METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

10 rail ideas that still matter

Another top 10 list in our 100th Anniversary special section.

by Cliff Henke
May 1, 2004
3 min to read


The history of passenger rail in many ways is not linear. Several times in U.S. history the mode has nearly been abandoned altogether. But rail has survived, and these important breakthroughs made it possible. 1. Electric traction: Frank Sprague’s work in electric traction began in the 19th century, but widespread commercialization of his ideas occurred after the 20th century began. Without electric propulsion, underground metro systems were unpleasant and hazardous. 2. Elevated railroads: Beginning with Chicago and New York, cross-urban rail also went above ground. Though unsightly, they avoided the problems that electric traction obviated. 3. Streetcars: In perhaps a historic quirk, Sprague got his first chance to apply electric propulsion to streetcars, which were horsedrawn and not much faster than walking. The result was an explosion in streetcar systems in the early 20th century Ñ to the point of overcapacity by the mid-1920s. After a long period when community after community ripped out their systems, cities are returning to surface rail transit. Some are bringing back historic streetcars. 4. The first creators of sprawl: While automobiles’ speeds (and subsidies) took the idea much farther, urban sprawl was actually first stimulated by interurban rail lines. Henry Huntington’s Pacific Electric in California and several other systems in the East and Midwest were classic examples. 5. Presidents’ Conference Committee: With the growing challenge of the automobile, the streetcar industry knew it had to modernize its image and efficiency. This committee of streetcar CEOs came up with the PCC car Ñ still the most successful vehicle standardization effort ever. The issues driving the project are just as relevant today. Those responsible for the PCC success were actually committed to adopting their work Ñ and did. 6. Sprague’s second big invention: Locomotive-hauled trains had and still have a drawback: smaller trains are far less economic to operate. Sprague solved this problem with the multiple-unit concept (a non-powered car coupled with a motorized one). Smaller electric traction equipment more readily enabled multiple units. The result revolutionized economies in off-peak periods of rail operation. 7. Digging the subway boom: Beginning with the opening of Boston’s subway in 1897, cities began to take heavily traveled transit corridors underground. With minor exceptions, these have come with hefty public-sector financial commitments, supported in most cases by voter-approved dedicated local taxes. In 1970, Oakland, Calif., became the eighth American city with a rail corridor (BART) at least partly in subway. Today, 15 cities have their rail systems partly in tunnel. The boom inherently is thus as much a political achievement as technological. 8. Computer chips on rails: Beginning with the BART system in the early 1970s, computers became increasingly involved in rail operations. Breakthroughs in power chips made traction power much more reliable with far less electromagnetic interference. By the 1980s, metro systems began to be fully driverless in Europe (see below). If Moore’s Law is true (which holds that computing power doubles every 18 months or so, and conversely, the price of said given power halves about as fast), then we’ll see ever-more affordable rail technology in the future. 9. Technology explosion: Partly related to the previous item, rail transit has undergone an explosion in technology. It has created problems for both the supply chain as well as operational challenges such as recruitment and training of skilled people. Indeed, some call it the greatest challenge to ensuring reliable and cost-effective rail operations. 10. Automated train control: What was once the province of airports in the U.S. has spread to other applications such as urban transit elsewhere. Union advocates foresaw driverless trains as far back as the debates over the first modern transit legislation in 1964. Thanks to some of the above breakthroughs, signaling and train control retrofits now make driverless systems affordable.

Topics:Management
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Management

Reinventing Transit's Digital Future with Luminator's Magnus Friberg
Technologyby Alex RomanJuly 13, 2026

Building the Next Generation of Transit Technology

In this edition of METROspectives, Luminator CEO Magnus Friberg discusses the company's transformation, the growing role of AI and software, and what's next for transit technology.

Read More →
EPA Proposal Targets DEF-Related Engine Derates
Motorcoachby Alex RomanJuly 10, 2026

EPA Proposal to Ease Diesel Emissions Compliance Could Improve Reliability for Motorcoach Operators

The EPA is proposing to remove DEF-related engine derates for new heavy-duty diesel vehicles, a change bus operators say would improve safety and reliability while sparking debate over the future of emissions enforcement.

Read More →
Transit Industry Rallying for Emily DeVito

Act Now to Join Rays the Mark Foundation's Annual Golf Tournament, Fundraiser

This year's tournament honors Emily DeVito, a member of the public transportation family whose story has moved colleagues across the industry — and with only a few foursomes remaining, organizers are encouraging companies and individuals to register soon.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A green and white Rhode Island Public Transit Authority electric bus.

RIPTA Celebrates 60 Years of Public Transit Service

The Rhode Island agency is marking the milestone by highlighting service improvements, mobility initiatives, and its vision for the future of transit.

Read More →
MTA, State and City Leadership Unveil Plan to Build the Fastest, Best Bus System in NYC History
Busby Staff and News ReportsJuly 9, 2026

New York Unveils Sweeping Plan to Modernize City Bus Service

Next Stop: Fast Buses, Better Service identifies 50 priority bus corridors for improvements across the five boroughs and launches the City’s next generation of rapid bus service along five key routes.

Read More →
A VIA bus
Technologyby StaffJuly 9, 2026

San Antonio's VIA Launches Second Year of Data Fellowship Program

The partnership gives Better Futures Scholars hands-on experience with real-world challenges while providing VIA with additional analytical capacity to support key agency priorities.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
STV Advances CTDOT Fleet Electrification
Busby Staff and News ReportsJuly 8, 2026

CTDOT Taps STV for Electric Bus Facility Design

The firm will work with CTDOT and RVT to define the facility layout, operational requirements, and long-term flexibility for RVT’s growing electric fleet.

Read More →
An image of an American flag waving under a bridge in Los Angeles with palm trees in the sunlight.

USDOT Awards $170M for Transit Projects in Latest BUILD Grants

Federal funding will support maintenance facility upgrades and other projects aimed at improving transit safety and reliability across the U.S.

Read More →
A rendering of a passenger train for California's High-Speed Rail project.
Railby StaffJuly 7, 2026

Keolis and SNCF Voyageurs Bring Rail Expertise to California High-Speed Rail

The CDA establishes a collaborative predevelopment partnership intended to evaluate future delivery opportunities through public-private partnership models.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Blue and white graphic with a professional portrait of Nathaniel P. Ford Sr.

Ford to Leave JTA After More Than 10 Years as CEO

He plans to continue his work advancing innovative mobility solutions to improve the quality of life in communities across the nation. He did not announce specific plans.

Read More →