METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Transit leases with private companies in jeopardy

Congress is reviewing a bill that would outlaw the right of transit agencies to lease equipment to private corporations to earn extra cash.

March 23, 2004
2 min to read


More than a dozen U.S. city and state transit agencies are in limbo pending Senate deliberation on a bill that would block their ability to earn millions of dollars. Under review are deals made when transit systems lease train cars, buses or rail lines to private corporations.

“At a time when these states and localities are strapped for resources — look at California, that’s a good example — it’s unfortunate that this additional resource area looks like it’s going to be shut down,” said Daniel Duff, vice president of government affairs for the American Public Transportation Association (APTA).

Ad Loading...

Transit systems in Atlanta, Los Angeles, Connecticut and New Jersey are among those affected. Fifteen leasing deals averaging more than $3 billion in assets have come to a halt after the U.S. Treasury Department told the Transportation Department to stop approving them. APTA estimates that the deals would have reaped $250 million for transit agencies.

“You can’t tell people, notwithstanding the fact it was legal when you did it, it’s not legal now,” said House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Bill Thomas, R-Calif., to the Associated Press. “A government should never do that.”

Under these type of leases, the transit system retains control over the equipment and receives payment to cover upgrades, while the corporation gets a tax break for the equipment’s depreciated value. Critics have said the deals should stop because they merely provide a tax loophole for corporations.

“The promoters of these deals had a clear indication that their gig would be up sooner or later,” Senate Finance Committee Chairman Charles Grassley, R-Iowa told the AP in an interview.

Topics:Management

More Management

Taking the Guesswork Out of Fleet Replacement
Management•by Alex Roman•October 14, 2026

Utilimarc Launches SmartReplace to Optimize Fleet Replacement Decisions

AI-powered SmartReplace helps fleets prioritize vehicle replacements, model budget scenarios, and build more defensible long-term strategies.

Read More →
A group of 2026 APTA Award recipients pose onstage with medals and trophies in front of a large APTA Awards backdrop during the awards ceremony.
Management•by Staff and News Reports•October 12, 2026

APTA Honors 2026 Award Winners, Hall of Fame Inductees at TRANSform & EXPO

Innovations in autonomous and zero-emission transportation, standout transit systems, and industry leadership took center stage among this year's honorees.

Read More →
An orientation for DRPA/PATCO interns.
Management•by Alex Roman•October 9, 2026

7 Ways to Build a Better Transit Internship Program

Lessons from DRPA/PATCO’s approach to creating a meaningful internship experience—and developing the next generation of transportation professionals.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
An overhead view of APTA EXPO's show floor.
Management•by Alex Roman•October 9, 2026

Scenes from APTA TRANSform & EXPO 2026

Transit leaders, manufacturers, and industry professionals gathered in Chicago to explore new technologies, share ideas, and discuss the future of public transportation.

Read More →
Transit Leadership is Broken...Here's Why
Management•by Alex Roman•October 8, 2026

Building Stronger Leaders, More Resilient Transit Teams

Dr. Carol Parker Walsh discusses leadership development, employee retention, workplace culture, and preparing transit’s workforce for AI and automation.

Read More →
Overhead view of the APTA 2026 EXPO show floor at McCormick Place in Chicago, with attendees walking among exhibitor booths and gathering around APTA Central.
Management•by Staff and News Reports•October 5, 2026

APTA 2026 TRANSform & EXPO Kicks Off in Chicago

After 45 years, APTA returns to Chicago with a focus on next-generation fleets, AI, connected transit networks, and the funding strategies shaping public transportation’s future.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
An MTA bus approaches a bus stop on a New York City street as passengers wait on the sidewalk, with a headline about the potential $1 billion impact of federal tariffs on rolling stock costs overlaid on the image.
Management•by Elora Haynes•October 5, 2026

New York MTA Warns Federal Tariffs Could Add $1 Billion to Rolling Stock Costs

The agency said tariffs on specialized imported components could reduce the purchasing power of its $23 billion investment in new subway cars, railcars, and buses.

Read More →
Graphic reading “From the Show Floor: 2026 APTA TRANSform & EXPO” with the APTA event and METRO Magazine logos.
Management•by Staff•October 5, 2026

From the Show Floor: What Happened at APTA TRANSform & EXPO 2026

See the latest product launches, partnerships, technology updates, and transit industry announcements from APTA TRANSform & EXPO in Chicago.

Read More →
A Valley Metro light rail train and bus travel alongside each other in downtown Phoenix.
Management•by Elora Haynes•October 5, 2026

How Valley Metro Is Balancing Transit Growth With the Rider Experience

The APTA award-winning agency is pairing rapid system expansion with investments in workforce, safety, technology, and the fundamentals of transit service.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Management•October 2, 2026

Bus Tech Talk: Keeping Transit Technicians Ahead of the Technology Curve

In this episode of Bus Tech Talk, Complete Coach Works’ Business Development Manager Mark Hollenbeck and METRO’s Executive Editor Alex Roman sit down with Obed Mejia, Senior Technical Trainer for Bus Maintenance, at LA Metro to discuss how rapidly evolving bus technology is changing the maintenance shop — and the skills technicians need to keep pace.

Read More →