Could Technology Allow Uber to Displace Public Transportation?
The Uber website proudly states that, “Uber is evolving the way the world moves. By seamlessly connecting riders to drivers through our apps, we make cities more accessible, opening up more possibilities for riders and more business for drivers. From our founding in 2009 to our launches in over 200 cities today, Uber's rapidly expanding global presence continues to bring people and their cities closer.” Such hype is common on corporate websites, but when the braggadocio is backed up by an article in the Wall Street Journal that discloses a valuation of $41 billion their ambitious words take on relevance.
Jim Holm・President, The InterAgency/Insurance Partners
The Uber website proudly states that, “Uber is evolving the way the world moves. By seamlessly connecting riders to drivers through our apps, we make cities more accessible, opening up more possibilities for riders and more business for drivers. From our founding in 2009 to our launches in over 200 cities today, Uber's rapidly expanding global presence continues to bring people and their cities closer.”
Such hype is common on corporate websites, but when the braggadocio is backed up by an article in the Wall Street Journal that discloses a valuation of $41 billion their ambitious words take on relevance.
Ad Loading...
Six years ago it seemed impossible for an upstart company to disrupt a highly regulated taxi industry, but that has all but been accomplished.
Now Uber has announced Uber Pool. The concept of Uber Pool is simple. They’re going to reduce expenses for the rider by introducing ride-sharing. The Uber driver picks up a rider. Then the pick up additional riders (along with additional fees) while dropping off riders at their requested locations.
Sounds a lot like a bus making its way through a route.
Given enough Uber cars on the road, would there be a need for city shuttles or buses, except for those unable to pay the Uber fares?
Does such a disruption sound improbable? Uber Pool is already running in San Francisco, Paris and New York. The company has reported riders are developing habitual behavior using the same route five days a week. Regulators are already on alert citing possible violations.
Ad Loading...
That probably won’t faze Uber. As an observer of the insurance industry, I haven’t been a big fan of Uber’s tendency to seemingly disregard regulation and their ability to use civic arguments to generate free publicity and an advantage over their competitors.
The financial world clearly supports Uber, lining up to pour what seems to be an unlimited amount of investment to support Uber’s growth.
The money keeps coming despite the fact that Uber has been hit with a multitude of class action lawsuits claiming:
Uber drivers have been misclassified as independent contractors.
Uber passengers have been misled by claims that the $1 safe rides fee is warranted because their background checks were “industry leaders.”
Uber drivers are being exploited.
Uber discriminates against the blind, charges bogus fares and has violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
This is only a partial list, but makes you wonder if founder Travis Kalanick deserves his reputation as Darth Vader.
Ad Loading...
Uber has used a variety of methods to flummox regulators into negotiating new rules for Transportation Network Companies (TNCs). It would be extremely shortsighted to assume that the current bus and shuttle regulations will protect the integrity of those industries any more than they have the taxis.
The public seems to have a strong stomach when it comes to riding in cars with questionable insurance, being driven by people with little or no relevant training, who have been subjected to questionable background checks.
The people who use Uber are so enamored with the company that they willingly agree to Terms and Conditions that don’t hold Uber accountable for virtually anything and require the rider to indemnify Uber for possible legal expense.
It’s doubtful that bus riders who have the wherewithal to use Uber will display much loyalty to a public bus service that is impartial and much needed, by many. Give some thought to the culture surrounding the Uber experience.
Polis comprises cities and regions, as well as corporate partners, from across Europe, promoting the development and implementation of sustainable mobility. This year’s event had over a thousand attendees across various policy forums and an exhibition.
Across North America and beyond, transit agency officials are contending with a perfect storm of operational headaches and strategic challenges that hamper daily service and long-term progress.
Simply incentivizing electrification is not enough to make a meaningful impact; we must shift our focus toward prioritizing public transportation and infrastructure.
For many years, the narrative surrounding public transit improvements has been heavily weighted toward environmental gains and carbon reduction. While these are undeniably crucial long-term benefits, the immediate focus of this new funding environment is firmly on demonstrable system efficiencies and a clear return on investment.
The notion of agencies being over- or underfunded, I argued, doesn’t hold up. If an agency wants to turn up the heat — to grow beyond the status quo — it must demonstrate measurable value.
Some agencies might suggest they are funded in the public transportation space. Some complain that they are funded too little. I have never heard a public transportation executive proclaim that they are funded too much. And if no public agencies are funded too much, then, by definition, none are funded too little. To steal from Goldilocks’ thinking, they are all funded just right.
From East Asia to Europe, more than 400 exhibitors and 70 sessions tackled global mobility challenges — highlighting AI, automation, and urban transit equity in the race toward a carbon-free future.
A closer look at ridership trends, demographic shifts, and the broader impacts of service reductions reveals why maintaining, and even improving, bus service levels should be a top priority in 2025.