolling Meadows City Hall to celebrate expanded on-demand transit service in northwest Cook County.
New Mobilityby News/Media ReleaseMarch 9, 2026

Chicago Pace Expand On-Demand Transportation Program

The expanded service builds on Pace’s growing On Demand network and is intended to improve access to destinations such as medical appointments, schools, shopping, employment centers and connections to the regional transit system.

Read More →
A vehicle that will be used for MARTA's Reach mobility program.
New Mobilityby StaffMarch 2, 2026

Atlanta's MARTA Set to Launch New On-Demand Transportation Service

An important part of the authority’s NextGen Bus Network, MARTA Reach will bring transit service directly to the rider’s location and offer a seamless link to the broader rail and bus system.

Read More →
A black and blue HOLON urban autonomous vehicle on a city street.
New Mobilityby Elora HaynesFebruary 26, 2026

CharterUP Moves to Scale Autonomous Shuttle Deployments Through HOLON Partnership

The partnership aims to accelerate the rollout of electric, high-capacity autonomous shuttles for campuses, airports, transit systems, and more.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Portrait of Joshua Schank, Ph.D., alongside the ACES Mobility Coalition logo.
Managementby StaffFebruary 16, 2026

ACES Mobility Coalition Selects Joshua Schank as New Executive Director

Veteran transportation innovator to lead coalition as it pushes nationwide expansion of shared autonomous mobility.

Read More →
David Carol, Baker Alloush, and Jesse Lazarus from METRO's People Movement February 4 edition.
Managementby Staff and News ReportsFebruary 4, 2026

New Rolling Stock Strategy Lead at New York MTA and More in People Movement

In this edition, we cover recent appointments and announcements at HDR, NCTD, STV, and more, showcasing the individuals helping to shape the future of transportation.

Read More →
New Mobilityby StaffJanuary 30, 2026

Chicago's Pace Expands VanGo Mobility Program

The service is a flexible, reservation-based transit service designed to close the first- and last-mile gaps and connect riders to employment for just $5 per day.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
SponsoredJanuary 22, 2026

5 Costly Myths About Paratransit Vehicles

What agencies often overlook when selecting vehicles.

Read More →
Busby StaffJanuary 22, 2026

Biz Briefs: BART, Uber Launch Partnership and More

Stay informed with these quick takes on the projects and companies driving progress across the transportation landscape.

Read More →
SponsoredJanuary 19, 2026

Fleet Software ROI: Boost Uptime & Safety

Transit agencies depend on safe, reliable vehicles to deliver consistent service. This eBook examines how next-generation fleet software helps agencies move from reactive processes to proactive operations through automated maintenance, real-time safety insights, and integrated data. Learn how fleets are improving uptime, safety outcomes, and operational efficiency.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Transit signal priority and public transit agencies.
New Mobilityby Alex RomanJanuary 16, 2026

How AI is Redefining Transit Operations and Signal Priority

In a recent episode of METROspectives, LYT CEO Timothy Menard discusses how artificial intelligence, cloud connectivity, and real-time data are transforming traffic management, boosting bus reliability, and enabling system-wide transit optimization across cities.

Read More →