METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

No. 1 reason why TQM plans fail? No leadership

The total quality management (TQM) revolution has now been entrenched in the public transport community for several years now, long enough for people to start evaluating its effects on product and service quality.

by Cliff Henke, Associate Publisher/Editor
February 1, 2001
3 min to read


The total quality management (TQM) revolution has now been entrenched in the public transport community for several years now, long enough for people to start evaluating its effects on product and service quality. These early initial results are not encouraging. For reasons similar to the disappointment many experienced in other industries, public transport operators and suppliers are questioning their investment in quality initiatives. These doubters may keep their comments to themselves, for fear of being branded “politically incorrect,” or worse repercussions. Yet, rest assured these second thoughts are out there and must be dealt with. TQM neither religion nor fad According to a variety of management studies, between two-thirds and 80% of TQM initiatives fail to capture sufficient returns for the organization soon enough to make them worth their while and are abandoned. The statistic at left indicates the average rate of company TQM failures is nearly three out of four. By contrast, marriage in America, an institution that saw half end in failure, is making a comeback. The reasons most experts give for such failures come in three basic categories, all of which apply to companies and public agencies involved with TQM failures in public transport. First, management abandons the initiative too early, often as early as six months after its launch, because it doesn’t see tangible enough returns on the not-insignificant investment required by TQM. Second, the TQM plan isn’t tailored sufficiently to the needs of the company because someone is using a “quick and dirty” off-the-shelf approach and/or because not enough resources and backing was given to those responsible for implementing it. Third, and this applies to too many public transport suppliers, companies are adopting TQM only because they think the marketplace demands it, not because they are sold on the concept. All those, however, boil down to one font of failure: lack of leadership. TQM and ISO 9000 must begin with written corporate commitment—and management must mean every word of it, every day. In the words of one TQM veteran, “It is neither a religion nor a fad. It requires hard work and commitment to its success.” What TQM and Web share There are similarities between TQM initiatives and corporate Internet strategies. Both have the same failure rate. And, according to a former executive at one of those struggling dot-coms (redundant?): “The No. 1 reason why so many Internet projects fail is the failure of top management to get involved. CEOs must lead. Only they can explain why it is being done and what it means for everyone in the organization. When they don’t it’s the kiss of death.” The same could also be said of TQM, almost to a word. I posted a recent message to participants in a maintenance discussion group funded by the Transportation Research Board. I asked the community what it thought of ISO 9000. The answers were enlightening. Without revealing what I think are confidences, everyone who replied is not seeing much change in product quality after public transport suppliers became registered to one of the ISO quality standards. Many of them still back the promise of ISO 9000, but feel the companies are not engaging in enough follow-through once they receive their certificates of registration. To me, that’s a failure of leadership, of using the bully pulpit, of setting the tone for a corporate culture. I hope these comments are also finding their way back to the companies themselves, because a major aspect of TQM and ISO 9000 is managing the change required of customer feedback; in the ISO 9000 standards it’s called “corrective action.” Quality is not an easy road. The commitment is arduous and the rewards might not materialize for years. In today’s corporate world, that might be tough to take. Someone must lead, including suppliers, operators and in government where the funds are given out.

Topics:Management
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

NJ TRANSIT's new Multilevel III commuter railcar manufactured by Alstom
Technologyby StaffApril 14, 2026

Alstom Delivers First Multilevel III NJ TRANSIT Commuter Railcar

The delivery marks the first car in a 374‑vehicle order and begins the arrival of a new generation of higher‑capacity, more reliable, and more comfortable trains for one of the country’s busiest commuter rail systems.

Read More →
New Cincinnati Metro bus stop sign with large route numbers and clear layout at a city intersection, part of a systemwide signage upgrade initiative.
Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 13, 2026

Cincinnati Metro Begins Countywide Bus Stop Sign Upgrade

Metro launches a 24-month project to replace 3,700 bus stop signs, introducing improved visibility, QR-enabled rider info, and expanded amenities across Hamilton County.

Read More →
A BART train on the tracks.
Railby StaffApril 13, 2026

San Francisco's BART Breaks Multiple Records for Post-Pandemic Ridership in March

BART recorded 5,403,140 exits in March, making it the highest monthly ridership since the pandemic and surpassing the previous high set in October 2025 (5,346,890 exits).

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Rod Diridon Sr. speaking at a podium wearing a brown blazer.
Managementby StaffApril 13, 2026

Transit Leader Rod Diridon Sr., ‘Father of Modern Transit’ in Silicon Valley, Dies at 87

See how the longtime public servant and transportation visionary helped shape Bay Area transit systems and championed rail development nationwide.

Read More →
FlixBus vehicles in a parking garage.
ManagementApril 13, 2026

Intercity Bus Industry Outlook: A Mix of Apprehension & Optimism

Industry leaders see both promise and peril ahead as intercity bus travel rebounds, but unpredictable market forces threaten to reshape the sector.

Read More →
Ribbon cutting photo celebrating SEPTA's new Ardmore Station
Railby StaffApril 13, 2026

Philadelphia's SEPTA Celebrates New Ardmore Station

The station was rebuilt as part of SEPTA’s Station Accessibility Program, making it fully ADA accessible with new elevators, ramps, and high-level platforms.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Passengers in crowded SEPTA station
Managementby StaffApril 10, 2026

SEPTA Releases Proposed $2.7B Fiscal Year 2027 Budget

The plan represents an increase of just 1.9% over the current year, and includes investments in new buses, more full-length fare gates, and other enhancements for customers.

Read More →
Two Metra locomotives on rail tracks.
Railby StaffApril 10, 2026

Metra Reaches New 10-Year Agreement with BNSF

The announcement highlights the long-standing partnership between the Class I railroad and the commuter rail system, dating back to Metra's creation in 1983.

Read More →
Cover Photo for Bus Tech Talk
ManagementApril 9, 2026

Bus Tech Talk: AC Transit’s Cecil Blandon on Leadership, Mentorship, and a Career in Transit

In Part 1, Blandon shares his journey from the U.S. Marines to a leadership role in public transit, along with insights on mentorship and professional growth within the industry.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
METRO Buyer's Guide art
Managementby Staff and News ReportsApril 8, 2026

Last Chance: Be A Part of METRO's Annual Buyer’s Guide

The revamped Buyer’s Guide will reach METRO’s audience of more than 17,000 print and digital subscribers, providing suppliers with year-round visibility in front of transit agency leaders, motorcoach operators, and industry decision-makers across North America.

Read More →