METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Feds finally see housing connection

A new task force will develop federal housing affordability measures that include housing, transportation and other costs that affect location choices.

by Cliff Henke
April 21, 2009
3 min to read


For years, experts in the U.S. transit industry have touted the connection between public transport and economic development. A number of studies have documented it, and some developers have made a lot of money in properties around rail (and in a few cases, bus) stations. Little wonder, as several studies have shown that the average working U.S. household spends nearly 60 percent of its monthly expenses on housing and transportation costs, and the highest rates of foreclosures and upside-down mortgages are in the edges of metropolitan areas where higher gas prices have hiked commute costs the most. Now policymakers seem to have gotten the connection.

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Secretary Shaun Donovan and U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) Secretary Ray LaHood announced a new interagency task force to help stimulate transit-oriented development (TOD).

Ad Loading...

Importantly, the two department heads said that the task force will set a goal to have every major metropolitan area in the country conduct integrated housing, transportation, and land use planning and investment in the next four years. To help meet this laudable goal, HUD will make planning grants through its proposed Sustainable Communities Initiative in consultation with DOT to metropolitan areas, and create mechanisms to ensure those plans are carried through to localities. For its part, DOT will encourage MPOs to conduct the same integrated planning as a part of their next long-range transportation plan update and will provide technical assistance on “scenario planning,” a tool for assessing future growth alternatives that better coordinates land use and transportation.

Beyond the coordination and grant money, you may ask: Don’t these departments really already require similar planning processes? Yes, but what will be supposedly different is coordination. The announcement mentioned the synchronization of planning cycles, processes and geographic coverage with which these mandates operate.

Another new focus is on transparency. The task force will develop federal housing affordability measures that include housing, transportation costs and other costs that affect location choices. Currently, federal housing affordability definitions fail to recognize transportation costs on homeowners and renters, especially those who live farther away from their jobs. The task force will redefine affordability to reflect these interdependent costs and create online tools to help people calculate these combined costs when choosing a new home. By doing so, the task force intends to encourage “location efficiency” in housing and transportation choices, something that HUD has been funding in pilot mortgage programs for years.

This is long overdue, and rail transit stands to be a big winner. Households now pay on average at least 25 percent of their income on car ownership and operation versus less than 5 percent a century ago, according to Center for Transit Oriented Development data. Nor is it great for the environment. According to a new Brookings Institution study, car-dependent households emit three times the climate change gases, as a walkable urban household with good access to transit.

Topics:Rail
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Rail

Transit Reaches 200 Agency Partnerships, Expands Rider Experience Tools
Technology•by Alex Roman•November 6, 2026

Transit Expands Agency Partnerships, Reaching 200 Official App Partners

COO Jake Sion discusses Transit’s growth, the success of its Transit Royale program, and how technology is helping agencies improve the rider experience.

Read More →
A rendering of Trinity Metro's future station at the Medical Center
Rail•by Alex Roman•October 30, 2026

Trinity Metro Breaks Ground on $270M TEXRail Extension

The 2.1-mile extension will connect Fort Worth’s Medical District and Near Southside to downtown, surrounding communities, and Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport.

Read More →
Austin Light Rail rendering from UT perspective
Rail•by Alex Roman•October 30, 2026

Bringing Austin’s First Light Rail System to Life

Austin Transit Partnership CEO Greg Canally discusses the city's nearly 10-mile light rail project, its collaborative approach to project delivery, the importance of community engagement, and the milestones ahead as construction approaches in 2027.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Two Metra locomotives on rail tracks.
Rail•by Alex Roman•October 29, 2026

Metra Draft Plan Outlines Costs, Service Improvements for Regional Rail

The Systemwide Network Plan identifies infrastructure needs and potential investments to expand all-day, bidirectional rail service across the Chicago region.

Read More →
METRO Magazine graphic featuring railroad tracks and switches inside a dark tunnel with the headline “Amtrak Completes First Street Tunnel Upgrades, Restores Service.”
Rail•by Elora Haynes•October 29, 2026

Amtrak Completes First Street Tunnel Upgrades, Restores Service

The nine-day construction project included replacing aging track infrastructure and modernizing switch systems near Washington Union Station.

Read More →
FRA Invests $2.3B in Rail Projects Nationwide
Rail•by Alex Roman•October 28, 2026

FRA Announces $2.3B for Passenger, Freight Rail Projects Nationwide

The CRISI Grant Program funding will support rail infrastructure improvements, safety upgrades, and projects aimed at improving freight and passenger rail service across 45 states and Washington, D.C.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A Caltrain electric railcar on the tracks
Rail•by Alex Roman•October 27, 2026

Caltrain’s Electrification Drives a New Era of Ridership Growth

The railroad’s shift to electric service has brought more frequent trains, stronger customer satisfaction, and increased ridership, earning it APTA’s Outstanding Public Transportation System award.

Read More →
METRO Magazine graphic featuring a dark blue background with abstract curved lines and the headline “FTA Advances $164M Broward County Commuter Rail Project.”
Rail•by Staff and News Reports•October 26, 2026

FTA Advances $164M Broward County Commuter Rail Project

The proposed 10.5-mile commuter rail extension would connect Fort Lauderdale and Aventura, expanding passenger rail options in South Florida.

Read More →
An A line MTA subway car near the soon to be replaced signaling system.
Rail•by Staff and News Reports•October 23, 2026

New York MTA Launches Historic $1.9B Signal, Track Modernization Project

Funded in part by congestion pricing revenue, the project will replace nearly century-old signals along the A and C lines in Brooklyn and Queens.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
The LA Metro San Fernando Valley light rail extension corridor
Rail•by Alex Roman•October 20, 2026

LA Metro Breaks Ground on East San Fernando Valley Light Rail Project

The 6.7-mile line will add 11 stations along Van Nuys Boulevard, expand access to jobs and regional transit connections, and support Metro’s broader efforts to improve mobility as rail ridership grows.

Read More →