METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Benefits of 13(c) Debated at Senate Hearing

Federal administrators and transit operators disagreed on the necessity of 13(c) during a hearing held in April by the Senate Banking Committee.

June 30, 2000
3 min to read


Federal administrators and transit operators disagreed on the necessity of 13(c) during a hearing held in April by the Senate Banking Committee. The Federal Transit Administration (FTA) and the Amalgamated Transit Union (ATU) expressed the necessity of 13(c) to further protect and preserve the rights of transit workers. "The FTA strongly supports the integration of 13(c) protections and rights into our grant agreements and will continue to work cooperatively with the Department of Labor [DOL] to ensure that these rights are integrated in a timely fashion," said Nuria Fernandez, acting administrator of the FTA. Jim La Sala of the ATU said 13(c)’s function is to prevent transit worker abuse. “It has been a hallmark of the federal transit program that the collective bargaining process maintained through the Section 13(c) transit employee protection program has functioned to enhance stability and service within the industry,” he said. Both Fernandez and La Sala disputed accusations that 13(c) delays grant certification processes and contributes to rising costs. Fernandez said that joint efforts of the FTA, DOL and transit authorities actually sped up the processes and increased the number of final certifications. "Since the issuance of the 1995 guidelines, approximately 97% of the grant applications received an interim or final certification within 60 days," Fernandez said. Before, about 85% of grant applications were certified within a 90-day period. La Sala said the costs of 13(c) programs have been minimal over the last 30 years. Individual employee’s claims during that time total a fraction of the $120 billion to $130 billion distributed by the program since 1964. Lee Gibson, assistant general manager of transit at the Regional Transportation Commission of Clark County, Nev., said 13(c) is no longer necessary to the transit community. "It is a relic of another era and has outlived its usefulness. In fact, I submit that 13(c) stands in the way of the transit industry," he said. "Unlike the situation in 1964, today many states have public sector collective bargaining and labor relations statutes. Further, for the private sector transit employees, traditional labor rights are fully addressed by the National Labor Relations Act," Gibson said. Roger Snoble, president of Dallas Area Rapid Transit (DART), said his primary concern is the sole provider clause within 13(c). He said that such a clause goes against Texan law and prohibits DART from contracting out services for preventative maintenance and other new activities. "This prohibition is in direct contradiction to … the Texas Transportation Code and to the industry’s best business practices," Snoble said. "If, as a result of this evaluation, DART would determine that it would be more economically efficient to contract for new transportation services, the sole provider clause would prohibit DART from doing so." Snoble said that attempts to negotiate the clause out of the 13(c) operating assistance arrangement became futile. In December 1999, ATU and DART concurred that the sole provider clause would be eliminated from the 13(c) arrangement. But in January, ATU changed its mind and reasserted the clause that left DART to decline 13(c) arrangements entirely. Snoble said DART experienced negative financial consequences due to DOL and ATU holding on to 13(c). "It seems that 13(c) has served its purpose and is no longer required to protect transit employees," Snoble said.

Topics:Management

More Management

A black, white, and red SEPTA graphic with text reading "New routes to new places."
Managementby StaffMarch 12, 2026

SEPTA to Launch New Bus Network Redesign in August

The first comprehensive overhaul of SEPTA’s bus network will expand frequent service, add routes, and phase in changes through 2027.

Read More →
A CDTA bus in Albany, New York
Managementby Staff and News ReportsMarch 12, 2026

CDTA Outlines Mobility Vision at 2026 State of the Authority Event

In his first State of CDTA address as CEO, Frank Annicaro highlighted the organization’s continued focus on delivering reliable service, investing in innovation, and strengthening connections across the region.

Read More →
An up close image of WMATA priority seating sticker reminders.
Managementby StaffMarch 11, 2026

WMATA Introduces Priority Seating Reminder Pilot for Metro Riders

The agency is testing floor decals on select railcars to improve awareness of priority seating and support a more accessible transit experience.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Cover photo for Transit Unplugged Episode 400
Managementby StaffMarch 6, 2026

Transit Unplugged Celebrates 400 Episodes

The special episode features an exclusive interview with Mark Miller, president of Constellation Software Inc. and executive chairman of the Volaris Group, who reflects on the podcast's early vision and the importance of creating a platform where transit leaders can share ideas and learn from one another.

Read More →
A recent generation New Flyer Electric Bus
Managementby StaffMarch 4, 2026

NFI Group Officially Opens New Flyer All-Canadian Build Facility in Winnipeg

The CAD facility enables NFI to complete full domestic production of heavy-duty transit vehicles, including zero-emission buses, in Winnipeg for the first time in 15 years.

Read More →
Photo of public transportation system with APTA logo.
Managementby StaffMarch 4, 2026

APTA: Surface Transportation Funding Delivers 5:1 Economic Return, Supports 41,400 Jobs per $1B

The findings provide clear evidence that sustained Federal investment in public transit and passenger rail delivers significant returns for workers, communities, taxpayers, and the U.S. economy, APTA officials said.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A photo of rail tracks in Ottawa, Canada

Building a National Framework for Transit Safety and Consistency

On a recent episode of METROspectives, METRO Magazine’s Executive Editor Alex Roman sat down with Ana-Maria Tomlinson, Director of Strategic & Cross-Sector Programs at the CSA Group, to explore a bold initiative aimed at addressing those challenges: the development of a National Code for Transit and Passenger Rail Systems in Canada.

Read More →
Photo of World Cup soccer ball.
Managementby StaffMarch 3, 2026

FTA Invests $100M to Strengthen Transit for 2026 World Cup

The funding will ensure communities can expand transit options to meet increased demand for services around stadiums.

Read More →
ENC's John Obert
Managementby StaffMarch 3, 2026

ENC Names New VP of Transit Sales

John Obert previously served as regional sales manager for ENC since joining the company in June 2025.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Disabled and senior passengers on a transit vehicle.
Managementby StaffMarch 3, 2026

New 2026 Plan Aims to Expand Transportation Access Across Virginia

Over the next four years during the Spanberger Administration, DRPT will use the plan to prioritize funding for human service transportation projects and programs that reduce barriers, expand access, and promote equitable mobility, said department officials.

Read More →