METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Report: Competition Key to Revitalizing U.S. Passenger Rail

The report was written by Chapman and Ray Chambers, head of the Association for Innovative Passenger Rail Operations and a Senior Fellow at the Discovery Institute.

August 13, 2025
Report: Competition Key to Revitalizing U.S. Passenger Rail

The authors of the Discovery Institute report propose eight reform goals, including a competitive access model, the separation of infrastructure and operations in the Northeast Corridor, a sustainable federal rail capital fund, and the creation of a national high-speed rail plan. 

Photo: Amtrak

2 min to read


A new report from the Discovery Institute outlines a bold vision for restoring American passenger rail through competition, private sector innovation, and targeted infrastructure investment. 

The report was written by Chapman and Ray Chambers, head of the Association for Innovative Passenger Rail Operations and a Senior Fellow at the Discovery Institute.

Ad Loading...

Report Findings

Titled "Competition Will Put Passenger Rail on the Right Track," the report argues that the time is ripe for meaningful reform. 

With Congressional reauthorization of transportation policy on the horizon and growing interest from private operators like Brightline and Texas Central, the authors propose a Passenger Rail Authority to restructure the national system and open the door for public-private partnerships. 

The authors propose eight reform goals, including a competitive access model, the separation of infrastructure and operations in the Northeast Corridor, a sustainable federal rail capital fund, and the creation of a national high-speed rail plan. They also call for state-level management of short-distance routes and safeguards for labor rights during the transition.

"The future of passenger rail is not about dismantling Amtrak — it's about modernizing it and allowing private innovation to thrive alongside it," said Chambers.

The report highlights successful private rail models such as Brightline in Florida and recommends leveraging infrastructure grants to stimulate further private investment and improve service quality nationwide.

Ad Loading...

About the Discovery Institute

Discovery Institute is a non-profit educational and research organization whose mission is to advance a culture of purpose, creativity, and innovation. It sponsors programs in areas such as economics, education, science and technology, bioethics, and artificial intelligence. 

Bruce Chapman is the founder and board chair of the Discovery Institute and a former member of the Amtrak Reform Council. Ray Chambers is a longtime rail advocate and a Senior Fellow at the Discovery Institute, and leads the Association for Innovative Passenger Rail Operations.

More Rail

An Amtrak Acela train at New York Penn Station
Railby StaffMarch 24, 2026

Transportation Secretary Duffy, Amtrak Announce Progress on New York Penn Station Project

As part of the contract, the AECOM-LiRo NYPennT Joint Venture will work with Amtrak and the selected Master Developer to completely transform Penn Station, improving safety and operational efficiency, making the system more family-friendly, accommodating increased train and passenger capacity, and delivering a world-class experience to its growing passenger base, according to Amtrak officials.

Read More →
A screenshot of ZeroEyes AI gun detection technology.
Railby Staff and News ReportsMarch 24, 2026

ZeroEyes Launches ZeroLink to Expand AI Gun Detection Beyond Traditional Networks

New edge-based solution enables real-time threat detection and situational awareness in remote, mobile, and infrastructure-limited environments.

Read More →
A Chicago rail and rail car in the city.
Railby Staff and News ReportsMarch 23, 2026

Chicago Transit Authority Sues USDOT Over Paused Funding for Red Line Extension, Modernization Projects

The Chicago agency seeks restoration of nearly $2 billion in federal funding, warning halted projects could impact transit access and economic growth.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
GO Transit railcars
Railby StaffMarch 20, 2026

Alstom Awarded 5-Year Extension for GO Transit, UP Express Services

Company officials said that this latest contract extension with Metrolinx consolidates the company’s position as the leading private provider of Operations and maintenance services in North America.

Read More →
A New York MTA subway car with an open gangway
Railby StaffMarch 20, 2026

New York MTA Seeks Bids for 2,390 Subway Cars in Record-Breaking Order

The new cars, model R262, will be funded by the MTA’s 2025-29 Capital Plan, which received a historic $68 billion in funding from Governor Hochul and the State Legislature in the FY26 Enacted State Budget.

Read More →
Graphic from Amtrak promoting the B&P Tunnel Replacement and Frederick Douglass Tunnel project, featuring the Amtrak logo, project title and an illustration of a high-speed train near the West Baltimore MARC Station.
Railby News/Media ReleaseMarch 17, 2026

Amtrak Announces Community Grants for Projects Near Baltimore’s New Frederick Douglass Tunnel

Amtrak will open grant applications March 23 for community projects near the Frederick Douglass Tunnel alignment in Baltimore as part of a $50 million investment tied to the B&P Tunnel Replacement Program.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Amtrak train with logo
Railby StaffMarch 16, 2026

Amtrak Marks Restoration of Two South Carolina Stations

The Denmark Station $2.3 million construction investment project includes a new 280-foot concrete boarding platform, built eight inches above the top of rail, for improved accessibility for passengers with disabilities and families with small children and much more.

Read More →
A view looking down the rail across the new Portal North Bridge.
Railby Staff and News ReportsMarch 13, 2026

NJ Transit, Amtrak Prepare to Open First Track on New Portal North Bridge

The new bridge will begin carrying passenger trains on March 16, replacing a 116-year-old swing bridge that has long caused delays.

Read More →
Caltrain trains on tracks
Railby StaffMarch 6, 2026

Caltrain Adopts Corridor-Wide Right-of-Way Safety Strategy

Caltrain and its partners have implemented safety improvements at specific locations in response to known risk conditions, operational needs, and available funding since the agency’s founding.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A photo of rail tracks in Ottawa, Canada

Building a National Framework for Transit Safety and Consistency

On a recent episode of METROspectives, METRO Magazine’s Executive Editor Alex Roman sat down with Ana-Maria Tomlinson, Director of Strategic & Cross-Sector Programs at the CSA Group, to explore a bold initiative aimed at addressing those challenges: the development of a National Code for Transit and Passenger Rail Systems in Canada.

Read More →