METRO Magazine Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

How to Ensure New Mobility Services Make City Life Better, Not Worse

A recent headline in the Chicago Tribune read: “Driverless cars may make traffic worse, not better.”

Michael Cottle
Michael CottleVP, Sales & Customer Success, Bestmile
Read Michael's Posts
May 23, 2018
How to Ensure New Mobility Services Make City Life Better, Not Worse

New mobility services like ridehailing, micro-transit and autonomous taxis and shuttles (shown) can be integrated and deployed with minimal new infrastructure investment. Photo: Bestmile

4 min to read


New mobility services like ridehailing, micro-transit and autonomous taxis and shuttles (shown) can be integrated and deployed with minimal new infrastructure investment. Photo: Bestmile

A recent headline in the Chicago Tribune read: “Driverless cars may make traffic worse, not better.” The same week, the BBC ran a story titled, “How the internet is clogging up city streets.”

Both articles question some of the conventional wisdom suggesting that new mobility services will ease congestion and pollution by creating a seamless path from home to office and back, and anywhere in between in comfortable, shared, zero-emission vehicles.

Transportation planners have noted the only thing worse than streets clogged with single-occupant vehicles would be streets clogged with additional fleets of zero-occupant vehicles. Meaning if we simply add robotaxis to the current mix of public and private transit options, we could indeed see congestion worsen in city centers.

While autonomous cars enjoy increasing attention in the media, the focus has been mainly on the vehicles. Vehicles alone don’t constitute services. How can these vehicles, along with ridehailing and public transit services, be coordinated and optimized to create and deliver services that people love and that reduce traffic and pollution?

Ad Loading...

What will be badly needed...is an overarching mobility management system that coordinates services, connecting travelers with the right vehicle at the right time in the right destination...

What will be badly needed to ensure that the conventional wisdom prevails — that new mobility services will make urban transit more convenient and boost the quality of urban living — is an overarching mobility management system that coordinates services, connecting travelers with the right vehicle at the right time in the right destination within the service area, pooling as many as possible, and managing vehicle locations based on demand. Because vehicles and their guidance technologies are all being designed independently of one another, this management solution must be “vehicle-agnostic,” able to communicate with and deliver instructions to vehicles of different brands or makes. It will also, in the near term, need to be able to communicate with human-driven services to ensure mixed fleets are coordinated.

A useful analogy for what is needed might be the air traffic control employed by airports around the world. Each airline uses different vehicles and technologies, sometimes with different brands and types of vehicles within the same fleet. They all communicate with a single management center that serves as the brain of the service, guiding vehicles to ensure that traffic is smooth, safe, and efficient.

It will be important for new mobility services to easily integrate with transit systems to enable operators to get new services up and running quickly, and coordinate with other modes of transit in the network.

Most transit networks already have massive management centers with sophisticated management tools. It will be important for new mobility services to easily integrate with transit systems to enable operators to get new services up and running quickly, and coordinate with other modes of transit in the network. This is important because new mobility services will be complementary to current transit modes, solving first/last mile limitations, making conventional services more convenient for commuters, and for intra-city transit. Microtransit — shared, human-driven cars, or vans — for example, can pool travelers with similar destinations at train and bus stations and take them to their homes or offices.

Cities around the world are expected to grow significantly in coming decades. Most cannot add more roads to make mobility easier. Large public transit infrastructure projects like new rail lines are expensive and take years to plan and build. New mobility services like ridehailing, micro-transit and autonomous taxis and shuttles can be integrated and deployed with minimal new infrastructure investment, reducing the use of private cars, increasing the use of public transit, and making cities more livable to residents, commuters and visitors.

For transportation to get smarter, new public and private entrants will need to be able to easily integrate into and communicate with other modes of transit.

Many have noted that cities will need to get smarter in order to grow in ways that improve the quality of life of the people that live, work, and travel within them. Cities will need smarter buildings, utilities, and transportation. For transportation to get smarter, new public and private entrants will need to be able to easily integrate into and communicate with other modes of transit. Synchronizing as many modes of mobility as possible — including new mobility services — can optimize efficiency and provide a seamless user experience. This has the potential to make getting in and out of cities and getting around town so convenient that  people will gladly leave their cars at home, or exit private car ownership entirely, delivering on the promise to reduce pollution and congestion.

Michael Cottle has more than 25 years of working with public and private transit organizations. Currently he is the VP of Sales and Customer Service at Bestmile, maker of a mobility services platform for autonomous and human-driven vehicles and services.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Blogposts

Transit Dispatchesby Dan Verbsky January 26, 2026

How Digital Signage is Reshaping the Traveler Experience at Transportation Hubs

What was once a landscape of static signs has evolved into a responsive, immersive environment powered by real-time visual communication.

Read More →
Transit Dispatchesby Giles BaileyDecember 19, 2025

Latest Trends in Urban Mobility from Polis Conference 2025

Polis comprises cities and regions, as well as corporate partners, from across Europe, promoting the development and implementation of sustainable mobility. This year’s event had over a thousand attendees across various policy forums and an exhibition.

Read More →
Transit Dispatchesby Timothy MenardOctober 29, 2025

Why Transit Leaders Require Better Tools for Operational Clarity In Today’s Tech-Fragmented Environment

Across North America and beyond, transit agency officials are contending with a perfect storm of operational headaches and strategic challenges that hamper daily service and long-term progress.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Transit Dispatchesby Colin Parent October 22, 2025

The Powerless Brokers: Why California Can’t Build Transit

It is no secret that transit in the U.S. is slow and expensive to build.

Read More →
Transit Dispatchesby Anna AllwrightSeptember 24, 2025

Why Transport Sustainability Should Focus on People Instead of Cars

Simply incentivizing electrification is not enough to make a meaningful impact; we must shift our focus toward prioritizing public transportation and infrastructure.

Read More →
Transit Dispatchesby Timothy MenardSeptember 2, 2025

Transit ROI & System Efficiencies Will Drive 'Big, Beautiful' Transit Funding

For many years, the narrative surrounding public transit improvements has been heavily weighted toward environmental gains and carbon reduction. While these are undeniably crucial long-term benefits, the immediate focus of this new funding environment is firmly on demonstrable system efficiencies and a clear return on investment.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Transit Dispatchesby Mark R. AeschAugust 12, 2025

Getting Better on Purpose

The notion of agencies being over- or underfunded, I argued, doesn’t hold up. If an agency wants to turn up the heat — to grow beyond the status quo — it must demonstrate measurable value.

Read More →
Transit Dispatchesby Mark R. AeschJuly 15, 2025

The Fiscal Lessons of Goldilocks

Some agencies might suggest they are funded in the public transportation space. Some complain that they are funded too little. I have never heard a public transportation executive proclaim that they are funded too much. And if no public agencies are funded too much, then, by definition, none are funded too little. To steal from Goldilocks’ thinking, they are all funded just right.

Read More →
Transit Dispatchesby Giles BaileyJuly 1, 2025

UITP Congress Charts the Next Era of Public Transport

From East Asia to Europe, more than 400 exhibitors and 70 sessions tackled global mobility challenges — highlighting AI, automation, and urban transit equity in the race toward a carbon-free future.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Transit Dispatchesby Laramie Bowron June 25, 2025

Why Bus Service Cuts Should Be the Last Resort for Transit Agencies

A closer look at ridership trends, demographic shifts, and the broader impacts of service reductions reveals why maintaining, and even improving, bus service levels should be a top priority in 2025.

Read More →
Ad Loading...