METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

The business case for a gas tax increase gets stronger

Most private business groups, including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, support a gas tax increase, because they see the dire need for more U.S. transportation investment.

by Frank Di Giacomo, Publisher
November 16, 2011
2 min to read


For years now, politicians, including our current president, have avoided an increase in the federal gasoline tax as a way to pay for needed spending on more transportation projects. Fortunately for him and the country, there is an opportunity this November, and another one before January 2013, to cut a deal on a gas tax increase combined with transportation investment, tax reform and reducing the deficit. He should do so as soon as possible.

You will know by the time you get this whether he tried to get this deal, and whether he got it. By law, the 12-member, bipartisan joint Senate and House deficit commission was to have submitted its plan by November 23, and the Congress is to pass it a month later. There is no roadmap to tell them how to get there except that the committee and Congress needs to get another $1.5 trillion in deficit cuts over the next 10 fiscal years, as scored by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. If they don't, mandatory cuts of $1.2 trillion over the same period kick in, half in domestic programs (including transportation) and half in defense, so they have an incentive to do a deal.

Experts, business groups support tax
Most private business groups, including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, support a gas tax increase, because they see the dire need for more U.S. transportation investment. So does even the American Trucking Association, whose members would be more directly affected by higher fuel taxes than just about any other industry.

Ad Loading...

Revenues have always been the sticking point in a six-year authorization bill. The Highway Trust Fund is just too small to support the $400 billion or more of investment that's really needed for economic growth. Even Ronald Reagan saw this connection in 1982, when the Mass Transit Account was created.

The only groups not in favor are most members of Congress, the president and a majority of the public. Yet no one has asked whether they would accept a gas tax hike if it meant greater transportation investment and was combined with other tax re-form. At the state and local levels, voters have approved transportation-related tax increases more than 70% of the time, even during the current recession and in conservative states.

Get it done
In theory, the president and Congress have a little longer than this year to cut this deal. The cuts would kick in as law on Jan. 15, 2012, if the "super committee's" recommendations have not been enacted. The Office of Management and Budget then has until Jan. 2, 2013, when it must issue the cut-spending orders to departments and agencies. Regardless, it's time to do this deal as soon as possible.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Bus

Busby Alex RomanSeptember 11, 2026

New York MTA Plans Largest Bus Fleet Upgrade in More Than a Decade

The agency is seeking manufacturers for 650 new CNG buses to replace aging vehicles, improve reliability, and advance its broader fleet modernization strategy.

Read More →
How BAE Systems Electrifies Transit Fleets
Zero Emissionsby Alex RomanSeptember 10, 2026

Building a Flexible Path to Transit Electrification

John Hroncich discusses BAE Systems’ modular and scalable approach, lessons learned from decades of real-world operations, and how agencies can identify electrification strategies that fit their fleets.

Read More →
Bus Tech Talk: Transit Tech Training...What's Changed?
Busby Alex RomanSeptember 4, 2026

Bus Tech Talk: Keeping Transit Technicians Ahead of the Technology Curve

LA Metro’s Obed Mejia discusses technician training, evolving maintenance technology, fleet replacement, and strategies for getting the most out of today’s transit fleets.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
RIPTA, APTA, and federal officials at the launch of the agency's new Frontrunner vehicles
Technologyby Alex RomanSeptember 4, 2026

Biz Briefs: RIPTA Unveils New Frontrunners, Clevland RTA Adds New Siemens, and More

In METRO's latest installment, we take a look at recent news from Siemens, Prevost, Dodge, and more partnerships making headlines across the transportation sector.

Read More →
Holly Arnold
Managementby Alex RomanSeptember 2, 2026

People Movement: Holly Arnold Joins Transdev and More

In this edition, we also cover recent appointments and announcements at Pace, CamTran, MCI, and more, showcasing the individuals helping to shape the future of transportation.

Read More →
A man in a blue suit stands at a clear podium.
Busby Elora HaynesAugust 26, 2026

The High Cost of Transit Buses: Industry Leaders Look to Procurement Reform

Transit leaders and policymakers examine how standardized bus designs, streamlined procurement, and predictable funding could help agencies stretch budgets and deliver better service.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Ray Melleady and industry leaders on Capitol Hill
Managementby Alex RomanAugust 24, 2026

The Business Voice Behind Public Transportation

As chair of APTA’s Business Members Board of Governors, Ray Melleady explains how more than 850 business members are partnering with transit agencies to advance funding, innovation, and industry-wide collaboration.

Read More →
METROspectives: The Overlooked Issues Holding Bus Operators Back
Managementby Alex RomanAugust 21, 2026

From Surviving to Thriving: Building Stronger Transportation Organizations

Bus Business Consultants founder Brian Dickson shares lessons on leadership, organizational health, and creating options for long-term success in a changing transportation industry.

Read More →
Finding the Right Balance: Optimizing Transit Maintenance
ManagementAugust 14, 2026

Finding the ‘Happy Medium’: Optimizing Maintenance Without Sacrificing Reliability

The key to maintenance optimization isn’t doing less work—it’s doing the right work at the right time on the right assets.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
AI Powers Bus Lane Enforcement
Technologyby Alex RomanAugust 12, 2026

LA Metro, City of West Hollywood, and Partners Advance Smarter Bus Lane Enforcement

The award-winning partnership combines AI-powered detection with human oversight to improve bus reliability, accessibility, and enforcement efficiency.

Read More →