METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Report into Fatal Ohio Bus Crash Involving Students Reveals Potential Cause [Updated Dec. 12]

Three students, two chaperones, and a teacher were killed in the fiery chain-reaction crash. The report reveals the semi-truck was allegedly following too closely.

Christy Grimes
Christy GrimesFormer Senior Editor
December 12, 2023
Report into Fatal Ohio Bus Crash Involving Students Reveals Potential Cause [Updated Dec. 12]

(Top L-R) David Kennat, Kristy Gaynor, Shannon Wigfield, (bottom L-R) John Wyatt Mosley, Katelyn Nicole Owens, and Jeffrey "JD" Worrell were killed in a chain-reaction crash on their way to a conference where the students were going to perform with their high school band.

Photo: Tuscarawas Valley School District, School Bus Fleet

4 min to read


A recently released report from the Ohio Department of Public Safety reveals a semi-truck was following too close to the vehicles in front of it, ultimately leading to the chain-reaction crash that killed six people and injured 18 others on Nov. 14.

The report comes as the National Transportation Safety Board continues its investigation into the highway crash in Licking, Ohio. A charter bus carrying a high school marching band was among the vehicles involved.

Ad Loading...

An NTSB team arrived in Ohio on Nov. 15 and spent several days there, collecting information for the investigation.

The Crash: What We Know

According to the Ohio State Highway Patrol (OSHP), the crash happened just before 9 a.m. on Nov. 14 on Interstate 70 near State Route 310. Involved in the crash were the charter bus carrying a driver and 54 students and chaperones from Tuscarawas Valley Local Schools, two passenger vehicles, and two commercial vehicles — one of which was identified in the report sent to School Bus Fleet as a semi-truck.

The students and chaperones were on their way to perform at the Ohio School Boards Association conference in Columbus. WBNS reported that the conference was canceled when organizers learned of the crash.

The report shed light into the events leading up to the crash. According to the report, all five vehicles were traveling in the right lane. All of the vehicles except for the semi-truck slowed for traffic. The semi-truck reportedly struck an SUV carrying a staff member and two parents, forcing the SUV into the rear of the charter bus. The semi-truck then struck the bus after overriding the SUV. The charter bus was then forced into the rear of another SUV, which hit the back of a cargo van, spinning the second SUV into the left lane. The semi-truck came to a stop after striking the cargo van.

Three of the bus passengers were pronounced deceased on the scene. Additionally, all three people in the first SUV died.

Ad Loading...

None of the drivers involved were found to be distracted or under the influence, according to the report.

The Tuscarawas Valley School District released a photo of bus crash victims, as well as ways to support the school district.

Photo: Tuscarawas Valley School District

The names of those killed include:

  • John W. Mosely, age 18.

  • Katelyn N. Owens, age 15.

  • Jeffery D. Worrell, age 18.

  • Kristy Gaynor, age 39

  • Dave Kennat, age 56.

  • Shannon Wigfield, age 45.

Fifteen students and the bus driver were transported to area hospitals. The remaining students were taken to a reunification site.

Tuscarawas Valley Local Schools Superintendent Dr. Derek Varansky read a statement to parents and students at a vigil held on Nov. 14, saying in part, "There are no words for the magnitude of loss and grief felt by all of us," calling the students who died "bright lights" and "full of life," according to WKYC.

Ad Loading...

Varansky explained the district's decision to resume classes on Nov. 15, saying, "we do not want children home alone, yet we respect students and parents who wish for their child to remain at home." The district made counselors and support staff from community organizations and neighboring districts available to those who needed them.

Additionally, the district shared common signs and signals of a stress reaction for parents to look for in their children following the crash.

Sally Green, Ohio School Boards Association (OSBA) president-elect and Tuscarawas Valley local school board member, shared a statement with OSBA, saying in part, "During this time of loss, it's important to capture every moment with have with students. Relationships have the greatest impact both in grief and restoration."

Of the two commercial vehicles involved, one driver was transported to a local hospital with non-life-threatening injuries. The other was treated and released at the scene. The driver of the second passenger vehicle was also transported to an area hospital.

Investigating the Crash

The OSHP statement said the cause of the crash was under investigation and witnesses were urged to come forward.

Ad Loading...

In a Nov. 15 news conference, NTSB Chair Jennifer Homendy said there was conflicting information about the sequence of events that led to the crash. The report by the Ohio Department of Public Safety will be used in the NTSB's investigation.

The NTSB team will also look through camera footage gathered by OSHP after the crash, as well as footage from vehicles that were not involved that may have captured the crash.

In the news conference, Homendy mentioned that there was an unrelated crash about an hour prior to this one, west of where this crash occurred. OSHP told School Bus Fleet that crash was a four-vehicle crash to the left of the roadway, off the road. Law enforcement were still on the scene of that crash when this one occurred. It's unclear if the two are related.

The only seat belt on the motor coach, according to Homendy, was in the driver's seat.

The NTSB investigation could take up to 18 months. At any time during the investigation, the NTSB could release urgent safety recommendations related to the crash.

Ad Loading...

"Our focus is on safety. Our whole mission is based on determining how this happened, why this happened, and to prevent it from reoccurring," Homendy said.

Originally posted on School Bus Fleet

More Motorcoach

ABAF Examines Motorcoach Insurance Crisis
Motorcoachby Alex RomanAugust 11, 2026

ABAF Study Reveals Growing Insurance Crisis for Motorcoach Operators

Preliminary findings show 98% of operators faced premium increases over the past five years, while shrinking insurer participation is putting added pressure on businesses and customers.

Read More →
Virginia Breeze's new Van Hool motorcoaches with branding, which were delivered by ABC Companies.
Motorcoachby Alex RomanAugust 5, 2026

Motorcoach Market Remains Flat Amid Shift in Buying Patterns

Q2 sales totaled 514 units, up slightly from 2025, as operators favored pre-owned equipment and public-sector purchases increased.

Read More →
An OCTA ZEB.
Technologyby Alex RomanJuly 31, 2026

Biz Briefs: OCTA Taps Clean Energy for Hydrogen Station, Stadler to Supply Via Rail Vehicles, and More

From manufacturers and suppliers to transit agencies and motorcoach operators, these updates offer a snapshot of the projects, partnerships and business moves driving the industry forward.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A CharterUP branded Holon AV.
New Mobilityby Alex RomanJuly 31, 2026

CharterUP Expands Into New Mobility and Autonomous Transportation

Vice President of New Mobility Stephen Joos discusses how CharterUP is leveraging its nationwide transportation network, technology platform, and autonomous vehicle partnerships to expand into workforce mobility, campus shuttles, and transit solutions.

Read More →
A photo of an Amtrak train with a logo
Managementby Alex RomanJuly 24, 2026

Biz Briefs: STV teams with Amtrak, Motorcoach Operators Boost Fleet and Land Contracts, and More

From manufacturers and suppliers to transit agencies and motorcoach operators, these updates offer a snapshot of the projects, partnerships and business moves driving the industry forward.

Read More →
EPA Proposal Targets DEF-Related Engine Derates
Motorcoachby Alex RomanJuly 10, 2026

EPA Proposal to Ease Diesel Emissions Compliance Could Improve Reliability for Motorcoach Operators

The EPA is proposing to remove DEF-related engine derates for new heavy-duty diesel vehicles, a change bus operators say would improve safety and reliability while sparking debate over the future of emissions enforcement.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
An MCI J4500 for Rustad Tours
Motorcoachby StaffJune 26, 2026

Minnesota's Rustad Tours Takes Delivery of New MCI Motorcoach

The latest addition represents Rustad Tours’ 17th new MCI coach, marking more than four decades of partnership between the two companies.

Read More →
Endera electric buses for California’s Mendocino Transit Authority
Technologyby StaffJune 25, 2026

Biz Briefs: Endera Delivers to California, Safety Vision Teams with San Antonio's VIA, and More

From manufacturers and suppliers to transit agencies and motorcoach operators, these updates offer a snapshot of the projects, partnerships and business moves driving the industry forward.

Read More →
New MobilityJune 19, 2026

Modernizing Mobility with CharterUP CEO Armir Harris

From digital transformation to evolving customer demands, CharterUP's Armir Harris offers his perspective on the transportation industry's next chapter.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Group announcing BUSES Act
Motorcoachby StaffJune 16, 2026

Bipartisan BUSES Act Seeks Changes to New York City's Bus Idling Enforcement Program

Backed by motorcoach operators, the legislation seeks to balance emissions goals with passenger safety by allowing limited idling for inspections, accessibility needs and extreme weather conditions.

Read More →